Abstract
Previous research demonstrated that cognitive conflict could induce an affective priming effect, and the stage (detection/resolution) of conflict processing led to different directions (positive/negative) of the affective priming effect. We suggested that rewards play a critical role in the affective priming effect on conflict resolution. The present study used event-related potentials (ERPs), using the arrow flanker task as primes and choosing specific affective words as targets to investigate the affective priming effect induced by cognitive conflict during the resolution stage. Our question was whether rewards created a modulating effect. Participants were asked to judge the congruency of the prime stimuli and then evaluate the valence of the target words. For behavioral results, the conflict effect was significant, and the reward promoted the behavioral performance of participants. For ERP results, enhanced N2 amplitudes for incongruent primes indicated a significant conflict effect. More importantly, as expected, in the rewarded condition, the enhanced N400 amplitudes for positive targets following incongruent primes were found, indicating a positive priming effect. However, in the unrewarded condition, the reduced N400 amplitudes for positive targets following incongruent primes were found, indicating conflict resolution hindered the processing of positive stimuli. These findings suggested that cognitive conflict-induced the positive priming effect during the resolution stage and that rewards had a moderating effect on the positive priming effect.
Introduction
In cognitive psychology, "conflict" occurs when the brain must filter out distracting information to focus on a specific goal—a process often exemplified by the Flanker task (e.g., ignoring the middle arrow in a set like <<><<). Traditionally, researchers have characterized this conflict as inherently "aversive," suggesting it triggers a negative emotional state. However, recent evidence suggests that the resolution of that conflict might actually be experienced as rewarding, leading to a "positive priming" effect where individuals are faster to process positive stimuli following a difficult task.
This study addresses the inconsistency in these findings: Why does conflict sometimes feel aversive and other times rewarding? The authors hypothesize that external reward acts as a moderating factor. They set out to determine if an explicit reward is necessary to transform the mental effort of conflict resolution into a positive emotional state, using electrophysiological markers to track these shifts in real-time.
Methods
Participants and Stimuli
The researchers recruited 34 university students (data from 32 were analyzed after quality filtering). Stimuli included 120 Chinese words (60 positive, 60 negative) selected from the Chinese Affective Words System (CAWS), carefully controlled for frequency, valence, and arousal levels. The cognitive task utilized standard arrow flanker configurations.
Experimental Paradigm
The study employed a dual-task paradigm combined with Event-Related Potentials (ERPs) to track brain activity with millisecond precision. Each trial followed a specific sequence:
- The Prime (Arrow Flanker Task): Participants indicated the direction of a center arrow. "Congruent" trials (arrows in the same direction) were easy, while "Incongruent" trials (center arrow different) created cognitive conflict.
- The Moderator (Reward): In half the trials, a correct and fast response earned a "+1" reward symbol. In the other half, participants received a neutral symbol.
- The Target (Affective Word Task): Immediately following feedback, participants were shown a Chinese word and asked to judge its emotional valence (positive or negative).
Results
Behavioral Performance
Behavioral data confirmed a robust "conflict effect." Participants were significantly faster and more accurate on congruent trials compared to incongruent trials. Furthermore, the presence of a reward generally improved reaction times across all conditions, suggesting that the incentive successfully motivated participants.
Electrophysiological Evidence
The study focused on two primary ERP components: the N2 (associated with conflict detection) and the N400 (associated with affective processing).
- Conflict Detection (N2): Incongruent trials triggered significantly larger N2 waves than congruent trials, providing biological evidence that the brain successfully detected the cognitive conflict.
- Affective Priming (N400): The N400 served as a marker for emotional "mismatch."
- In the Rewarded Condition, difficult (incongruent) trials followed by positive words elicited enhanced N400 amplitudes. This indicates a positive priming effect; the brain was primed for positivity by the successful, rewarded resolution of conflict.
- In the Unrewarded Condition, the N400 for positive words was reduced following incongruent trials. This suggests that without an external payoff, the mental effort of the task actually hindered the brain's ability to process positive information.
Discussion
The findings suggest that cognitive conflict is a multi-stage process where the resolution stage can be modulated by external incentives. The most striking insight is that reward acts as a "switch": without it, resolving a difficult task does not inherently feel good. In fact, unrewarded conflict resolution appears to leave the brain in a state that makes processing positive stimuli more difficult.
While this study provides strong evidence for the role of rewards, it is limited by a relatively homogeneous sample of university students. Future research should explore how these effects vary in populations with different affective traits (such as anxiety) and whether different types of rewards—such as social praise or tangible monetary gains—produce similar moderating effects on the cognitive-emotional interface.
Summary updated