RNA secondary structure ensemble mapping in a living cell identifies conserved RNA regulatory switches and thermometers

Ivana Borovská, Chundan Zhang, Edoardo Morandi, Daphne A. L. van den Homberg, Michael T. Wolfinger, Willem A. Velema, Danny IncarnatobioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first transcriptome-wide map of RNA secondary structure ensembles within living E. coli cells, revealing a complex landscape of dynamic RNA structures. They developed a new framework to identify conserved RNA regulatory switches and discovered novel temperature-sensitive RNA elements (thermometers) that control gene expression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

RNA molecules are not static; they can adopt multiple, dynamic structures that are crucial for their function, particularly in regulating gene expression. However, comprehensively mapping these structural ensembles within a living cell has been a major challenge. Previous studies often focused on a single dominant RNA structure, missing the nuances of dynamic conformational changes. This limits our understanding of how RNA molecules fine-tune cellular processes and respond to environmental cues.

Methods

The researchers employed a technique called DMS-MaPseq (Dimethyl sulfate-Mutational Profiling and Sequencing). This method uses a chemical probe (DMS) to modify unpaired RNA bases within living cells. By sequencing the resulting cDNA, they can infer which bases were accessible (unpaired) and thus map RNA structures.

The core innovation is their DRACO algorithm, which can deconvolute the chemical probing data to not just identify a single structure, but to estimate the ensemble of different conformations an RNA molecule adopts and their relative abundances. They combined this with DeConStruct, a framework that uses evolutionary conservation analysis (looking for similar structures across related bacterial species) to prioritize functionally relevant RNA structures.

Datasets

The study utilized in vivo chemical probing data from two strains of Escherichia coli (DH5α and TOP10) under normal growth conditions (37°C) and after cold shock (10°C). They also generated in vitro refolded RNA data for comparison. The analysis covered the entire E. coli transcriptome, focusing on regions with sufficient sequencing coverage.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RNA is more dynamic than we thought: The study reveals that a significant portion of the E. coli transcriptome exists as a mixture of RNA structures, not just a single conformation.
  • Structural heterogeneity is conserved: Regions with multiple conformations are often more conserved across bacterial species, suggesting their functional importance.
  • Cold shock dramatically reshuffles RNA structures: Temperature changes induce widespread and significant rearrangements of RNA ensembles, impacting gene expression.
  • Novel RNA thermometers discovered: The researchers identified several new RNA elements in the 5' UTRs of genes that act as "thermometers," switching their structure to control translation in response to temperature.
  • Chaperones play a role in RNA structure dynamics: The study highlights the involvement of chaperones (like CspE) in regulating the structural transitions of certain RNAs, particularly for lpxP.

Key Results

  • They generated the first transcriptome-scale maps of RNA secondary structure ensembles in a living cell.
  • Approximately 16.6% of the analyzed bases in E. coli were found to populate two or more conformations.
  • Regions with multiple conformations were significantly more conserved across bacterial genomes (p-value: 2.8e-57).
  • Cold shock at 10°C led to a nearly twofold increase in the proportion of bases populating two or more conformations compared to 37°C.
  • They identified and characterized several novel RNA thermometers, including those in the 5' UTRs of cspG, cspI, cpxP, and lpxP mRNAs.
  • The lpxP thermometer was shown to be a chaperone-dependent switch, regulated by CspE.

Limitations and Future Work

  • DMS limitations: The chemical probe DMS primarily modifies A and C bases, potentially missing structurally dynamic regions that are A/C-poor. Future work could use newer probing methods that target all four nucleotides.
  • Interconversion rates: The study assumes that RNA structures must interconvert at a rate slower than the probing experiment for ensemble deconvolution. Transition barrier analysis suggests high energy barriers for interconversion, implying that chaperone-mediated processes are likely involved in dynamic structural changes.
  • Conservative estimate: The identified set of structurally heterogeneous regions is likely an underestimate due to various factors in the analysis pipeline.
  • Broader implications: The findings challenge the traditional view of the cold shock response and suggest a more intricate mechanism involving widespread RNA structural reorganization. This work provides a valuable resource for discovering new regulatory RNA switches and could inform the development of RNA-targeted therapeutics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract RNA molecules can populate ensembles of alternative structural conformations, but comprehensively mapping RNA conformational landscapes within living cells presents significant challenges and has, as such, so far remained elusive. Here, we generated the first transcriptome-scale maps of RNA secondary structure ensembles in a living cell, using Escherichia coli as a model. Our analysis uncovered features of structurally-dynamic regions, as well as the existence of hundreds of highly-conserved bacterial RNA structural elements. Conditional structure mapping revealed extensive restructuring of RNA ensembles during cold shock, leading to the discovery of several novel RNA thermometers in the 5′ UTRs of the cspG, cspI, cpxP and lpxP mRNAs. We mechanistically characterized how these thermometers switch structure in response to cold shock and revealed the cspE chaperone-mediated regulation of lpxP . Collectively, this work reveals a previously unappreciated complexity of RNA structural dynamics in living cells, and it provides a key resource to significantly accelerate the discovery of regulatory RNA switches.
BibTeX
@misc{borovska2024rna,
  author = {Ivana Borovská and Chundan Zhang and Edoardo Morandi and Daphne A. L. van den Homberg and Michael T. Wolfinger and Willem A. Velema and Danny Incarnato},
  title = {{RNA secondary structure ensemble mapping in a living cell identifies conserved RNA regulatory switches and thermometers}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.09.16.613214},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure