Robot Shape and Location Retention in Video Generation Using Diffusion Models

Peng Wang, Zhihao Guo, Abdul Latheef Sait, Minh Huy PhamarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Generating high-fidelity synthetic video data for safety-critical robotics tasks, such as human-robot collision detection, is hindered by the tendency of generative models to produce structural artifacts. This paper introduces a diffusion-based video generation model that leverages robot pose data and semantic masks to ensure physical integrity and spatial accuracy. By incorporating these constraints into a ConvNext-based architecture, the model effectively prevents "broken" robot limbs and unrealistic positional drift. Experimental results across various robotic morphologies demonstrate significant improvements in structural similarity and location retention over state-of-the-art baselines.

Introduction: The Challenge of Structural Common Sense

Generative models, particularly Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs), have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in visual synthesis. However, they often lack "structural common sense," leading to artifacts where moving objects lose their physical coherence. In the context of robotics, a standard model might generate a video where a robot's arm becomes detached or its base drifts unrealistically between frames.

Comparison between the original robot arm and the 'broken arm' artifact common in standard generative models.

For human-robot collaboration research, these inaccuracies are critical. Training collision detection algorithms requires high-quality data of "near-misses"—scenarios that are dangerous and ethically complex to capture in the real world. Synthetic data offers a solution, but only if the generated robot maintains precise shape and location consistency.

Methodology: Enforcing Consistency via Pose and Masks

The proposed framework extends the DDPM architecture with two primary innovations designed to enforce structural constraints:

  1. Robot Pose Embedding: The model incorporates real-time telemetry from the Robot Operating System (ROS). By embedding the robot’s pose difference (translation and rotation) directly into the network blocks, the model is explicitly guided on the robot's intended spatial coordinates.
  2. Semantic Mask Regulation (SPADE): To preserve the robot's morphology, the authors utilize semantic masks. These masks are processed through a Spatially-Adaptive Normalization (SPADE) module integrated within a ConvNext backbone. This regulation ensures that generated pixels strictly adhere to the defined physical boundaries of the robot.
Overview of the proposed architecture featuring ConvNext blocks, pose embeddings, and semantic mask inputs.

The choice of a ConvNext backbone over the traditional UNet provides greater computational efficiency and reduces the risk of overfitting when training on specialized, smaller-scale robotic datasets.

Experimental Setup

The model was evaluated using three distinct datasets captured at 24 fps (downsampled to 1 fps to highlight motion):

  • Scene I: A Turtlebot Waffle Pi in a controlled laboratory.
  • Scene II: A Turtlebot in a cluttered, complex environment.
  • Scene III: An industrial collaborative robot (cobot) with complex joint movements.

Performance was benchmarked against SinFusion, a leading model for single-video diffusion.

Key Results and Insights

The study highlights that traditional metrics like Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR) are often insufficient for robotics, as they may overlook critical structural failures if the background is well-reconstructed. Instead, the authors emphasize Structural Similarity (SSIM), Intersection over Union (IoU) for location accuracy, and Hu Moments for shape consistency.

Quantitative Performance

The researchers tested three variants: Ours-Mask-Pose, Ours-Mask, and Ours-Pose.

  • Structural Fidelity: In Scene III, the benchmark model frequently exhibited the "broken arm" problem. In contrast, the Ours-Mask-Pose variant maintained the arm's integrity throughout the sequence.
  • Accuracy: The Ours-Mask-Pose model achieved the highest SSIM and IoU scores across all scenes, confirming its superior ability to preserve both visual quality and coordinate precision.
  • Efficiency: While mask regulation increased training time (from ~3.7 to ~6 hours on an Nvidia A100), the Ours-Pose variant provided significant gains in location retention with negligible overhead compared to the benchmark.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research demonstrates that integrating physical constraints—specifically pose and semantic masks—into diffusion models significantly enhances the utility of synthetic video for robotics. While the current work is limited by resolution ($256 \times 144$) and focuses on single-robot scenes, it establishes a foundation for generating reliable training data for human-robot interaction. Future work will explore scaling to higher resolutions and validating the synthetic data by training and testing collision detection models in real-world environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2024robot,
  author = {Peng Wang and Zhihao Guo and Abdul Latheef Sait and Minh Huy Pham},
  title = {{Robot Shape and Location Retention in Video Generation Using Diffusion Models}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.02873},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02873},
}
Figure