Robust and Incremental Robot Learning by Imitation

Roberto CapobiancoDWAI@AI*IA 2014 · OpenReview

Abstract

Learning by Imitation (LbI) is a powerful paradigm for robot programming, yet it often relies on the assumption of a single perfect teacher and a "blank slate" start for every new task. This paper presents a framework for robust and incremental LbI. By clustering demonstrations from multiple teachers and segmenting them into a reusable motion library, robots can handle conflicting strategies and build a hierarchy of skills. The approach bridges low-level control with high-level symbolic planning, facilitating autonomous skill synthesis.

Introduction

The goal of Learning by Imitation (LbI) is to enable robots to acquire new skills by observing and mimicking demonstrations. This process involves answering four fundamental questions: who to imitate, when to imitate, what to imitate, and how to imitate. While significant progress has been made, most existing systems operate under idealized conditions that limit their real-world applicability.

The conceptual dimensions of Learning by Imitation, categorizing the challenges into Who, When, What, and How.

Problem Definition

Current LbI research faces two primary hurdles:

  1. The Single-Teacher Assumption: Most models assume a single, perfect human teacher. In practice, robots may receive demonstrations from various sources—multiple humans, other robots, or even biological agents—leading to conflicting strategies that simple averaging cannot resolve.
  2. The Tabula-Rasa Problem: Robots typically start learning each new task from a "blank slate." This lack of incremental learning prevents the accumulation of knowledge and the ability to reuse sub-skills, making the acquisition of complex, multi-stage tasks highly inefficient.

Proposed Methodology: A Robust and Incremental Pipeline

To overcome these limitations, we propose a hybrid methodology that integrates low-level trajectory control with high-level task planning. The pipeline processes demonstrations through several key stages:

1. Strategy Clustering and Segmentation

Rather than treating variations in demonstrations as noise, the system clusters them into distinct strategies. This preserves the validity of different approaches to the same task (e.g., different ways to grasp an object). These clusters are then segmented into primitive motions.

The proposed pipeline: Demonstrations from multiple teachers are clustered, segmented, and transformed into a library of learned controllers and Dynamic Movement Primitives (DMPs).

2. Skill Encoding and the Motion Library

Each segment is analyzed using Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) to extract the underlying intent or reward function. These are encoded as Dynamic Movement Primitives (DMPs), which provide robust execution capable of handling environmental perturbations. These skills are stored in a "motion library," allowing the robot to identify and reuse known sub-skills in new tasks, thereby reducing learning redundancy.

3. Hierarchical Planning

For complex tasks, the system employs Hierarchical Task Networks (HTN). This allows the robot to sequence sub-skills from its library to achieve high-level goals, effectively bridging the gap between numerical sensor data and symbolic logic.

Validation Strategy

The proposed framework is designed for validation on both simulated (V-REP, Webots) and real-world platforms. The primary hardware target is the KUKA Youbot, an omnidirectional mobile manipulator. Testing focuses on industrial-like scenarios, such as those found in the RoCKIn@Work benchmarks, involving tasks like door opening, object manipulation, and navigating dynamic environments.

Discussion and Future Work

A significant insight of this work is the concept of "strategy co-activation," where non-conflicting sub-skills can be activated simultaneously based on task priority. Furthermore, the move toward bio-inspired learning suggests that robots could learn efficient movement patterns from non-human agents.

However, several challenges remain. The "correspondence problem"—mapping teacher movements to a robot's specific embodiment—is a persistent difficulty. Additionally, as the motion library scales, efficient real-time skill selection becomes a computational bottleneck. Future research will focus on refining the numerical-symbolic interface and conducting extensive physical experiments to demonstrate the framework's robustness in diverse settings.

Conclusion

By moving beyond the "blank slate" and embracing the complexity of multi-teacher environments, this framework provides a foundation for robots that can learn incrementally and robustly. This approach not only improves learning efficiency but also brings us closer to robots that can be naturally taught and adapted by non-expert users in everyday environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{capobianco2014robust,
  author = {Roberto Capobianco},
  title = {{Robust and Incremental Robot Learning by Imitation}},
  booktitle = {DWAI@AI*IA},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4Ypwg0HJzV},
}
Figure