Rigid Control of Motor Unit Firing Rates in the Human Tibialis Anterior Muscle Persists during Neurofeedback

Meng‐Jung Lee, Patrick Ofner, Hsien-Yung Huang, Joris Mulder, Jaime Ibáñez, Dario Farina, Carsten MehringbioRxiv 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The conventional framework of motor-unit (MU) control assumes that MUs in a MU pool are constrained by a fixed recruitment order and a common input. This rigid-control framework has been challenged by recent findings suggesting that MU activity could be flexibly modulated, potentially mediated by descending cortical inputs. In this study, we investigated control flexibility by assessing if human participants can voluntarily modulate MU firing rates beyond rigid-control constraints. Specifically, we examined whether participants could voluntarily modulate the firing rates of a pair of MUs from the tibialis anterior muscle during real-time feedback. Two tasks involving target-reach with different visual feedback derived from the MUs firing rates were conducted. In both tasks, there was no evidence that participants were able to change MU firing rates in a way that would violate rigid control robustly. Our findings demonstrate limited flexibility in MU control in human tibialis anterior muscle within single-session training, even when real-time MU activity feedback was provided. The results suggest that MU flexibility is not inherently present in the human lower limb.

Introduction

For decades, the "size principle" has dominated our understanding of movement: motor units are recruited in a fixed order, driven by a common neural signal. This "rigid control" suggests that a muscle acts essentially as a one-dimensional actuator. However, recent studies in primates and some human experiments have suggested "flexible control"—the idea that the brain can pick and choose specific motor units to fire independently. If flexible control exists, a single muscle could provide multiple independent control signals for prosthetic limbs or computer interfaces. This study sought to determine if this flexibility is an inherent feature of the human lower limb or if we are "hardwired" for synchronized output.

Methods

The study involved 33 able-bodied participants. Researchers utilized High-Density Surface Electromyography (HD-sEMG) combined with a real-time decomposition algorithm to identify the firing rates of individual motor units in the tibialis anterior (shin muscle) during isometric dorsiflexion. These firing rates were translated into a visual cursor on a screen in milliseconds.

Experimental setup for real-time motor unit neurofeedback using HD-sEMG and visual feedback.

Two distinct neurofeedback tasks were designed:

  1. Displacement Control: The firing rate of MU1 controlled the X-axis, and MU2 controlled the Y-axis. To reach specific "displacement zone" targets, participants had to increase the firing rate of one unit while decreasing the other—a direct violation of common neural drive.
  2. Difference Control: A mapping where the sum of firing rates controlled vertical position and the difference controlled horizontal velocity.

Results and Discussion

Under rigid control, the firing rates of two MUs are mathematically confined to a one-dimensional curve, or manifold. Moving "off-manifold" into the displacement zones is the litmus test for true independent control.

Conceptual framework of the rigid control manifold (a), target zones (b), and experimental firing rate data showing adherence to the manifold (c).

The results provided strong evidence against flexibility:

  • Low Performance: Participants spent only 17% to 28% of the time in target zones, barely above chance levels.
  • Manifold Constraint: Bayesian analysis (BF21 > 10) showed that participants failed to reach displacement targets robustly. Instead of independent control, participants were consistently pulled toward a single quadrant by the muscle's intrinsic properties.
  • Hysteresis and PICs: Some apparent target reaches were identified as artifacts of Persistent Inward Currents (PICs). Because MUs ramp up and down differently (hysteresis), a simple "increase then decrease force" maneuver can make the cursor appear to move independently when it is actually following a predictable physical lag.
  • No Learning Effect: Across five blocks of training, there was no significant improvement in performance, suggesting that a single session of neurofeedback is insufficient to "unlock" independent MU control.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that the human lower limb, primarily used for posture and walking, may be strictly optimized for stable, common-drive control. While single-session training might be a limitation, the results indicate that MU flexibility is not an inherent feature of the tibialis anterior. Future work may explore intrinsic hand muscles, which are evolved for fine manipulation, or longitudinal studies to determine if extended practice can eventually rewire these rigid neural pathways.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The conventional framework of motor-unit (MU) control assumes that MUs in a MU pool are constrained by a fixed recruitment order and a common input. This rigid-control framework has been challenged by recent findings suggesting that MU activity could be flexibly modulated, potentially mediated by descending cortical inputs. In this study, rather than evaluating flexibility from the perspective of recruitment thresholds, we investigated control flexibility by assessing if human participants can voluntarily modulate MU firing rates beyond rigid-control constraints. Specifically, we examined whether participants could voluntarily modulate the firing rates of a pair of MUs from the tibialis anterior muscle during real-time feedback. Two tasks involving target-reach with different visual feedback derived from the MUs firing rates were conducted. In both tasks, there was no evidence that participants were able to change MU firing rates in a way that would violate rigid control robustly. Our findings demonstrate limited flexibility in MU control in human tibialis anterior muscle within single-session training, even when real-time MU activity feedback was provided. The results suggest that MU flexibility is not inherently present in the human lower limb.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2025rigid,
  author = {Meng‐Jung Lee and Patrick Ofner and Hsien-Yung Huang and Joris Mulder and Jaime Ibáñez and Dario Farina and Carsten Mehring},
  title = {{Rigid Control of Motor Unit Firing Rates in the Human Tibialis Anterior Muscle Persists during Neurofeedback}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.02.10.637074},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure