Reward Redemption Effects in a Loyalty Program When Customers Choose How Much and When to Redeem

Matilda Dorotić, Peter C. Verhoef, Dennis Fok, Tammo H.a. BijmoltSSRN 2014

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the decision to redeem loyalty program rewards, not just the act itself, significantly boosts customer purchase behavior both before and after redemption. This "redemption momentum" effect, distinct from traditional "points pressure," suggests that loyalty programs can drive engagement even without strict expiry dates or high redemption thresholds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Loyalty programs (LPs) are ubiquitous, but their effectiveness, particularly around reward redemption, is not fully understood. While LPs aim to increase customer loyalty and purchases, it's unclear how reward redemption itself influences behavior, especially in programs where customers have flexibility in choosing when and how much to redeem, and where points don't expire. Traditional explanations often rely on "points pressure" (the urge to reach a threshold before expiry), but this paper investigates if redemption effects can occur even without such external pressures, exploring the interplay between purchase and redemption decisions in a more naturalistic setting.

Methods

The authors employ a sophisticated econometric model to analyze the complex, bi-directional relationship between purchase and redemption behavior. They use a simultaneous equation model to capture:

  • Purchase incidence: Whether a member makes a purchase.
  • Purchase amount: How much is spent.
  • Redemption decision: Whether to redeem points.
  • Redemption fraction: How much of the accumulated balance is redeemed.

A key methodological innovation is the modeling of redemption timing as an endogenous variable, allowing for the possibility that the decision to redeem precedes the actual redemption event. They also account for heterogeneity across members (age, income, membership duration) and the decay effects of mailings and post-reward impacts. Bayesian techniques (MCMC sampling) are used for parameter estimation due to the model's complexity.

Datasets

The study utilizes a rich dataset of 3,094 members from a nationwide coalition loyalty program in the Netherlands. This program features:

  • Continuous and linear rewarding (1 point per euro spent).
  • No points expiration.
  • A broad spectrum of redemption options.
  • Multiple partner vendors across various industries (grocery, gas retail, insurance, travel).

The data spans three and a half years (184 weeks), providing longitudinal information on members' points collection, redemptions, and socio-demographic characteristics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Redemption Momentum is Key: The most significant finding is that the decision to redeem, even if it happens days or weeks before the actual redemption, drives increased purchase behavior. This "redemption momentum" is a novel explanation for pre-reward effects, independent of points pressure.
  • Beyond Points Pressure: Traditional "points pressure" (driven by expiry or thresholds) plays a minor role. The data suggests that for most redemptions (97%), members redeem only a fraction of their balance, indicating they aren't solely motivated by reaching a specific goal before expiry.
  • Bi-directional Influence: Purchase behavior isn't just influenced by redemption; it also influences it. Increased purchases boost the LP's mental accessibility, making redemption more likely.
  • Long-Term Members are Different: Experienced members are less responsive to LP mechanisms like points pressure and redemption momentum, exhibiting more strategic behavior.
  • Age and Income Matter: Older members show stronger redemption momentum, while higher-income members are less influenced by it. Both age and income reinforce post-reward effects.

Key Results

  • Pre-reward Effects: For 69.5% of members, the decision to redeem leads to increased purchase frequency (1.763x) and amount (0.325x) in the weeks leading up to redemption. This effect is strongest within a week of the decision.
  • Points Pressure: Only about 3% of members show a significant increase in purchase likelihood due to points pressure.
  • Post-reward Effects: Members tend to purchase more often (0.033x) and increase their purchase amounts (0.031x) after redemption. This effect lasts for several weeks, with a decay rate of 0.734.
  • Accessibility: Increased purchases enhance LP accessibility, boosting redemption likelihood (0.039x) and purchase frequency/amount.
  • Long-term Members: Effects are less pronounced for long-term members, who show declining purchase trends over time.
  • Mailings: Mailings have a positive impact on purchase and redemption, but their effectiveness declines with increased frequency, suggesting potential member fatigue.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study is based on a single LP in the Netherlands, limiting generalizability to other LP designs or countries.
  • Vendor-Level Analysis: The study aggregated data across vendors, missing potential differences in reward effects across individual partners in coalition LPs. Future research could explore this.
  • Selection Effect: The analysis focused on members who had redeemed at least once, potentially creating a selection bias relative to non-redeemers.
  • Cost Structure Unknown: The study couldn't fully analyze profit implications due to missing cost structure data.
  • Theoretical Depth: More theoretical work is needed on the psychological mechanisms driving redemption momentum and other effects in continuous LPs without expiry.
  • Emotional Drivers: Future research could explore the emotional drivers of LP behavior, such as excitement and feelings associated with redemption.
  • Heterogeneous Thresholds: The assumption of common points-pressure thresholds across members could be relaxed in future studies.
  • Mailing Content: The study analyzed mailing frequency but not content, which could be a fruitful area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

The redemption of loyalty program (LP) rewards has an important impact on LP members’ behavior, particularly on purchase behavior before and after redeeming a reward. However, little is known about the interplay between members’ purchase and redemption behavior when members are not pressured with points expiration and they choose for themselves when and how much to redeem. In this context, the effects of redemption are not straightforward, as little additional effort is required from an LP member to obtain the reward. Analyzing the behavior of 3,094 members in such an LP, we find that the mere decision to redeem a reward significantly enhances purchase behavior before and after the redemption event, even when members redeem just a fraction of their accumulated points. Conceptually, we refer to this enhancement as the redemption momentum, which is an alternative and novel explanation of the existence of pre-reward effects that does not depend on points-pressure. In addition to the overall impact of redemption on purchases, prior purchase behavior also enhances redemption decisions. Finally, we find a number of moderating effects on purchase and redemption behavior that derive from the length of LP membership, age, income and direct mailings. Our study’s most important managerial implication is that firms can avoid imposing binding thresholds and/or points expiry and still enhance members’ purchase behavior.
BibTeX
@misc{dorotic2014reward,
  author = {Matilda Dorotić and Peter C. Verhoef and Dennis Fok and Tammo H.A. Bijmolt},
  title = {{Reward Redemption Effects in a Loyalty Program When Customers Choose How Much and When to Redeem}},
  year = {2014},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure