Robust Cooperative Load Frequency Control for Enhancing Wind Energy Integration in Multi-Area Power Systems

Zhijian Hu, Kun Zhang, Rong Su, Ruiping WangIEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a robust cooperative Load Frequency Control (LFC) strategy for multi-area power systems with high wind energy penetration. It combines a Model Predictive Control (MPC) with an improved Event-Triggered Scheme (ETS) for wind turbine control and a novel LFC model that accounts for system parameter shifts, ensuring grid stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of wind energy into power grids presents a significant challenge: wind power is intermittent and can cause frequency instability due to rapid fluctuations in generation. This instability arises from the inherent lack of physical inertia in wind turbines compared to traditional synchronous generators. Furthermore, the fluctuating nature of wind power can shift the system's steady-state operating point, rendering traditional LFC models, which are typically linearized around a single operating point, inaccurate. Existing control strategies often struggle to effectively manage these challenges, especially in multi-area power systems where coordinated control is crucial.

Methods

The paper proposes a hierarchical control approach:

  • Low-Level Wind Turbine Control:
    • Model Predictive Control (MPC): Used for tracking the rated wind power output of individual wind turbines. MPC is chosen for its ability to handle constraints and optimize control actions over a finite horizon.
  • Improved Event-Triggered Scheme (ETS): To reduce the computational burden of MPC, an enhanced ETS is introduced. Unlike traditional ETSs that rely on the difference between current and the most recent signal, this improved version considers multiple historical signals. This helps trigger control actions at critical points (crests/troughs) of system responses and avoids unnecessary triggers from minor disturbances.
  • High-Level Cooperative LFC:
    • Robust Performance Index: A robust performance index is incorporated into the control synthesis to effectively suppress the impact of intermittent wind power on frequency stability.
  • Improved Small-Signal LFC Model: To address the issue of shifting operating points, the traditional small-signal LFC model is augmented with an uncertain but bounded matrix. This allows the model to better represent variations in system parameters caused by wind power fluctuations, enhancing its applicability to real-world scenarios.
  • Cooperative Output Feedback Controller: A controller is designed to achieve cooperative control across multiple areas, utilizing both local and neighboring area information.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a simulated four-area power system with parameters provided in the text and tables.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hierarchical Control is Key: A multi-layered approach, separating wind turbine control from overall grid frequency control, is effective for managing complex systems with high renewable penetration.
  • ETS for Efficiency: The improved ETS significantly reduces computational load without sacrificing control performance, making MPC more practical for real-time applications, especially on resource-constrained devices.
  • Modeling for Reality: Accounting for the dynamic shift in operating points due to wind power is crucial for accurate LFC. The proposed uncertain matrix in the LFC model is a significant improvement over static models.
  • Robustness Matters: Incorporating robust control principles is essential to guarantee system stability in the face of unpredictable wind power fluctuations.

Key Results

  • The proposed robust cooperative LFC strategy effectively maintains system frequency within acceptable limits (±0.2Hz) even with high wind energy penetration (200MW per area).
  • The improved ETS demonstrated significant reduction in computational burden, allowing the controller to remain idle for extended periods (up to 17 seconds) without compromising performance.
  • Simulations showed that the proposed approach significantly outperforms traditional PI controllers and controllers based on standard small-signal LFC models in terms of frequency deviation amplitude.
  • The controller also demonstrated robustness against communication delays between different areas.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Burden of MPC: While the ETS helps, MPC inherently has a computational cost. The paper focuses on reducing this but doesn't eliminate it.
  • Parameter Uncertainty Handling: The paper introduces an uncertain matrix to model parameter variations. Further research could explore more sophisticated methods for identifying or adapting to these uncertainties in real-time.
  • Communication Delays: While the study considers communication delays, the modeling of these delays is simplified. More complex and realistic delay models could be investigated.
  • Real-World Implementation: The study is based on simulations. Future work could focus on experimental validation and implementation on actual power systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The wind energy, as a kind of renewable energy resources, has the potential to replace traditional fossil fuels. However, its intermittent power output can incur frequency instability due to the instantaneous unbalance between power generation and load demand. To smooth the penetration of wind energy, this paper presents a robust cooperative load frequency control (LFC) strategy for multi-area power systems, which is a hierarchical control approach. For the low-level wind turbine control, this paper adopts model predictive control (MPC) method to achieve the rated wind power tracking. In the meantime, an improved event-triggered scheme (ETS) considering multiple historic released signals is employed to relieve the computational burden of MPC. For the high-level cooperative LFC, this paper incorporates the robust performance index in the control synthesis to suppress the impact of intermittent wind power on frequency stability. In addition, to address the underlying shift of the steady-state operating point caused by the intermittent wind power supply, this paper improves the commonly used small-signal LFC model by adding an uncertain matrix, which reasonably explains the possible change of system parameters and extends the applicability of the traditional LFC model. Simulations are done on a four-area power system, and the results verify the efficacy of the presented event-triggered scheme and the robust cooperative LFC approach.Note to Practitioners—To promote the penetration of wind energy into power systems, this work explores a robust cooperative LFC approach under multi-agent structure to ensure the stability of the system, aiming at extending the applicability of existing approaches. The proposed approach is hierarchical. At the rated wind power tracking level, the MPC is employed to handle constraints associated with actuating devices, such as heterogeneous convertors. Simultaneously, an improved ETS considering multiple historic triggered signals is integrated in the MPC to reduce the computational burden. At the power system level, the robust performance index is incorporated in the control design to smooth the impacts of intermittent wind power on frequency stability. Additionally, the study accounts for the potential shift of the steady-state operating point and improves the traditional small-signal LFC model by adding an uncertain matrix, which can better explain the variation of system parameters and is more applicable in practical power system engineering. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed robust cooperative LFC approach can effectively maintain the system frequency within the admissible range under the high penetration of wind energy, whereas the traditional PI controller falls short in this regard.
BibTeX
@article{hu2024robust,
  author = {Zhijian Hu and Kun Zhang and Rong Su and Ruiping Wang},
  title = {{Robust Cooperative Load Frequency Control for Enhancing Wind Energy Integration in Multi-Area Power Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tase.2024.3367030},
}
Figure