RgCop-A regularized copula based method for gene selection in single cell rna-seq data

Snehalika Lall, Sumanta Ray, Sanghamitra BandyopadhyaybioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces RgCop, a novel method for selecting informative genes from single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data. By leveraging a robust measure called copula correlation and incorporating L1 regularization, RgCop effectively identifies key genes that improve downstream analysis like cell clustering and classification, even in the presence of technical noise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) generates vast amounts of data, allowing researchers to study complex biological processes at an unprecedented resolution. A critical early step in analyzing this data is gene selection, where the goal is to identify a subset of genes that best represent the biological information within the cells. Traditional methods often rely on identifying genes with high variation or high expression. However, these approaches can be sensitive to technical noise inherent in scRNA-seq data, leading to unstable and less predictive gene sets. This instability can negatively impact subsequent analyses, such as clustering cells into distinct types and annotating unknown cell populations. The paper aims to address this by developing a more robust and accurate gene selection method.

Methods

The core of RgCop lies in its novel objective function, which combines two key components:

  • Copula Correlation (Ccor): This is a robust measure of dependence that captures multivariate relationships between genes. Unlike traditional correlation measures, Ccor is scale-invariant, making it less susceptible to noise and data transformations common in scRNA-seq. It's used to assess both the "relevancy" of a gene to cell type labels and the "redundancy" among selected genes.
  • L1 Regularization: To further refine the gene selection process and penalize redundant genes, the authors incorporate an L1 regularization term into the objective function. This encourages sparsity, effectively pushing the coefficients of less informative or redundant genes towards zero, leading to a more parsimonious and effective gene set.

The gene selection process is iterative: it starts by identifying the most relevant gene, then iteratively adds genes that are both relevant to cell types and minimally redundant with the already selected genes.

Datasets

The authors evaluated RgCop on several publicly available scRNA-seq datasets:

  • Yan: A dataset of 124 cells from human preimplantation embryos and embryonic stem cells, representing 7 cell types.
  • Pollen: A dataset of single-cell RNA-seq data from 11 cell types.
  • Muraro: Single-cell transcriptomics data from a human pancreas tissue, containing 10 cell types.
  • PBMC68k: A large dataset comprising 68,000 cells from peripheral blood mononuclear cells.

They also used synthetic Gaussian Mixture datasets to evaluate performance under controlled conditions, specifically with overlapping and non-overlapping classes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robustness to Noise: The scale-invariant property of copulas makes RgCop inherently more robust to the technical noise prevalent in scRNA-seq data, leading to more stable gene selection.
  • Capturing Complex Dependencies: Ccor goes beyond simple pairwise correlations to capture more intricate multivariate dependencies among genes, which is crucial for understanding biological systems.
  • Balancing Relevancy and Redundancy: The objective function explicitly balances selecting genes that are informative about cell types (relevancy) with ensuring these genes are not overly correlated with each other (redundancy).
  • Improved Downstream Performance: RgCop-selected genes significantly improve the performance of downstream tasks like clustering and classification compared to existing methods.
  • Effective Annotation of Unknown Cells: The method's ability to select informative genes directly translates to better annotation of previously uncharacterized cell populations.

Key Results

  • Improved Clustering and Classification: RgCop consistently achieved higher Adjusted Rand Index (ARI) scores for clustering and classification accuracy across multiple real-world scRNA-seq datasets compared to state-of-the-art methods (e.g., MRMR, DISR, JMIM, CMIM, PCA Loading, CV2 Index, Fano Factor, Gini Clust). For instance, on the Yan dataset, RgCop achieved an ARI of 0.99 ± 0.01 with SVM, outperforming other methods.
  • Stability in Noisy Data: RgCop demonstrated superior performance in noisy datasets, maintaining a high "match_score" (percentage of matching features) compared to other methods, indicating its robustness.
  • Accurate Marker Identification: The genes selected by RgCop were found to be highly expressed within specific cell clusters, effectively acting as biological markers for those cell types.
  • Scalability: The method was successfully applied to a large PBMC68k dataset (68,000 cells), demonstrating its scalability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tuning Parameter: The performance of RgCop is influenced by a regularization parameter ($\gamma$). While the paper demonstrates tuning this parameter using synthetic data, finding the optimal value for diverse real-world datasets might require further investigation.
  • Computational Cost: While not explicitly detailed as a limitation, the iterative nature of the algorithm and the computation of copula correlations might imply a certain computational cost, especially for extremely large datasets.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that RgCop can be further utilized for various downstream analyses, including supervised classification of unknown cells and identifying marker genes, implying these are areas for continued exploration. The paper also highlights the potential for RgCop to be treated as a valuable tool for computational biologists in the initial stages of scRNA-seq data analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Gene selection in unannotated large single cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data is important and crucial step in the preliminary step of downstream analysis. The existing approaches are primarily based on high variation (highly variable genes) or significant high expression (highly expressed genes) failed to provide stable and predictive feature set due to technical noise present in the data. Here, we propose RgCop , a novel r e g ularized cop ula based method for gene selection from large single cell RNA-seq data. RgCop utilizes copula correlation ( Ccor ), a robust equitable dependence measure that captures multivariate dependency among a set of genes in single cell expression data. We raise an objective function by adding a l 1 regularization term with Ccor to penalizes the redundant co-efficient of features/genes, resulting non-redundant effective features/genes set. Results show a significant improvement in the clustering/classification performance of real life scRNA-seq data over the other state-of-the-art. RgCop performs extremely well in capturing dependence among the features of noisy data due to the scale invariant property of copula, thereby improving the stability of the method. Moreover, the differentially expressed (DE) genes identified from the clusters of scRNA-seq data are found to provide an accurate annotation of cells. Finally, the features/genes obtained from RgCop can able to annotate the unknown cells with high accuracy. Availability Corresponding software is available in: https://github.com/Snehalikalall/RgCop Contact [email protected]
BibTeX
@misc{lall2020rgcop,
  author = {Snehalika Lall and Sumanta Ray and Sanghamitra Bandyopadhyay},
  title = {{RgCop-A regularized copula based method for gene selection in single cell rna-seq data}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.23.424205},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure