Reward-enhanced encoding improves relearning of forgotten associations

Ewa A. Miendlarzewska, Sara Ciucci, Carlo Vittorio Cannistraci, Daphné Bavelier, Sophie SchwartzScientific 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Research on human memory has shown that monetary incentives can enhance hippocampal memory consolidation and thereby protect memory traces from forgetting. However, it is not known whether initial reward may facilitate the recovery of already forgotten memories weeks after learning. Here, we investigated the influence of monetary reward on later relearning. Nineteen healthy human participants learned object-location associations, for half of which we offered money. Six weeks later, most of these associations had been forgotten as measured by a test of declarative memory. Yet, relearning in the absence of any reward was faster for the originally rewarded associations. Thus, associative memories encoded in a state of monetary reward motivation may persist in a latent form despite the failure to retrieve them explicitly. Alternatively, such facilitation could be analogous to the renewal effect observed in animal conditioning, whereby a reward-associated cue can reinstate anticipatory arousal, which would in turn modulate relearning. This finding has important implications for learning and education, suggesting that even when learned information is no longer accessible via explicit retrieval, the enduring effects of a past prospect of reward could facilitate its recovery.

Introduction

It is well-established that monetary incentives during the learning phase can significantly boost memory consolidation, primarily through the hippocampal-VTA (ventral tegmental area) loop. However, the long-term persistence of this "reward boost" remains a subject of investigation. Specifically, researchers sought to determine if a reward offered during initial encoding could facilitate the recovery of memories that have since been forgotten. This study explores whether such memories are truly erased or if they persist in a latent, accessible state.

Methods

The study utilized a two-session behavioral paradigm involving 19 healthy participants.

Experimental Procedure

In Session 1, participants were tasked with learning 72 unique object-location associations. To manipulate motivation, half of the trials were designated as "rewarded" (cued by a piggy bank icon), while the other half were "non-rewarded" (cued by a cross).

Overview of the experimental design, showing the two-session structure and trial types for encoding and recall.

Session 2 occurred six weeks later. It began with a Delayed Recall test to measure explicit memory retention. Following this, participants underwent a Relearning phase consisting of three cycles. Crucially, no rewards were offered during this second session, allowing researchers to isolate the residual effects of the initial incentive.

Data Analysis

Performance was evaluated using accuracy, Reaction Time (RT), and Distance-To-Target (DTT), which measures spatial precision. To identify subtle behavioral signatures of reward, the team employed unsupervised machine learning techniques, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Minimum Curvilinear Embedding (MCE), a non-linear dimensionality reduction tool.

Detailed timeline of Session 2, highlighting the delayed recall and the three subsequent relearning cycles.

Key Results

Initial Learning and Explicit Forgetting

As expected, rewarded items were learned more effectively in Session 1 (75.6% vs. 55.4% accuracy). By Session 2, six weeks later, explicit recall for both categories had dropped to near-chance levels (~21%), with no statistically significant difference between originally rewarded and non-rewarded items. At this point, the memories appeared to be forgotten.

The Latent Reward Advantage

Despite the failure of explicit recall, the original reward status significantly influenced relearning. In the first cycle of Session 2, participants relearned rewarded associations with higher accuracy and lower DTT than non-rewarded ones. This advantage was most prominent in the first cycle and diminished as participants reached a performance ceiling in cycles 2 and 3.

Computational Validation

The MCE algorithm successfully separated behavioral data points based on their original reward status, confirming that the initial incentive left a persistent, albeit latent, signature on how information is re-encoded.

Discussion and Implications

The results suggest that reward-enhanced encoding creates a "privileged" memory trace that survives even when explicit retrieval fails. This effect may be driven by "anticipatory arousal"—a state reinstated by re-exposure to the original stimuli, facilitating faster re-encoding.

These findings have practical implications for education and professional training. They suggest that "gamifying" or rewarding the initial acquisition of knowledge could make future "refresher" courses significantly more effective, even if the material has not been used for years. Future research using neuroimaging is required to map the specific neural circuits, likely involving the hippocampus and midbrain reward centers, that maintain these latent traces.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research on human memory has shown that monetary incentives can enhance hippocampal memory consolidation and thereby protect memory traces from forgetting. However, it is not known whether initial reward may facilitate the recovery of already forgotten memories weeks after learning. Here, we investigated the influence of monetary reward on later relearning. Nineteen healthy human participants learned object-location associations, for half of which we offered money. Six weeks later, most of these associations had been forgotten as measured by a test of declarative memory. Yet, relearning in the absence of any reward was faster for the originally rewarded associations. Thus, associative memories encoded in a state of monetary reward motivation may persist in a latent form despite the failure to retrieve them explicitly. Alternatively, such facilitation could be analogous to the renewal effect observed in animal conditioning, whereby a reward-associated cue can reinstate anticipatory arousal, which would in turn modulate relearning. This finding has important implications for learning and education, suggesting that even when learned information is no longer accessible via explicit retrieval, the enduring effects of a past prospect of reward could facilitate its recovery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{miendlarzewska2018reward,
  author = {Ewa A. Miendlarzewska and Sara Ciucci and Carlo Vittorio Cannistraci and Daphné Bavelier and Sophie Schwartz},
  title = {{Reward-enhanced encoding improves relearning of forgotten associations}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-26929-w},
}
Figure