Robust Bayesian variable selection for gene-environment interactions

Jie Ren, Zhou Fei, Xiaoxi Li, Shuangge Ma, Yu Jiang, Cen WuarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

This paper presents a significant advancement in the field of computational biology and statistics by introducing a robust Bayesian framework for identifying gene-environment (G×E) interactions.

TL;DR

The authors develop RBSG-SS, a fully Bayesian robust variable selection method that handles outliers and heavy-tailed data in gene-environment interaction studies. By combining robust regression with bi-level "spike-and-slab" priors, the method accurately identifies both important genetic groups and specific interaction effects, outperforming existing non-robust and frequentist alternatives.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding complex diseases requires deciphering how our genes (G) interact with our environment (E). However, analyzing these interactions is statistically challenging. Genetic data is high-dimensional, and phenotypic traits (like weight or tumor thickness) often contain "contaminated" data—outliers or heavy-tailed distributions that violate the assumptions of standard linear models.

While frequentist regularization methods (like robust LASSO) exist, they often struggle with uncertainty quantification. Conversely, existing Bayesian methods for G×E studies haven't adequately addressed robustness. There is a specific need for "bi-level" selection: the ability to determine if a genetic variant is relevant at all (group level) and, if so, whether its importance comes from its main effect, its interaction with the environment, or both (individual level).

Methods

The authors propose Robust Bayesian Sparse Group Selection with Spike-and-Slab priors (RBSG-SS). Key components include:

  • Robustness via LAD Regression: Instead of minimizing squared errors (which over-weights outliers), the model uses Least Absolute Deviation (LAD) regression. In a Bayesian context, this is modeled using a Laplace distribution for the error terms.
  • Bi-level Spike-and-Slab Priors: This is the core innovation. They impose hierarchical priors that act as "on/off" switches.
  • The group-level prior determines if a whole genetic variant (main + interactions) is included.
  • The individual-level prior determines which specific components within that group are active.
  • Unlike Laplacian shrinkage (LASSO), these priors allow unimportant effects to be shrunk to exactly zero in the posterior distribution.
  • Efficient Computation: The authors utilize a location-scale mixture representation of the Laplace distribution, allowing them to develop a fast Gibbs sampler for posterior inference.
  • Software: The method is implemented in the C++ based R package roben, available on CRAN.

Datasets

The researchers evaluated their method using:

  1. Extensive Simulations: Six different error distributions were tested, ranging from standard Normal to highly problematic Cauchy and LogNormal distributions.
  2. Nurses’ Health Study (NHS): A dataset of 1,732 subjects and 35,099 SNPs, focusing on the relationship between obesity (weight) and environmental factors like physical activity and diet.
  3. TCGA Melanoma (SKCM): Gene expression data from 294 subjects, using (log-transformed) Breslow’s depth—a measure of tumor thickness—as the response variable.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Necessity of Bi-level Sparsity: The paper demonstrates that robust group selection alone (RBG-SS) leads to high false-positive rates because it forces all interactions in a "relevant" group to be non-zero. RBSG-SS solves this by allowing within-group sparsity.
  • Robustness is Non-Negotiable: In the presence of heavy-tailed noise (like the Cauchy distribution), non-robust Bayesian methods (BSG-SS) fail significantly, showing much lower true-positive rates and higher prediction errors.
  • Biological Plausibility: In the NHS data, the model identified genes like DOCK1 and NRG3. DOCK1 was found to interact with physical activity, aligning with its known role in obesity-related pathways.

Key Results

  • Simulation Superiority: In scenarios with contaminated data (e.g., mixture Laplace errors), RBSG-SS identified ~21 true positives with only ~1.5 false positives. In contrast, its closest robust competitor without within-group sparsity (RBG-SS) identified ~25 true positives but at the cost of ~30 false positives.
  • Better Prediction: In the TCGA melanoma study, RBSG-SS achieved a Prediction Mean Absolute Deviation (PMAD) of 0.69, notably better than the individual-level-only robust method (RBL-SS) at 0.83.
  • Convergence: The authors used Potential Scale Reduction Factors (PSRF) to demonstrate that their MCMC chains converge reliably within 15,000 iterations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current work focuses primarily on robustness regarding the response variable (the phenotype). They suggest that future research should explore:

  • Robustness against outliers in the predictors (the genetic and environmental factors themselves).
  • Handling general model misspecification.
  • Extending the framework to semiparametric G×E studies where interaction effects might be non-linear.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gene-environment (G$\times$E) interactions have important implications to elucidate the etiology of complex diseases beyond the main genetic and environmental effects. Outliers and data contamination in disease phenotypes of G$\times$E studies have been commonly encountered, leading to the development of a broad spectrum of robust regularization methods. Nevertheless, within the Bayesian framework, the issue has not been taken care of in existing studies. We develop a fully Bayesian robust variable selection method for G$\times$E interaction studies. The proposed Bayesian method can effectively accommodate heavy-tailed errors and outliers in the response variable while conducting variable selection by accounting for structural sparsity. In particular, for the robust sparse group selection, the spike-and-slab priors have been imposed on both individual and group levels to identify important main and interaction effects robustly. An efficient Gibbs sampler has been developed to facilitate fast computation. Extensive simulation studies and analysis of both the diabetes data with SNP measurements from the Nurses' Health Study and TCGA melanoma data with gene expression measurements demonstrate the superior performance of the proposed method over multiple competing alternatives.
BibTeX
@misc{ren2020robust,
  author = {Jie Ren and Zhou Fei and Xiaoxi Li and Shuangge Ma and Yu Jiang and Cen Wu},
  title = {{Robust Bayesian variable selection for gene-environment interactions}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2006.05455},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.05455},
}
Figure