Introduction
Richard Taruskin, arguably the most influential musicologist of his generation, has long dedicated his career to what he calls "cleaning the Augean stables" of Russian music history. In his 2016 collection, Russian Music at Home and Abroad: New Essays, Taruskin compiles twenty provocative pieces that continue his relentless deconstruction of the myths, stereotypes, and ideological distortions that have plagued the field for over a century. Reviewed by Christoph Flamm in 2018, the volume serves as both a rigorous scholarly contribution and a sharp polemic against the "alternative facts" that persist in modern musicology and political discourse.
The Problem of Historiographical "Nonsense"
The central "problem" Taruskin addresses is the resilience of historiographical legends. Despite decades of archival research and critical analysis, musicology often remains tethered to narratives that serve nationalistic or ideological agendas. Taruskin expresses a palpable frustration that "nonsense"—his term for these historical inaccuracies—continues to thrive.
In the Russian context, this manifests as the state-sanctioned denial of Tchaikovsky’s homosexuality or the continued reliance on Solomon Volkov’s Testimony (the disputed Shostakovich memoirs) as a source of "poetic truth." In the West, it appears as the persistent image of Igor Stravinsky as an isolated, "original" genius who emerged fully formed, independent of his Russian roots. Taruskin argues that these myths are not merely harmless stories but are active manipulations of historical truth.
Methodological Rigor and Polemical Bite
Taruskin’s methodology is multifaceted, combining deep hermeneutic analysis with historiographical deconstruction. He examines musical works—such as Prokofiev’s Symphony-Concerto—not in a vacuum, but within their specific cultural and political environments. A hallmark of his approach is genealogical research, where he traces the technical lineage of composers to debunk the myth of the ex nihilo creator. For instance, he meticulously links Stravinsky’s octatonicism back to the teachings of Rimsky-Korsakov, a connection Stravinsky himself later sought to obscure.
Beyond technical analysis, Taruskin is known for his "polemical bite." He uses sharp rhetoric to challenge colleagues and established narratives ex cathedra. This style is not merely for effect; it reflects a moral commitment to historical accuracy and a refusal to accept "alternative facts," whether they originate in the Soviet era or the contemporary political landscape.
Key Insights: From Stravinsky to the Soviet Era
One of the book's most significant contributions is its continued dismantling of the "monument" of Stravinsky. Taruskin links the aesthetics of Le Sacre du printemps and Oedipus Rex to a "proto-fascist zeitgeist," warning that the "anti-humanism" often celebrated in modernist art has inherent, and often overlooked, political dimensions.
Furthermore, the collection offers surprising "honorary rescues" of figures often dismissed or vilified. Taruskin provides nuanced reconsiderations of Sergei Rachmaninoff and even Tikhon Khrennikov, the long-time head of the Soviet Composers' Union. By moving beyond the binary of "hero" or "villain," Taruskin provides a more complex understanding of how these figures navigated the pressures of their time.
The book also highlights the "Russian School" in emigration, specifically the role of Arthur Lourié. Taruskin reveals Lourié’s significant influence on Stravinsky, an influence that the latter famously and systematically denied in his later years.
A Darker Outlook
A notable shift in this 2016 collection, compared to Taruskin’s 2009 work On Russian Music, is a move toward a "darker" outlook. While he was previously optimistic that historical "nonsense" was receding, he now observes a regression. He notes how the "True, Good, and Beautiful" are being ironically inverted by modern political taboos in Russia, where music history remains a primary battlefield for national identity.
Critical Reception and Limitations
Reviewer Christoph Flamm acknowledges Taruskin as a "brilliant stylist" whose work transcends the narrow confines of musicology to address broader ethical and historical themes. However, the review also notes certain limitations. Taruskin’s high degree of self-referentiality can occasionally border on the mannered, and his "moralizing basic trait" has not always endeared him to his professional peers. Additionally, some sections—particularly those regarding Stravinsky—do not significantly expand upon the ground covered in Taruskin’s landmark 1996 monograph.
Conclusion
Russian Music at Home and Abroad stands as a testament to Taruskin’s enduring role as the conscience of Russian musicology. While his polemical style may be divisive, his commitment to deconstructing myths and exposing the political instrumentalization of art remains essential. The collection serves as a vital reminder that music history is never just about the notes; it is a reflection of the complex, often messy, human and political contexts from which it emerges.
Summary updated