Risk Prevention And Control And Construction Path Of Criminal Compliance Of Construction Engineering Corporates

Heyuan Sun, Zhiyuan LiuAsian 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a comprehensive criminal compliance framework for construction engineering firms in China to mitigate high-stakes risks like fraud, corruption, and safety accidents. By shifting from a reactive "command and control" regulatory model to an internal, incentive-based compliance system, the authors argue that companies can better navigate the "going global" era while reducing devastating legal liabilities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry is a "high-risk" sector prone to criminal activity, ranging from collusive bidding and bribery to fatal safety accidents and ecological damage. In China, traditional regulation relies heavily on prior administrative approvals and post-incident penalties. However, this model is failing due to a "power vacuum" in internal supervision and an imbalance between a massive number of projects and limited government resources.

The authors highlight that as Chinese firms expand internationally (via the "Belt and Road" initiative), they face increasing scrutiny from entities like the World Bank. Without robust internal mechanisms to identify and stop illegal acts before they happen, these firms risk being blacklisted, suffering massive economic losses, and facing "devastating" criminal prosecution.

Methods

The paper presents a legal and policy framework analysis rather than an experimental study. The authors propose a "Construction Path" for compliance based on three pillars:

  1. Risk Identification: Utilizing a "normative tracking" approach focused on the "eight powers" (core corporate authorities) to set up early warning lines.
  2. Legislative Reform: Proposing specific amendments to China’s Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Law, such as introducing a corporate probation system and "effective compliance" as a statutory factor for sentencing leniency.
  3. Dual Incentive/Punishment Model: Creating a system where "induced compliance" (voluntary commitments beyond the legal minimum) is rewarded with administrative certifications or penalty alleviations.

Datasets

As a legal policy paper, it does not utilize training datasets or benchmarks in the computational sense. However, it draws on:

  • World Bank Sanctions Lists: Used to demonstrate the increasing number of Chinese firms being blacklisted due to low compliance standards.
  • Chinese Statutory Law: Analysis of the Criminal Law, Construction Law, and Company Law of the PRC.
  • Case Studies: Qualitative references to the "ZTE and Huawei incidents" of 2018 as catalysts for corporate compliance awareness in China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Eight Powers" Breakthrough: The authors argue that compliance shouldn't be a vague goal but should focus specifically on the improper exercise of a firm's core powers. By tracking these specific points, firms can identify the source of risk rather than just the symptoms.
  • Procedural vs. Consequential Impact: Traditional law focuses on the consequence (the accident or the bribe). Criminal compliance focuses on the procedure—proving that the company had a "measuring instrument" in place to prevent the act, which can then be used to mitigate corporate liability.
  • The Reciprocity Gap: A major reason for compliance failure is the lack of motivation for stakeholders other than the main contractor. The paper suggests that for compliance to work, the "rewards" (reduced regulatory intensity) must be distributed across the "community of interests," including subcontractors and consultants.
  • Cultural Barriers to Whistleblowing: The authors candidly note that Western-style reporting systems struggle in Chinese corporate culture. They suggest that a "guaranteed mechanism" to stop retaliation is a prerequisite for any effective identification system.

Key Results

The paper outlines a legal blueprint for the future of Chinese construction law:

  • Proposed Amendment to Article 31 (Criminal Law): Suggests that if a company implements an effective compliance plan, it should receive lighter, mitigated, or even exempted punishment.
  • Executive Accountability: Proposes that senior managers should be legally obligated to promote compliance plans, with potential fines or imprisonment for failing to do so.
  • Discretionary Non-Prosecution: Recommends that the Criminal Procedure Law be updated to allow procuratorates to suspend or drop charges against a firm if a robust compliance plan is adopted post-offense.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that "compliance management cannot generate direct profits," making it a hard sell for firms focused on short-term revenue. Furthermore, the definition of what constitutes an "effective compliance program" remains somewhat subjective.

Future Work: The paper suggests a need for clearer legislative interpretations to define "effective compliance" to ensure judicial uniformity. There is also a call for more research into "qualification-related penalties" (e.g., losing the right to bid) as a more effective deterrent than simple fines.

Summary updated

Abstract

The corporate compliance system, an internal control mechanism to prevent, detect and stop illegal and criminal offences within a corporate, can serve to effectively solve potential criminal compliance risks in construction projects. The construction projects are characterized by their long-term, continuous and concealed nature. In addition, the system design of construction projects is limited by many factors, including the limitation of traditional centralized administrative mode, the absence of process supervision mechanism and reciprocal motivation mechanism, the complicated setting of supervision matters, the lack of reciprocity of the motivation mechanism and the dislocation of the main body in regulatory responsibilities. Such that, numerous violations of rules and regulations, including quality-centred disputes and safety accidents, keep coming up in the construction industry in China. Under the context of the co-development of economic and legal globalization, in order to prevent and control the potential criminal compliance risks of construction engineering corporates, it is necessary to construct compliance rules centred on supervision activities, form a corporate criminal offence and compliance identification mechanism, improve the corporate criminal liability system, establish corporate obligation and rules of criminal compliance, formulate measures for the dual models of punishment and incentive, and promote the construction and implementation of the corporate compliance system of the construction industry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2022risk,
  author = {Heyuan Sun and Zhiyuan Liu},
  title = {{Risk Prevention And Control And Construction Path Of Criminal Compliance Of Construction Engineering Corporates}},
  booktitle = {Asian},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.55662/alppr.2022.702},
}
Figure