Reward salience but not spatial attention dominates the value representation in the orbitofrontal cortex

Wenyi Zhang, Yang Xie, Tianming YangNature Communications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) prioritizes reward salience over spatial attention when representing the value of stimuli. Even when monkeys were instructed to attend to a specific location, their OFC neurons primarily encoded the value of the more rewarding option, suggesting a stable, salience-driven value representation in this brain region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the brain makes decisions involves knowing how it represents the value of different options. The orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) is a key player in this process, but how attention influences its value representations is unclear. Previous research suggested that the OFC might represent the value of only the attended item, implying attention acts as a filter. However, these studies often relied on indirect measures of attention. This paper aims to directly investigate whether spatial attention, driven by explicit cues, modulates the OFC's value encoding, particularly when stimuli differ in both value and physical salience.

Methods

The researchers trained two macaque monkeys on a visual detection task. In this task, monkeys were presented with two visual stimuli, each associated with a different amount of juice reward (and thus, different reward salience). A cue indicated which stimulus would undergo a luminance change, directing the monkeys' spatial attention.

Key methods included:

  • Behavioral Task: A visual detection task with a Posner cueing paradigm. Monkeys had to detect a luminance change at a cued location.
  • Stimulus Design: Over-trained visual stimuli associated with varying juice rewards to create distinct levels of reward salience.
  • Neuronal Recordings: Extracellular recordings of single-unit activities from the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC).
  • Decoding Spatial Attention: Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) was used to decode the monkeys' spatial attention location from DLPFC neuronal activity, confirming they followed the cues.
  • Value Encoding Analysis: Linear regression models were employed to quantify the contribution of salient value (SV), non-salient value (NSV), cued value (CV), and uncued value (UCV) to neuronal responses in both OFC and DLPFC. Coefficients of Partial Determination (CPD) were calculated to measure the variance explained by each variable.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as distinct datasets. The study utilized data collected from two macaque monkeys performing the described behavioral task. The stimuli were pre-selected and associated with different reward values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OFC's Salience-First Approach: The OFC appears to prioritize reward salience above all else when representing value. Even when attention is explicitly directed elsewhere, the OFC neurons predominantly reflect the value of the more rewarding stimulus.
  • Dissociation of Attention and Value: The study provides strong evidence for a dissociation between the neural representations of spatial attention and value. Spatial attention signals are robust in the DLPFC, but their influence on OFC value encoding is minimal.
  • Bottom-Up vs. Top-Down Influence: While top-down spatial attention has little impact on OFC value encoding, bottom-up signals (like physical salience of the cue itself) can transiently influence OFC activity. This suggests OFC is more sensitive to intrinsic stimulus properties than directed attention.
  • DLPFC as a Hub for Both: In contrast to the OFC, the DLPFC shows strong representations of both spatial attention and reward salience, suggesting it integrates these different streams of information.

Key Results

  • Behavioral Confirmation: Monkeys reliably followed the spatial attention cues, as confirmed by their performance and DLPFC neuronal activity.
  • OFC Value Encoding: OFC neuronal responses were dominated by the stimulus's reward salience (SV). The value of the less salient stimulus (NSV) was only weakly represented, regardless of where attention was directed.
  • DLPFC Value Encoding: Similar to the OFC, DLPFC value encoding was also dominated by SV, with spatial attention having a weak modulatory effect.
  • Quantitative Evidence: Regression analyses showed that the coefficient of partial determination (CPD) for SV was significantly higher and more sustained in the OFC than for NSV. For the DLPFC, both SV and attention cue location had significant CPDs, but SV's dominance was still evident.
  • No Attention-Switching: In specific conditions designed to maximize attentional modulation (where attention was directed away from the most salient stimulus), the OFC neurons still primarily encoded the salient value, failing to switch their representation to the less salient, attended stimulus.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Species Differences: The authors acknowledge that OFC function can differ across species, and findings in rodents might not directly translate to primates.
  • Task Design: While the task was designed to isolate attention and salience, the random reward assignment meant neither cued nor salient value was a direct predictor of the outcome. The authors suggest future experiments could explore how reward expectancy interacts with attention.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that the stable representation of reward salience in the OFC, independent of top-down attention, might be crucial for evaluating potential targets before directing attention. Future work could investigate this hypothesis further.

Summary updated

Abstract

The orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) encodes value and plays a key role in value-based decision-making. However, the attentional modulation of the OFC's value encoding is poorly understood. We trained two monkeys to detect a luminance change at a cued location between a pair of visual stimuli, which were over-trained pictures associated with different amounts of juice reward and, thus, different reward salience. Both the monkeys' behavior and the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex neuronal activities indicated that the monkeys actively directed their spatial attention toward the cued stimulus during the task. However, the OFC's neuronal responses were dominated by the stimulus with higher reward salience and encoded its value. The value of the less salient stimulus was only weakly represented regardless of spatial attention. The results demonstrate that reward and spatial attention are distinctly represented in the prefrontal cortex and the OFC maintains a stable representation of reward salience minimally affected by attention.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022reward,
  author = {Wenyi Zhang and Yang Xie and Tianming Yang},
  title = {{Reward salience but not spatial attention dominates the value representation in the orbitofrontal cortex}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-34084-0},
}
Figure