Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals In Suspended Particulate Matter In A Typical Urban River of Northern China

Wenye Li, Wenqiang Zhang, Shan Baoqing, Sun Bao-ping, Xiaoping Guo, Zhenhan LiResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Suspended particulate matter (SPM) is a major contamination source in urban rivers. In this work, the Beiyun River, northern China, was used as a case study to determine the characteristics of heavy metal spatial distribution in SPM, and to evaluate the potential ecological risks and identify heavy metal sources. The concentration of seven heavy metals and associated indicators (TC, TN, TP, and OM) were measured at 12 sites and analyzed by Pearson correlation (PC) and principal component analyses (PCA). The average concentrations of Cr, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Cd, and Pb were 70.72, 27.88, 31.35, 115.70, 27.77, 0.23, and 29.62 mg/kg, respectively, and significant spatial differences occurred between some elements. Igeo values indicated the ranking of heavy metal pollution in SPM as As > Cd > Zn > Cu > Pb > Cr > Ni. The $E_r^i$ analysis demonstrated that the order of potential ecological risk of the seven metals was Cd > As > Cu > Pb > Ni > Cr > Zn. RI (potential ecological risk index) results confirmed high potential ecological risk in objective area. Of the measured heavy metals, Cd represented the highest pollution risk. Significant positive correlations were found between TC, TN, TP, and Cu. Three element pairs, Zn-Cd, Cr-Cu, and Cr-Ni, had strong correlations. Zn, Cu, and Ni were mainly introduced by human activities, and Cr was mainly from natural processes. This information on the concentration, risk, and sources of SPM in Beiyun River provides an important reference for reducing heavy metal pollution in SPM of a typical river in the Haihe River Basin.

Introduction

Urban rivers are often treated as the kidneys of a city, but they are increasingly becoming sinks for industrial and agricultural waste. While many studies focus on pollutants settled in the bottom sediment, this paper targets Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM)—the tiny particles floating in the water column. SPM is a critical concern because its high surface area and bio-organic coatings make it an incredibly efficient "carrier" for heavy metals. Because these particles stay suspended, they are more mobile than bed sediments, meaning they can transport toxins long distances downstream and easily enter the food chain through filter-feeding organisms and fish. This study maps the distribution of these metals in the Beiyun River and assesses the resulting ecological danger.

Methodology

The research team collected samples from 12 strategic sites along the Beiyun River in April 2019. They focused on seven heavy metals: Chromium (Cr), Nickel (Ni), Copper (Cu), Zinc (Zn), Arsenic (As), Cadmium (Cd), and Lead (Pb). Chemical analysis was performed using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS).

To quantify the environmental risk, the authors utilized three standard indices:

  1. Geoaccumulation Index ($I_{geo}$): Measures pollution relative to natural background levels.
  2. Potential Ecological Risk Index ($RI$): Factors in the biological toxicity of each metal.
  3. Mean Probable Effect Concentration quotient ($Q_{m-PEC}$): Evaluates the combined toxic effect of multiple metals on bottom-dwelling organisms.
Formula for the Potential Ecological Risk Index (RI), where Er is the individual risk factor and Ti is the toxic response factor.

Source apportionment was conducted using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Pearson correlation to statistically "fingerprint" whether the metals originated from natural weathering or anthropogenic activities.

Results and Data Analysis

The study found that heavy metal concentrations generally increased as the river flowed from upstream to downstream, suggesting cumulative loading from urban areas like Tianjin.

Table 1: Statistical summary of heavy metal concentrations (mg/kg) and comparative benchmarks in the Beiyun River.

Average concentrations for the most concerning metals were Zn (115.70 mg/kg), Cr (70.72 mg/kg), and Cu (31.35 mg/kg). Arsenic levels were particularly high, exceeding background values by 2.81 times. Based on the Geoaccumulation Index ($I_{geo}$), the ranking of pollution was As > Cd > Zn > Cu > Pb > Cr > Ni.

Crucially, even though Cadmium (Cd) had the lowest absolute concentration (0.23 mg/kg), it represented the highest ecological risk ($E_r^i$). This highlights that mass does not always equal impact in environmental monitoring. The overall Potential Ecological Risk Index ($RI$) confirmed a "high potential ecological risk" for the study area.

Discussion: Human vs. Natural Sources

The statistical analysis revealed a clear divide in sources. Zinc, Copper, and Nickel were strongly linked to human activities, specifically electroplating, metallurgy, and traffic emissions. In contrast, Chromium was largely attributed to natural soil weathering processes. Anthropogenic sources (PC1) explained 57.77% of the total variance, confirming that human activity is the dominant driver of river pollution in this region. Furthermore, the numerous sluice dams along the Beiyun River slow down water velocity, which encourages the accumulation of contaminated particles rather than natural flushing.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study provides a robust snapshot of pollution, several complexities remain:

  • Dynamic Interactions: The relationship between SPM and bed sediment is dynamic; particles are constantly settling and being resuspended. Future studies should examine these exchange rates across different seasons.
  • Bioavailability: The study measures total metal content, but not all of that metal is "bioavailable." Future research into chemical speciation would provide a more accurate picture of biological uptake.
  • Mitigation: While desilting and industrial runoff interception are suggested, the economic and long-term ecological feasibility of these projects requires further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Suspended particulate matter (SPM) is a major contamination source in urban rivers. In this work, the Beiyun River, northern China, was used as a case study to determine the characteristics of heavy metal spatial distribution in SPM, and to evaluate the potential ecological risks and identify heavy metal sources. The concentration of seven heavy metals and associated indicators (TC, TN, TP, and OM) were measured at 12 sites and analyzed by Pearson correlation (PC) and principal component analyses (PCA). The average concentrations of Cr, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Cd, and Pb were 70.72, 27.88, 31.35, 115.70, 27.77, 0.23, and 29.62 mg/kg, respectively, and significant spatial differences occurred between some elements. Igeo values indicated the ranking of heavy metal pollution in SPM as As > Cd > Zn > Cu > Pb > Cr > Ni. The E i r analysis demonstrated that the order of potential ecological risk of the seven metals was Cd > As > Cu > Pb > Ni > Cr > Zn. RI (potential ecological risk index) results confirmed high potential ecological risk in objective area. Of the measured heavy metals, Cd represented the highest pollution risk. Significant positive correlations were found between TC, TN, TP, and Cu. Three element pairs, Zn-Cd, Cr-Cu, and Cr-Ni, had strong correlations. Zn, Cu, and Ni were mainly introduced by human activities, and Cr was mainly from natural processes. This information on the concentration, risk, and sources of SPM in Beiyun River provides an important reference for reducing heavy metal pollution in SPM of a typical river in the Haihe River Basin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021risk,
  author = {Wenye Li and Wenqiang Zhang and Shan Baoqing and Sun Bao-ping and Xiaoping Guo and Zhenhan Li},
  title = {{Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals In Suspended Particulate Matter In A Typical Urban River of Northern China}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-721666/v1},
}
Figure