River loads of suspended solids, nitrogen, phosphorus and herbicides delivered to the Great Barrier Reef lagoon

Frederieke J. Kroon, Petra Kuhnert, Brent Henderson, Scott Wilkinson, Anne Henderson, Brett N. Abbott, Jon Brodie, Ryan TurnerMarine 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the significant increase in riverine loads of suspended solids, nutrients, and herbicides delivered to the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) lagoon since European settlement. These findings are crucial for understanding coastal ecosystem degradation and informing effective management strategies to protect this iconic natural wonder.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal ecosystems worldwide are facing degradation due to increased land-based runoff of pollutants. The Great Barrier Reef (GBR) lagoon, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is particularly vulnerable. While it's understood that human activities like land clearing, agriculture, and urbanization have increased pollutant loads, a comprehensive, basin-wide quantification of these changes for key pollutants in the GBR catchment has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by estimating the historical (pre-European) and current riverine loads of suspended solids, nitrogen, phosphorus, and herbicides across all 35 GBR basins, providing a critical baseline for assessing the impact of these changes and setting future management targets.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-pronged approach to estimate river pollutant loads. They combined existing catchment modeling (SedNet/ANNEX) with new analyses of monitoring data.

  • Catchment Modeling (SedNet/ANNEX): This approach models the sources, stores, and fluxes of sediment, nitrogen, and phosphorus within river networks. It accounts for various erosion processes and nutrient delivery mechanisms, providing estimates for both pre-European and current conditions.
  • Monitoring Data Analysis (Loads Regression Estimator - LRE): For basins with sufficient monitoring data, the LRE methodology was used. This statistical approach models the relationship between river flow and pollutant concentration to estimate annual loads and their uncertainties.
  • Area Correction Factors: Since monitoring stations are often located upstream of river mouths, "area correction factors" were calculated. These factors, derived from SedNet modeling, adjust the monitored loads to represent the total load delivered to the coast, accounting for additional pollutant sources and sinks downstream of the gauge.
  • Anthropogenic Load Calculation: The anthropogenic load for each pollutant and basin was determined by subtracting the estimated pre-European load from the current load.

The study also involved a rigorous assessment of the representativeness of monitoring data, using criteria related to flow range and maximum flow sampled, to ensure the reliability of the LRE estimates.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive compilation of existing data and modeling outputs:

  • Catchment Modeling Data: Pre-European and current load estimates from SedNet/ANNEX modeling were sourced from various studies (e.g., McKergow et al., Cogle et al., Armour et al.).
  • Monitoring Data: Extensive water quality and flow data were collated from three Queensland government monitoring programs (SWAN, GBR 15, SMP), the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS), and the Australian Centre for Tropical Freshwater Research (ACTFR).
  • Land Use Mapping: Data from 1999 and 2004 were used to characterize major land uses within the GBR region.
  • Geospatial Data: River network data and Natural Resource Management (NRM) region boundaries were used.

No new datasets were explicitly introduced as benchmarks, but the collation and synthesis of existing data across all GBR basins represent a significant new compilation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Increase in Pollutant Loads: The study confirms a widespread and substantial increase in riverine pollutant loads to the GBR lagoon across nearly all basins since European settlement. This highlights the pervasive impact of human activities on the landscape.
  • Disparate Increases Across Pollutants: While all measured pollutants have increased, the magnitude of increase varies significantly. Phosphorus, in particular, shows a disproportionately high increase (8.9 times), suggesting a strong link to agricultural practices.
  • Importance of Both Modeling and Monitoring: The study effectively demonstrates the value of integrating both process-based modeling (SedNet/ANNEX) and statistical analysis of monitoring data (LRE). This hybrid approach provides a more robust and comprehensive understanding of pollutant loads, especially when data availability varies across basins.
  • Herbicides as a New Concern: The introduction of PSII herbicides, which were absent pre-European settlement, represents a significant new anthropogenic input, posing a novel threat to the GBR ecosystem.
  • Basin-Specific Variability: The significant differences in load increases across the 35 basins underscore the importance of basin-specific management strategies, reflecting diverse land uses, topography, and hydrological characteristics.

Key Results

The study found significant increases in mean-annual river loads to the GBR lagoon:

  • Total Suspended Solids (TSS): Increased by 5.5 times to 17,000 ktonnes/year.
  • Total Nitrogen (TN): Increased by 5.7 times to 80,000 tonnes/year.
  • Total Phosphorus (TP): Increased by 8.9 times to 16,000 tonnes/year.
  • PSII Herbicides: Estimated at 30,000 kg/year, with no pre-European baseline.

The increases varied considerably by basin, with some basins showing more than a 10-fold increase for certain pollutants. For example, the Mary-Burnett basin showed a 11.9x increase in TSS, and the Fitzroy basin showed a 130x increase in PN.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Estimates: While the LRE method provides uncertainty bounds, SedNet/ANNEX estimates do not. The authors acknowledge that future work needs to focus on quantifying uncertainty for all load estimates.
  • Data Gaps and Model Assumptions: The study relied on existing data and models, which have inherent limitations. For instance, the representativeness of monitoring data varied, and some models made simplifying assumptions (e.g., about reservoir effects).
  • Pre-European Load Refinement: The authors suggest that revising pre-European load estimates in parallel with current loads, using updated modeling, is crucial for improving anthropogenic load estimations.
  • Flood Event Underestimation: The study notes that current methods might underestimate loads during flood events, and further research on flood load corrections is recommended.
  • Ecological Risk Assessment: To complement these load estimates, the authors recommend an ecological risk assessment to prioritize pollutants and their sources for management intervention.
  • Climate Change Impacts: The authors point out that current Reef Plan targets may not be sufficient to protect the GBR ecosystem, especially considering predicted environmental changes due to climate change. Developing linked catchment and receiving water models that incorporate climate change scenarios is highlighted as an urgent research need.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kroon2011river,
  author = {Frederieke J. Kroon and Petra Kuhnert and Brent Henderson and Scott Wilkinson and Anne Henderson and Brett N. Abbott and Jon Brodie and Ryan Turner},
  title = {{River loads of suspended solids, nitrogen, phosphorus and herbicides delivered to the Great Barrier Reef lagoon}},
  booktitle = {Marine},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1016/j.marpolbul.2011.10.018},
}
Figure