Risperidone Effects on Brain Dynamic Connectivity—A Prospective Resting-State fMRI Study in Schizophrenia

Kristin K. Lottman, Nina V. Kraguljac, David M. White, Charity J. Morgan, Vince D. Calhoun, Allison Butt, Adrienne C. LahtiFrontiers in Psychiatry 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Resting-state functional connectivity studies in schizophrenia evaluating average connectivity over the entire experiment have reported aberrant network integration, but findings are variable. Examining time-varying (dynamic) functional connectivity may help explain some inconsistencies. We assessed dynamic network connectivity using resting-state functional MRI in patients with schizophrenia, while unmedicated (n = 34), after 1 week (n = 29) and 6 weeks of treatment with risperidone (n = 24), as well as matched controls at baseline (n = 35) and after 6 weeks (n = 19). After identifying 41 independent components (ICs) comprising resting-state networks, sliding window analysis was performed on IC timecourses using an optimal window size validated with linear support vector machines. Windowed correlation matrices were then clustered into three discrete connectivity states (a relatively sparsely connected state, a relatively abundantly connected state, and an intermediately connected state). In unmedicated patients, static connectivity was increased between five pairs of ICs and decreased between two pairs of ICs when compared to controls, dynamic connectivity showed increased connectivity between the thalamus and somatomotor network in one of the three states. State statistics indicated that, in comparison to controls, unmedicated patients had shorter mean dwell times and fraction of time spent in the sparsely connected state, and longer dwell times and fraction of time spent in the intermediately connected state. Risperidone appeared to normalize mean dwell times after 6 weeks, but not fraction of time. Results suggest that static connectivity abnormalities in schizophrenia may partly be related to altered brain network temporal dynamics rather than consistent dysconnectivity within and between functional networks and demonstrate the importance of implementing complementary data analysis techniques.

Introduction

For decades, neuroscientists have characterized schizophrenia as a "disconnection syndrome." However, resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) results have been notoriously inconsistent. This study addresses a key limitation of traditional "static" analysis, which averages brain activity over an entire scan, potentially blurring transient but meaningful connectivity changes. By examining the "chronnectome"—the time-varying connectome—researchers can identify discrete connectivity states that the brain cycles through even at rest.

Furthermore, this study seeks to disentangle disease pathology from medication effects by studying unmedicated patients longitudinally as they begin treatment with the antipsychotic risperidone.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated pipeline to capture temporal dynamics:

  1. Group Independent Component Analysis (GICA): Identified 41 stable brain networks (Independent Components) across all subjects, categorized into seven functional domains.
  2. Sliding Window Analysis: Connectivity was calculated using a 44-second window that moved across the timecourse. This window size was validated using a Linear Support Vector Machine (SVM) to maximize the distinction between patients and controls.
  3. k-means Clustering: Resulting matrices were clustered into three discrete states: State 1 (Sparse/weak connectivity), State 2 (Abundant/strong connectivity), and State 3 (Intermediate connectivity).
  4. Longitudinal Design: The study compared 34 unmedicated patients with schizophrenia against 35 matched healthy controls, with follow-ups at 1 and 6 weeks of risperidone treatment.
Spatial maps of the 41 independent components (ICs) identified via GICA, grouped into functional domains such as Subcortical, Visual, and Auditory.

Results and Key Insights

The "Noisy" Brain and State Dynamics

Healthy controls spent the majority of their time in the "Sparse" state (State 1). In contrast, unmedicated patients exhibited significantly shorter mean dwell times in this state (p = 0.0334) and longer dwell times in the "Intermediate" state (p = 0.0055). This suggests that the schizophrenic brain may be more disorganized or "noisy," struggling to maintain the efficient, low-connectivity baseline seen in healthy individuals.

Static vs. Dynamic Connectivity

While static analysis showed widespread abnormalities, dynamic analysis revealed that hyperconnectivity (specifically between the thalamus and somatomotor network) was confined to a single state. This implies that many "static" abnormalities reported in literature may actually be artifacts of the brain spending disproportionate amounts of time in specific dynamic states.

Static functional connectivity matrices for healthy controls (HC) and patients (SZ) across timepoints, alongside difference maps (F, G) highlighting significant connectivity alterations and treatment effects.

Medication Effects

Risperidone treatment showed a specific temporal effect: after 6 weeks, the dwell time in the Sparse state normalized (p = 0.0115). However, the fraction of time (total percentage of the scan) spent in that state did not fully recover. This suggests that while the drug helps the brain "stay on track" once it reaches a healthy state, it does not necessarily increase the frequency of entering that state.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that schizophrenia is characterized by altered temporal dynamics of brain networks. The integration of static and dynamic features significantly improved classification accuracy (83.8%) between patients and controls. While risperidone partially normalizes these dynamics over six weeks, the persistence of certain abnormalities suggests that temporal instability remains a core component of the disorder's pathology. Future work should explore whether these dynamic "biotypes" can predict individual treatment responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Resting-state functional connectivity studies in schizophrenia evaluating average connectivity over the entire experiment have reported aberrant network integration, but findings are variable. Examining time-varying (dynamic) functional connectivity may help explain some inconsistencies. We assessed dynamic network connectivity using resting-state functional MRI in patients with schizophrenia, while unmedicated (<i>n</i> = 34), after 1 week (<i>n</i> = 29) and 6 weeks of treatment with risperidone (<i>n</i> = 24), as well as matched controls at baseline (<i>n</i> = 35) and after 6 weeks (<i>n</i> = 19). After identifying 41 independent components (ICs) comprising resting-state networks, sliding window analysis was performed on IC timecourses using an optimal window size validated with linear support vector machines. Windowed correlation matrices were then clustered into three discrete connectivity states (a relatively sparsely connected state, a relatively abundantly connected state, and an intermediately connected state). In unmedicated patients, static connectivity was increased between five pairs of ICs and decreased between two pairs of ICs when compared to controls, dynamic connectivity showed increased connectivity between the thalamus and somatomotor network in one of the three states. State statistics indicated that, in comparison to controls, unmedicated patients had shorter mean dwell times and fraction of time spent in the sparsely connected state, and longer dwell times and fraction of time spent in the intermediately connected state. Risperidone appeared to normalize mean dwell times after 6 weeks, but not fraction of time. Results suggest that static connectivity abnormalities in schizophrenia may partly be related to altered brain network temporal dynamics rather than consistent dysconnectivity within and between functional networks and demonstrate the importance of implementing complementary data analysis techniques.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lottman2017risperidone,
  author = {Kristin K. Lottman and Nina V. Kraguljac and David M. White and Charity J. Morgan and Vince D. Calhoun and Allison Butt and Adrienne C. Lahti},
  title = {{Risperidone Effects on Brain Dynamic Connectivity—A Prospective Resting-State fMRI Study in Schizophrenia}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2017.00014},
}
Figure