Rice Leaf Lateral Asymmetry in the Relationship between SPAD and Area-Based Nitrogen Concentration

Shen Yuan, Travis Luc Goron, Liying Huang, Lilian Wu, Fei WangSymmetry 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that rice leaves exhibit lateral asymmetry in how their nitrogen content relates to SPAD readings, with the wider side of the leaf offering a more reliable estimation of nitrogen status. The findings suggest that measuring SPAD on the lower-middle portion of the wider leaf half provides the most accurate and practical assessment of a rice plant's nitrogen needs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nitrogen (N) is a critical nutrient for rice production, and accurately assessing its status is vital for optimizing fertilizer application, improving yields, and minimizing environmental impact. Traditional methods for measuring leaf N concentration (Na) are destructive, time-consuming, and costly. Non-destructive methods like the SPAD chlorophyll meter offer a faster alternative, but their accuracy can be influenced by various factors, including where on the leaf the measurement is taken. Previous research has noted that rice leaves have a distinct asymmetry, with one side being wider than the other. However, it was unclear whether this lateral asymmetry affected the relationship between SPAD readings and actual nitrogen concentration, and if one side of the leaf was more suitable for SPAD measurements. This paper aims to bridge that knowledge gap by investigating the impact of leaf lateral asymmetry on SPAD-based nitrogen estimation.

Methods

The researchers conducted field experiments across multiple locations and growing seasons in China, using 17 different rice varieties. They collected data from the top three fully expanded leaves of rice plants at the heading stage. For each leaf, they meticulously divided it into a "wide side" and a "narrow side" along the midrib. SPAD readings were taken at seven specific points along the length of each lateral half, from the leaf apex to the base. After SPAD measurements, the leaves were processed to determine the leaf area and nitrogen concentration (Na) for each lateral half. Statistical analyses, including linear regression, were used to examine the relationship between SPAD readings and Na for both the wide and narrow sides, as well as for the whole leaf. They also analyzed the variability of SPAD readings across different points and sides to understand the stability of measurements.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from four field experiments conducted in Wuxue County and Wuhan City, Hubei Province, China, during 2014. These experiments involved 17 rice cultivars across early, middle, and late growing seasons. Soil properties were characterized for each experimental field. Climate data (daily temperature, solar radiation, relative humidity, and rainfall) for the growing seasons were also collected from nearby weather stations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leaf asymmetry matters for N estimation: The study definitively shows that the relationship between SPAD readings and leaf nitrogen concentration is not uniform across the entire leaf blade due to its inherent lateral asymmetry.
  • Wider side is the better predictor: The wider half of the rice leaf consistently demonstrated a stronger correlation (higher R²) between SPAD readings and nitrogen concentration compared to the narrower side. This suggests that the wider side provides a more reliable signal for estimating plant N status.
  • Location, location, location: The optimal position for SPAD measurement is not at the leaf tip or base, but rather in the lower-middle portion of the leaf blade (specifically, points 4, 5, and 6, representing roughly 55-75% from the apex). This region offers a good balance between accuracy and operability.
  • Averaging helps, but side matters more: While averaging SPAD readings across both sides of the leaf can slightly improve the estimation of whole-leaf nitrogen, prioritizing measurements from the wider side is more impactful.
  • Practical implications for farmers: This research provides concrete guidance for optimizing the use of SPAD meters in rice cultivation, leading to more precise nitrogen management and potentially improved fertilizer efficiency.

Key Results

  • SPAD readings were consistently higher on the narrow side of the leaf than on the wide side across all measured points and top three leaves.
  • The coefficient of determination (R²) for the relationship between SPAD and Na was significantly higher for the wide side (average R² of 0.71) compared to the narrow side (average R² of 0.64) across the top three leaves.
  • The optimal measurement points for estimating Na were identified as the 4th, 5th, and 6th points along the leaf blade, which correspond to the lower-middle section.
  • Averaging SPAD readings across both sides of the leaf and across these optimal points improved the estimation of whole-leaf Na, with R² values reaching up to 0.81 for the wide side.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that SPAD readings can be influenced by factors such as rice variety, growth stage, and leaf thickness, which were accounted for in their study design. However, they note that the midrib thickness and leaf width variations can limit SPAD measurement at the leaf base. Future research could explore the application of these findings to other non-destructive methods like leaf color charts (LCC) and NDVI, and investigate the relationship between sensor readings and N content on each side of the leaf blade in other crop species.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yuan2017rice,
  author = {Shen Yuan and Travis Luc Goron and Liying Huang and Lilian Wu and Fei Wang},
  title = {{Rice Leaf Lateral Asymmetry in the Relationship between SPAD and Area-Based Nitrogen Concentration}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/sym9060083},
}
Figure