RLS Recovery with Asymmetric Penalty: Fundamental Limits and Algorithmic Approaches

Ali Bereyhi, Mohammad Ali Sedaghat, Ralf R. MüllerarXiv 2018 · arXiv

Abstract

In signal processing and compressed sensing, recovering signals with non-identical distributions—such as those with time-varying sparsity—presents a significant challenge for standard Regularized Least Squares (RLS) methods. This paper provides a theoretical and algorithmic framework for signal recovery using RLS with asymmetric penalties. By employing the "replica method" from statistical physics, we derive a systematic approach to optimally tune recovery algorithms, specifically Approximate Message Passing (AMP), to achieve minimum distortion. Our results demonstrate that acknowledging signal asymmetry through tailored penalties significantly improves recovery performance in large-scale systems.

Introduction

The reconstruction of a signal $x$ from noisy, underdetermined measurements $y = Ax + z$ is a cornerstone of compressed sensing. Conventional RLS approaches, such as LASSO, typically employ symmetric penalties, assuming independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) signal components. However, real-world signals often exhibit "asymmetry," where statistical properties like sparsity vary across different segments of the signal. In such cases, uniform penalties lead to sub-optimal recovery.

This paper addresses two primary challenges:

  1. Performance Characterization: Predicting the error (distortion) of an RLS estimator with an asymmetric penalty in the large-system limit.
  2. Algorithmic Tuning: Establishing a systematic method for choosing free parameters, such as the regularization weight $\lambda$, when the signal is non-uniform.

Methodology

The authors utilize a combination of information theory and statistical mechanics to analyze the recovery problem in high-dimensional settings.

The Replica Method

Originating from the study of spin glasses, the replica method is used to analyze the "large-system limit" where the number of samples $N$ goes to infinity. This method reveals a decoupling property, showing that a complex high-dimensional recovery problem behaves like a collection of independent scalar problems affected by "effective noise." This insight allows researchers to predict the performance of a massive system by solving single-variable equations.

Generalized Approximate Message Passing (GAMP)

The recovery is implemented using the GAMP framework, an iterative algorithm known for its efficiency in high-dimensional linear inverse problems. To optimize performance, the authors propose a heuristic tuning strategy based on the analytical results of the replica method. By finding the parameters that minimize the predicted asymptotic distortion, the algorithm can be systematically optimized for various signal types.

Complex-Valued Extension

While previous research often focused on real-valued signals, this work extends performance characterization to complex-valued settings, which are essential for modern wireless communication systems.

Results and Discussion

The proposed framework was evaluated using synthetic non-uniform sparse signals and Binary Phase Shift Keying (BPSK) signals. The latter serves as a benchmark to ensure consistency with existing literature.

Error probability ($P_E$, blue curves/left axis) and optimal tunable factor ($\\lambda^*$, orange curves/right axis) as functions of SNR ($1/\\sigma^2$) for varying compression ratios $\\rho$.

Key findings include:

  • Theoretical Consistency: The framework successfully recovers known results for BPSK recovery, validating the replica-based approach.
  • Optimal Performance: As shown in Figure 1, the error probability ($P_E$) varies predictably with the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) and compression ratio ($\rho$). The systematic tuning strategy allows for the identification of optimal parameters ($\lambda^*$) for any given noise level, providing a clear roadmap for practical implementation.
  • Efficiency: The asymmetric RLS approach maintains linear complexity via AMP-based algorithms, making it viable for real-time applications in large-scale systems.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work demonstrates that asymmetry in signal statistics is an opportunity rather than a hindrance. By applying asymmetric penalties and utilizing a systematic tuning strategy derived from the replica method, significant improvements in recovery accuracy can be achieved.

While the replica method relies on certain mathematical conjectures and the results are asymptotic (most accurate for large $N$), the framework provides a robust foundation for engineering high-performance recovery systems. Future research may apply this systematic approach to a wider variety of large-scale RLS problems in machine learning and communications where the assumption of signal uniformity fails.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper studies regularized least square recovery of signals whose samples' prior distributions are nonidentical, e.g., signals with time-variant sparsity. For this model, Bayesian framework suggests to regularize the least squares term with an asymmetric penalty. We investigate this problem in two respects: First, we characterize the asymptotic performance via the replica method and then discuss algorithmic approaches to the problem. Invoking the asymptotic characterization of the performance, we propose a tuning strategy to optimally tune the algorithmic approaches for recovery. To demonstrate applications of the results, the particular example of BPSK recovery is investigated and the efficiency of the proposed strategy is depicted in the shadow of results available in the literature
BibTeX
@misc{bereyhi2018rls,
  author = {Ali Bereyhi and Mohammad Ali Sedaghat and Ralf R. Müller},
  title = {{RLS Recovery with Asymmetric Penalty: Fundamental Limits and Algorithmic Approaches}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1805.11895},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.11895},
}
Figure