TL;DR
This paper introduces REGR, a novel generative replay framework for reinforcement learning that uses a "novelty-tilted" distribution to generate more informative and dynamically plausible synthetic experiences. This approach effectively balances exploration of unseen states with maintaining realistic transitions, leading to more robust and stable learning compared to existing methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Reinforcement learning (RL) agents learn by interacting with an environment and storing these experiences in a replay buffer. To improve learning efficiency and exploration, researchers have explored using generative models to create synthetic experiences. While these generative replay methods can synthesize novel transitions, a key challenge is balancing two competing goals: encouraging exploration of new, potentially rewarding states, and ensuring the generated transitions are "dynamically plausible" – meaning they adhere to the environment's underlying physics and rules. Existing methods that use conditional generative models often struggle with this trade-off. If they prioritize novelty too much, they can generate unrealistic transitions that destabilize the learning process. Conversely, if they prioritize plausibility, they might not explore enough. This paper aims to solve this by proposing a principled way to generate synthetic experiences that are both novel and realistic, leading to more robust RL agent performance.
Methods
The core of REGR lies in its approach to generating synthetic transitions. Instead of directly conditioning a generative model on a novelty score (which can be tricky to tune), REGR defines a "novelty-tilted" target distribution. This distribution is created by taking a pre-trained diffusion model (which models the real replay buffer's distribution) and tilting it towards regions of higher novelty, controlled by an inverse temperature parameter $\beta$.
To sample from this novelty-tilted distribution, REGR employs a technique called Relative Trajectory Balance (RTB). This method fine-tunes the diffusion model to directly approximate the tilted distribution, avoiding the need for explicit guidance signals that can be problematic. The novelty itself is measured using standard intrinsic reward functions like Curiosity or Random Network Distillation (RND).
The overall REGR framework involves:
- Pre-training a diffusion model: This model learns the distribution of real experiences from the replay buffer.
- Fine-tuning the diffusion model: Using the RTB objective and a novelty function, the model is adapted to generate samples from the novelty-tilted distribution.
- Synthesizing and replaying: The fine-tuned diffusion model generates a batch of novel transitions, which are then added to a synthetic replay buffer. The RL agent then trains on a mixture of real and synthetic experiences.
Datasets
The paper evaluates REGR on standard continuous control benchmarks from the DeepMind Control suite (e.g., cheetah-run, reacher-hard, quadruped-walk) and OpenAI Gym (e.g., HalfCheetah, Hopper, Walker2d). It also includes a sparse-reward environment, finger-turn-hard, to specifically test exploration capabilities. No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Novelty-tilted distribution as a principled trade-off: The core idea of defining a target distribution that is a "tilted" version of the real data distribution, incorporating novelty, offers a more robust way to balance exploration and plausibility than direct conditional guidance.
- Fine-tuning diffusion models with RTB is key: Instead of relying on potentially unstable classifier-free guidance, fine-tuning the diffusion model directly to match the target distribution using RTB proves to be more effective and stable.
- Generative replay can be robust: The experiments demonstrate that with the right approach, generative replay can significantly improve RL performance, especially in challenging sparse-reward environments, without introducing excessive training instability.
- Agnostic to novelty function: REGR works with different novelty measures (Curiosity, RND), suggesting its core mechanism is generalizable.
Key Results
- REGR consistently outperforms prior generative replay baselines (SER and PGR) across various continuous control tasks, achieving higher average returns. For instance, in the MuJoCo-100K HalfCheetah environment, REGR achieved a mean return of 7390.86 ± 592.30, significantly higher than PGR (6286.16 ± 981.34) and SER (6221.22 ± 256.28).
- REGR also shows improved state coverage (measured by state entropy) compared to baselines, indicating more effective exploration of the state space.
- The method demonstrates robustness to novelty functions and base RL algorithms (SAC and TD3).
- REGR maintains high dynamic plausibility of generated samples, with dynamic MSE comparable to SER and lower than PGR, contributing to training stability.
- Analysis of Q-bias shows REGR exhibits more stable training compared to PGR, which can suffer from extreme bias.
Limitations and Future Work
- Computational cost: Training diffusion models from scratch multiple times and sampling large batches of transitions can be computationally expensive.
- Reusing trained models: The authors suggest future work could explore lightweight frameworks that reuse trained models from previous rounds or accelerate sampling through one-step generative modeling.
- Hyperparameter sensitivity: While REGR is generally robust, the paper notes that PGR can be susceptible to hyperparameter choices, implying that fine-tuning REGR's own hyperparameters (like $\beta$) might still be necessary for optimal performance in some cases.
Summary updated