RHINO: A large horn antenna for detecting the 21cm global signal

Philip Bull, Ahmed El‐Makadema, Hugh Garsden, John Edgley, N. Roddis, Jens Chluba, Christopher J. Conselice, Sohini Dutta, Katrine A. Glasscock, Ainulnabilah Nasirudin, J. Norris, Michael J. Wilensky, Isabelle Ye, Zheng ZhangarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

RHINO (Remote HI eNvironment Observer) is a new experiment designed to detect the faint "global signal" from the early universe using a massive, 7-meter-class horn antenna instead of the traditional compact dipoles. By combining the high characterizability of horn antennas with a novel continuous-wave calibration system, the project aims to overcome the instrumental artifacts and ground-coupling issues that have historically plagued 21cm cosmology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "global signal"—the sky-averaged 21cm emission from neutral hydrogen—is a goldmine for understanding the Cosmic Dawn and the Epoch of Reionization. However, this signal is incredibly faint (tens of millikelvin) and buried under Galactic foregrounds that are four to five orders of magnitude brighter.

Most current experiments use compact dipole antennas. While portable, dipoles are notoriously difficult to model because they interact strongly with the ground beneath them and have "chromatic" beams (patterns that change significantly with frequency). If the antenna beam or the ground reflections aren't perfectly understood, they can create spectral ripples that look exactly like the signal researchers are searching for. RHINO addresses this by moving to a large horn antenna architecture, which is self-shielding and far more predictable.

Methods

The paper details the design and simulation of the RHINO system, focusing on three main areas:

  1. The Antenna: A large pyramidal horn (7.3m x 6.0m aperture) designed to operate between 60–85 MHz. Horns are essentially waveguides; the receiver is tucked deep inside, shielded from the ground and the local environment.
  2. Continuous Wave (CW) Calibration: Traditional systems use "Dicke switching," rapidly toggling between the sky and a calibration load. RHINO proposes injecting a constant, high-amplitude "tone" (a CW signal) into the signal path. This allows the system to monitor gain fluctuations (1/f noise) in real-time without ever looking away from the sky.
  3. Simulation Pipeline: The authors used CST Studio for full-wave electromagnetic simulations and the 21cmVAE emulator to generate plausible cosmological signals. They then used Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to test how well they could recover physical parameters (like star formation efficiency) from the data.

Datasets

  • Sky Models: The team used the reprocessed Haslam 408 MHz map and the Global Sky Model (GSM) 2016 to simulate diffuse foreground emission.
  • Signal Emulator: 21cmVAE was used to generate a library of 21cm global signal models based on different physical parameters of the early universe.
  • RFI Monitoring: The authors collected 24 hours of real-world Radio Frequency Interference (RFI) data at the Jodrell Bank Observatory (JBO) to assess the viability of the site for the prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Design Independence: By choosing a horn antenna, RHINO provides a crucial cross-check for results from dipole-based experiments like EDGES or SARAS. If different antenna architectures see the same signal, our confidence in the physics increases.
  • Ground Insensitivity: Simulations showed that the horn's "beam correction factor" varies by less than 1% between wet and dry soil conditions. This is a significant improvement over dipoles, which can be highly sensitive to soil moisture.
  • The Bandwidth Challenge: RHINO targets a relatively narrow 25 MHz window to avoid the FM radio band. The paper highlights that while this simplifies the hardware, it makes "blind" foreground removal (like PCA) dangerous, as the foreground models can easily "eat" the smooth 21cm signal.
  • Physical Modeling is Mandatory: The authors argue that because the signal is so smooth over a narrow band, we cannot rely on data-driven foreground removal. Instead, we must use highly constrained physical models of the Galaxy and the instrument.

Key Results

  • Antenna Specs: The reference design achieved a return loss better than -10 dB and a beam width of 44°–35° across the target band.
  • Parameter Recovery: In ideal (foreground-free) simulations, RHINO successfully recovered key parameters like the minimum circular velocity for star-forming halos ($V_c$).
  • RFI Environment: Initial monitoring at Jodrell Bank revealed that while the FM band is a "cliff" at 87.5 MHz, there are significant quiet windows during the night and early morning that are suitable for observations.
  • Prototype Progress: A scaled-down prototype (targeting 350 MHz) is already under construction to test the mechanical assembly and the CW calibration electronics.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the narrow bandwidth. A 25 MHz window is just barely enough to capture the "dip" of the 21cm signal. If the signal is broader than expected, RHINO might only see a featureless slope.

Future work will focus on:

  • Refining the Horn: Adding "choke rings" or corrugations to the aperture to further suppress sidelobes and backlobes.
  • Advanced Calibration: Moving from a single CW tone to a "comb" of multiple tones to better track frequency-dependent gain variations.
  • Site Selection: While JBO is convenient for prototyping, the full-scale experiment may eventually need a more remote, radio-quiet site to reach the required sensitivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The sky-averaged brightness temperature of the 21cm line from neutral hydrogen provides a sensitive probe of the thermal state of the intergalactic medium, particularly before and during Cosmic Dawn and the Epoch of Reionisation. This `global signal' is faint, on the order of tens to hundreds of millikelvin, and spectrally relatively smooth, making it exceedingly difficult to disentangle from foreground radio emission and instrumental artefacts. In this paper, we introduce RHINO, an experiment based around a large horn antenna operating from 60-85 MHz. Horn antennas are highly characterisable and provide excellent shielding from their immediate environment, which are potentially decisive advantages when it comes to the beam measurement and modelling problems that are particularly challenging for this kind of experiment. The system also includes a novel continuous wave calibration source to control correlated gain fluctuations, allowing continuous monitoring of the overall gain level without needing to rapidly switch between the sky and a calibration source. Here, we describe the basic RHINO concept, including the antenna design, EM simulations, and receiver electronics. We use a basic simulation and analysis pipeline to study the impact of the limited bandwidth on recovery of physical 21cm global signal model parameters, and discuss a basic calibration scheme that incorporates the continuous wave signal. Finally, we report on the current state of a scaled-down prototype system under construction at Jodrell Bank Observatory.
BibTeX
@misc{bull2024rhino,
  author = {Philip Bull and Ahmed El‐Makadema and Hugh Garsden and John Edgley and N. Roddis and Jens Chluba and Christopher J. Conselice and Sohini Dutta and Katrine A. Glasscock and Ainulnabilah Nasirudin and J. Norris and Michael J. Wilensky and Isabelle Ye and Zheng Zhang},
  title = {{RHINO: A large horn antenna for detecting the 21cm global signal}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.00076},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.00076},
}
Figure