Rise and Shock: Optimal Defibrillator Placement in a High-rise Building

Timothy C. Y. ChanPrehospital 2016 · DOI

Abstract: Elevator-based AEDs travel less vertical distance to OHCAs in tall buildings or those with uniform vertical risk, while lobby-based AEDs travel less vertical distance in buildings with substantial lobby, underground, and nearby street-level traffic and OHCA risk.

Introduction

Survival from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is a race against the clock, with survival rates dropping by roughly 10% for every minute of delay. While urban densification has led to a surge in high-rise living, emergency response research has historically focused on 2D horizontal geography. Patients in high-rises face a "vertical survival disadvantage" due to elevator wait times and travel distances. Current clinical guidelines suggest placing Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) in "accessible locations" like lobbies, but there is no formal logic for vertical placement. This paper addresses a specific logistical question: In a building with only one AED, should it be installed in the lobby or inside the elevator?

The Mathematical Framework

The study develops a mathematical model of a single-elevator, $n$-floor building to evaluate response distances. The core of the analysis relies on several key components:

  • Risk Modeling: OHCA occurrences are modeled as independent Poisson processes. The model distinguishes between the risk on the ground floor ($\lambda_1$) and the risk on any above-ground floor ($\lambda$).
  • Probabilistic Elevator Location: The elevator’s position when an emergency call comes in is treated as a discrete uniform random variable ($U$), representing an elevator that could be anywhere in the building.
  • Operational Assumptions: The model assumes a "security override" exists, allowing a guard to send the elevator directly to a target floor without intermediate stops.
  • Metric: The primary outcome is "Response Distance"—the number of floors the elevator must travel to get the AED to the patient.

This approach moves beyond simple average distances to calculate expected values and variances based on the building's specific risk profile and height.

Key Insights: The One-Way Trip Advantage

The fundamental advantage of an elevator-based AED is that it is a "moving target" that is statistically closer to upper floors. When an arrest occurs at height, the elevator makes a one-way trip. Conversely, a lobby-based AED requires a two-way trip: the elevator must first travel down to the lobby to pick up the AED (and potentially a responder) before heading back up to the patient.

The "3/4 Rule"

The optimality of elevator placement is governed by a simple inequality derived from the model: $$n \ge 0.75(\lambda_1/\lambda) + 0.5$$ If the building height $n$ exceeds this threshold, the elevator is the superior location. For example, if the risk is equal on all floors ($\lambda_1 = \lambda$), an elevator-based AED is always better for any building with more than one floor. If the ground floor is 10 times riskier than any single upper floor ($\lambda_1 = 10\lambda$), the building must be at least 8 floors high for the elevator placement to become the optimal choice.

Results and Performance Metrics

Beyond average response times, the study highlights two critical performance metrics:

  1. Maximum Distance: The maximum travel distance for an elevator-based AED is $n-1$ floors. For a lobby-based AED, it is $2(n-1)$ floors—literally double the worst-case scenario.
  2. Variance and Consistency: Even if the average response time were equal for both locations, the elevator-based AED has lower variance. This provides a more predictable response time, avoiding the extreme delays associated with lobby placements in tall buildings.

Lobby placement only wins when the ground floor has disproportionately high risk—for example, in buildings with massive transit hubs, underground malls, or heavy street-level foot traffic.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this model provides a robust theoretical foundation, it operates under the constraint of a single elevator and a single AED. Modern high-rises often feature elevator banks and multiple AEDs, which would require more complex multi-agent simulation. Furthermore, the benefit of an elevator-based AED assumes a second responder (like a neighbor) can meet the elevator. If the only responder is a security guard who must travel with the AED, the "one-way trip" advantage is negated.

Future research should utilize computer simulations to generate entire response time distributions for complex buildings with varying elevator holding strategies and vertical risk profiles, particularly as high-resolution data on how cardiac arrest risk scales with floor height becomes available.

Summary updated

Abstract

Elevator-based AEDs travel less vertical distance to OHCAs in tall buildings or those with uniform vertical risk, while lobby-based AEDs travel less vertical distance in buildings with substantial lobby, underground, and nearby street-level traffic and OHCA risk.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chan2016rise,
  author = {Timothy C. Y. Chan},
  title = {{Rise and Shock: Optimal Defibrillator Placement in a High-rise Building}},
  booktitle = {Prehospital},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1080/10903127.2016.1247202},
}
Figure