Roadmap on STIRAP applications

K. Bergmann, Hanns‐Christoph Nägerl, Cristian D. Panda, G. Gabrielse, Eduard Miloglyadov, Martin Qüack, Georg Seyfang, Gunther Wichmann, Silke Ospelkaus, Axel Kuhn, Stefano Longhi, Alexander Szameit, Philipp Pirro, B. Hillebrands, Xue‐Feng Zhu, Jie Zhu, Michael Drewsen, W. K. Hensinger, Sebastian Weidt, Thomas Halfmann, Hai-Lin Wang, G. S. Paraoanu, Nikolay V. Vitanov, J. Mompart, Thomas Busch, Timothy Barnum, David Grimes, Robert W. Field, Mark G. Raizen, Edvardas Narevicius, Marcis Auzinsh, Dmitry Budker, Adriana Pálffy, Christoph H. KeitelJournal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper is a comprehensive roadmap detailing the diverse applications of Stimulated Raman Adiabatic Passage (STIRAP), a powerful laser-based technique for efficient population transfer. It highlights STIRAP's evolution from its origins in chemical dynamics to its widespread adoption across atomic, molecular, solid-state, and even nuclear physics, showcasing its crucial role in quantum information processing and fundamental scientific discovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of efficiently and selectively transferring quantum populations between states, a fundamental requirement for many advanced scientific and technological applications. While STIRAP was initially developed for chemical dynamics, its unique properties – particularly its ability to avoid spontaneous emission from an intermediate state and maintain coherence – have made it a versatile tool for a much broader range of fields. The paper aims to consolidate and showcase these diverse applications, demonstrating STIRAP's impact and potential across physics and chemistry.

Methods

The core method discussed is Stimulated Raman Adiabatic Passage (STIRAP). This technique utilizes two laser pulses (pump and Stokes) to transfer population between two quantum states (e.g., |1> and |3>) via an intermediate state (|2>). The key to STIRAP's success lies in its adiabatic nature, where the laser pulses are carefully shaped to ensure that the system adiabatically follows a "dark state" that avoids populating the intermediate state, thus preventing spontaneous emission and maintaining coherence. The paper also discusses variations and extensions of STIRAP, such as fractional STIRAP (for creating superpositions), spatial adiabatic passage (SAP) for matter waves, and STIRAP in conjunction with other techniques like composite pulses and shortcuts to adiabaticity for enhanced robustness and speed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • STIRAP's Versatility: The most striking insight is the sheer breadth of STIRAP's applicability, extending far beyond its initial domain in chemical dynamics to encompass molecules, photons, ions, solid-state systems, and even nuclear physics.
  • Coherence and Robustness: STIRAP's ability to maintain quantum coherence and its inherent robustness against experimental imperfections are key drivers for its adoption in sensitive quantum information processing tasks.
  • Beyond Simple Transfer: STIRAP is not just for complete population transfer; variations like fractional STIRAP enable the creation of coherent superpositions, crucial for quantum computing.
  • Bridging Classical and Quantum: STIRAP principles are being applied to classical wave phenomena like light, magnons, and acoustic waves, highlighting fundamental analogies in wave control.
  • Enabling Quantum Technologies: STIRAP is presented as a foundational technique for various quantum technologies, including quantum computing, quantum networking, and precision measurements.

Key Results

The paper is a roadmap and review, not a single experimental study, so it doesn't present a single set of quantitative results. However, it highlights numerous successful applications:

