TL;DR
This study applies the Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) to identify critical risks in China's prefabricated building sector, revealing that while many risks are perceived as important, their management performance is often lacking. The findings highlight specific areas requiring urgent attention, such as improper system decomposition and factory management, to foster wider adoption of prefabricated construction.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Prefabricated construction, offering potential benefits like reduced waste and faster construction times, has seen significant government promotion in China. However, its market share remains surprisingly low. This paper addresses the critical question of why this adoption is lagging by investigating the key risks associated with prefabricated buildings in China. Existing research has focused on identifying driving and impeding factors, but this study aims to bridge the gap by not only identifying these risks but also assessing their perceived importance and the current performance of their management, paving the way for targeted strategies.
Methods
The research employed a multi-stage methodology:
- Critical Literature Review: An initial list of potential risks was compiled by reviewing academic literature on prefabrication.
- Expert Interviews: This preliminary list was refined through semi-structured interviews with ten industry experts to ensure relevance to the Chinese context and to identify any missing risks.
- Questionnaire Survey: A survey was conducted with 154 industry professionals to gather their expert opinions on the importance and performance of managing these identified risks.
- Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA): The collected data was analyzed using the IPA framework. This involves plotting each risk factor on a two-dimensional matrix based on its perceived importance and performance level. This allows for the classification of risks into four quadrants: "Concentrating here," "Keeping up the good work," "Low priority," and "Possible overkill," guiding strategic prioritization.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on survey data collected from industry professionals.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Importance-Performance Gap": A significant finding is the discrepancy between how important certain risks are perceived to be and how well they are currently managed. This suggests a reactive rather than proactive approach to risk management in the Chinese prefabricated building sector.
- Early-Stage Risks Dominate Importance: Many of the most important risks identified are concentrated in the early stages of a project, such as feasibility study and design. This highlights the industry's concern about foundational planning and policy.
- Later-Stage Risks Show Poorer Performance: Conversely, risks related to manufacturing and construction stages, while perhaps less universally perceived as "important" as early-stage risks, exhibit poorer management performance. This points to technical execution challenges.
- Standardization is Key: Several critical risks, including improper decomposition, defects in component systems, and missing catalogues, are directly linked to the lack of a standardized component system. This underscores the need for industry-wide standards and catalogues.
- Evidence is Crucial: A notable risk is the "lack of actual cases to prove the environmental benefits of prefabricated buildings." This suggests that beyond policy mandates, tangible, real-world evidence is needed to build confidence and drive adoption.
Key Results
The study identified 77 risks across the life cycle of prefabricated buildings. The IPA analysis revealed eight crucial risks that require immediate attention, falling into the "Concentrating here" quadrant:
- Improper decomposition system
- Low level of factory management
- Incompetent quality assurance system
- Deviation in specification of prefabricated components
- Defects of component system
- Missing catalogue of building parts and components
- Poor adaptability of prefabricated building during the operational stage
- Lack of actual cases to prove the environmental benefits of prefabricated buildings
The top ten risks, ranked by importance, are heavily weighted towards the feasibility study stage, including high overall cost, changes to preferable policies, lack of uniqueness in design, and lack of related standards.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the study's findings are based on the perceptions of industry professionals in China and may not be universally applicable. Future work suggested includes:
- Case Study Approach: Investigating prefabrication issues in real-life projects to gain deeper insights.
- Cross-Sector Comparison: Comparing prefabrication practices and risks across different sectors to inform policy and standardized procedures.
- Technological Innovation: Focusing on improving connection mechanisms, particularly for structural components, to enhance adaptability.
- Developing a Standardized Catalogue: The government is encouraged to lead the development of a catalogue for common modules to facilitate standardized design and manufacturing.
- Industry-Wide Training: Professional bodies should organize training to improve the industry's understanding of designing, constructing, and operating prefabricated buildings.
- Building a Database of Actual Cases: Creating a repository of successful projects with documented benefits would help build industry confidence.
Summary updated