This document is a book review section from the journal Schwäbische Heimat (98/1), primarily focusing on Hans Ulrich Simon’s historical study, "Mörike-Häuser: Wohnen in Stuttgart zwischen 1851 und 1875."
While the provided text also contains reviews of a botanical study on the Federsee moorlands and a medieval "Gift Book" (Schenkungsbuch) from Reichenbach, the following summary focuses on Simon’s work regarding the poet Eduard Mörike, as specified in the metadata.
TL;DR
Hans Ulrich Simon’s "Mörike-Häuser" provides a "forensic" socio-historical reconstruction of the domestic life of German poet Eduard Mörike. By cross-referencing the poet’s own architectural sketches with city archives, Simon challenges the "neurotic fugitive" myth of Mörike’s frequent moves, revealing instead the friction between 19th-century urban development and the poet’s need for creative sanctuary.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Scholars have long noted a "gap" between Eduard Mörike’s literary output and his chaotic personal life. Between 1851 and his death in 1875, Mörike moved his household at least ten times within Stuttgart. Previous biographers, such as Peter Härtling, characterized this instability as a "neurotic flight."
Simon tackles this by asking: What were the material and social realities of these living spaces? The work aims to move beyond psychological speculation to understand how the architecture of a rapidly industrializing Stuttgart—and the specific layout of Biedermeier-era apartments—impacted the poet’s daily existence and social standing.
Methods
The author employs a "micro-historical" and almost "criminological" approach to evidence gathering:
- Visual Analysis: Simon utilizes Mörike’s own prolific drawings of his living situations, treating them as primary data for spatial reconstruction.
- Archival Correlation: These sketches are compared against official floor plans and site maps from the Stuttgart City Archive.
- Textual Triangulation: The study incorporates a meticulous evaluation of letters and diaries from Mörike, his wife, and his sister Klara, drawing from the author's experience as an editor of the historical-critical edition of Mörike’s works.
- Social Mapping: The author uses an extensive "Zettelkasten" (index card system) to track the poet’s relationships with landlords, neighbors, and the evolving urban fabric of Stuttgart.
Datasets
The study is built upon a corpus of historical primary sources:
- 86 Illustrations: Including Mörike’s personal sketches and historical photographs.
- Stuttgart City Archives: Floor plans and urban development records from 1850–1875.
- The "Mörike-Zettelkasten": A vast personal database compiled by the author containing over 400 names and specific Stuttgarter street addresses.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Myth of the "Neurotic Fugitive": Simon suggests that Mörike’s frequent moves were less about psychological instability and more about the search for a functional "middle-class ideal" in a city undergoing massive industrial expansion.
- The Architecture of Privacy: The study highlights the difficulty of separating "living, sleeping, and working" in 19th-century apartments. Many units featured "walk-through rooms" (Durchgangszimmer), which offered little privacy for a writer.
- The "Öhrn" Conflict: A fascinating detail is the use of the "Öhrn" (a shared hallway/anteroom). In one residence (Hospitalstraße 36), the Mörike family had to cross a shared hallway where neighbors ate their meals just to reach their own kitchen, illustrating the lack of domestic boundaries in the era.
- Urban Transition: Mörike’s life coincided with Stuttgart’s transition from a sleepy royal residence to a crowded industrial metropolis, a shift that physically pushed the "old elite" and intellectuals out of the city center.
Key Results
- Mapping the "12 Stations": The book successfully documents 12 distinct living situations (ten apartments plus a garden house and his final resting place).
- Biographical Treasure Trove: The reviewer characterizes the work as a significant enrichment of Stuttgart’s local history and a vital resource for understanding the "outer framework" of a poet's daily life.
- Socio-Historical Context: Simon successfully places Mörike within the broader context of other intellectuals living in Stuttgart at the time, providing a comparative look at 19th-century "intellectual housing."
Limitations and Future Work
The reviewer, Raimund Waibel, notes several critical limitations regarding the book's academic rigor:
- Lack of Formal Citations: The author chose to omit footnotes, leaving many quoted sources "in the dark" and making it difficult for other researchers to verify specific claims.
- Speculative Conclusions: Some of the author’s psychological interpretations of Mörike’s feelings or his relationships with neighbors are described as "cleverly inferred" rather than strictly proven.
- Accessibility of Data: The reviewer expresses a desire for the author’s "Zettelkasten" (index card system) to be made publicly available (e.g., at the German Literature Archive in Marbach) to aid future researchers.
Summary updated