  • Ultracold Molecules: STIRAP achieves >90% efficiency in transferring Feshbach molecules to their absolute ground state.
  • Electron EDM Measurement: STIRAP has significantly improved the precision of electron electric dipole moment measurements, achieving a factor of 12 signal increase.
  • Quantum Information: STIRAP is used to create high-fidelity single-qubit gates with fidelities around 95% and is being explored for multi-qubit entangled states.
  • Solid-State Systems: STIRAP is employed for quantum memory protocols in rare-earth ion doped crystals and for optical spin control in NV centers.
  • Superconducting Circuits: STIRAP has been used to create Fock states with fidelities up to 89% and is being explored for quantum processing.
  • Nuclear Physics: Theoretical studies suggest STIRAP could enable efficient nuclear isomer depletion and control, with potential efficiencies up to 100% under ideal conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Adiabaticity Requirements: Achieving 100% transfer efficiency often requires high laser intensity or long interaction times, which can be challenging due to decoherence.
  • Spectral Linewidth: Strict spectral linewidth requirements are necessary for adiabaticity, demanding smooth laser intensity variations.
  • Frequency Chirp: Chirped laser pulses can be detrimental unless carefully compensated.
  • High Energy Level Density: Molecules with dense energy levels can lead to Stark shifts that disrupt two-photon resonance.
  • UV/VUV Limitations: Lack of transform-limited pulses in the UV/VUV region hinders applications.
  • Scalability: Implementing STIRAP in large-scale quantum systems (e.g., networks of cavities, many ions) remains a significant challenge.
  • Non-Hermitian Systems: Extending STIRAP to systems with gain and loss (non-Hermitian) is an unexplored but promising area.
  • Nuclear STIRAP Challenges: Achieving STIRAP in nuclear physics requires high-intensity, coherent X-ray sources and precise control over ion beams, which are experimentally demanding.
  • Future Work: The paper points to ongoing research in developing more robust STIRAP protocols (e.g., composite pulses, shortcuts to adiabaticity), improving laser technology, exploring new intermediary states, and applying STIRAP to novel systems like plasmonic waveguides and molecular ions. The development of quantum memories, advanced quantum computing architectures, and precision measurements are highlighted as key future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract STIRAP (stimulated Raman adiabatic passage) is a powerful laser-based method, usually involving two photons, for efficient and selective transfer of populations between quantum states. A particularly interesting feature is the fact that the coupling between the initial and the final quantum states is via an intermediate state, even though the lifetime of the latter can be much shorter than the interaction time with the laser radiation. Nevertheless, spontaneous emission from the intermediate state is prevented by quantum interference. Maintaining the coherence between the initial and final state throughout the transfer process is crucial. STIRAP was initially developed with applications in chemical dynamics in mind. That is why the original paper of 1990 was published in The Journal of Chemical Physics . However, from about the year 2000, the unique capabilities of STIRAP and its robustness with respect to small variations in some experimental parameters stimulated many researchers to apply the scheme to a variety of other fields of physics. The successes of these efforts are documented in this collection of articles. In Part A the experimental success of STIRAP in manipulating or controlling molecules, photons, ions or even quantum systems in a solid-state environment is documented. After a brief introduction to the basic physics of STIRAP, the central role of the method in the formation of ultracold molecules is discussed, followed by a presentation of how precision experiments (measurement of the upper limit of the electric dipole moment of the electron or detecting the consequences of parity violation in chiral molecules) or chemical dynamics studies at ultralow temperatures benefit from STIRAP. Next comes the STIRAP-based control of photons in cavities followed by a group of three contributions which highlight the potential of the STIRAP concept in classical physics by presenting data on the transfer of waves (photonic, magnonic and phononic) between respective waveguides. The works on ions or ion strings discuss options for applications, e.g. in quantum information. Finally, the success of STIRAP in the controlled manipulation of quantum states in solid-state systems, which are usually hostile towards coherent processes, is presented, dealing with data storage in rare-earth ion doped crystals and in nitrogen vacancy (NV) centers or even in superconducting quantum circuits. The works on ions and those involving solid-state systems emphasize the relevance of the results for quantum information protocols. Part B deals with theoretical work, including further concepts relevant to quantum information or invoking STIRAP for the manipulation of matter waves. The subsequent articles discuss the experiments underway to demonstrate the potential of STIRAP for populating otherwise inaccessible high-lying Rydberg states of molecules, or controlling and cooling the translational motion of particles in a molecular beam or the polarization of angular-momentum states. The series of articles concludes with a more speculative application of STIRAP in nuclear physics, which, if suitable radiation fields become available, could lead to spectacular results.
BibTeX
@article{bergmann2019roadmap,
  author = {K. Bergmann and Hanns‐Christoph Nägerl and Cristian D. Panda and G. Gabrielse and Eduard Miloglyadov and Martin Qüack and Georg Seyfang and Gunther Wichmann and Silke Ospelkaus and Axel Kuhn and Stefano Longhi and Alexander Szameit and Philipp Pirro and B. Hillebrands and Xue‐Feng Zhu and Jie Zhu and Michael Drewsen and W. K. Hensinger and Sebastian Weidt and Thomas Halfmann and Hai-Lin Wang and G. S. Paraoanu and Nikolay V. Vitanov and J. Mompart and Thomas Busch and Timothy Barnum and David Grimes and Robert W. Field and Mark G. Raizen and Edvardas Narevicius and Marcis Auzinsh and Dmitry Budker and Adriana Pálffy and Christoph H. Keitel},
  title = {{Roadmap on STIRAP applications}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1088/1361-6455/ab3995},
}
Figure