Revisiting enteric methane emissions from domestic ruminants and their δ13CCH4 source signature

Jinfeng Chang, Shushi Peng, Philippe Ciais, Marielle Saunois, Shree R. S. Dangal, Mario Herrero, Peter Havlík, Hanqin Tian, Philippe BousquetNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study revises estimates of methane emissions from domestic ruminants and their isotopic signature (δ¹³C), revealing a larger contribution to the recent increase in global methane and a greater influence on the atmospheric δ¹³C trend than previously thought. By developing a detailed global, time-dependent dataset of ruminant diet composition, methane emissions, and their isotopic signatures from 1961-2012, the research provides crucial insights for refining global methane budgets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately accounting for methane (CH₄) emissions is critical for understanding and mitigating climate change, as it's the second-largest driver of global radiative forcing after CO₂. A key challenge in tracking methane sources is distinguishing between biogenic (e.g., from livestock, wetlands), fossil fuel, and pyrogenic (e.g., biomass burning) emissions. The ¹³C isotopic signature (δ¹³C) of methane is a powerful tool for this, as different sources have distinct isotopic fingerprints.

Domestic ruminants (cattle, buffaloes, goats, and sheep) are the largest anthropogenic source of methane, primarily through enteric fermentation. However, understanding the global average, geographical distribution, and temporal variations of the δ¹³C of these emissions has been a significant knowledge gap. This lack of precise data limits the accuracy of both "bottom-up" (emission inventories) and "top-down" (atmospheric inversions) approaches to global methane budgeting. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a more refined and comprehensive dataset for ruminant methane emissions and their isotopic signatures.

Methods

The authors developed a multi-faceted approach to estimate ruminant methane emissions and their isotopic signatures:

  • C3-C4 Diet Composition: They created a global, time-dependent dataset of the C3-C4 diet composition for domestic ruminants. This involved separating concentrate feeds consumed by ruminants from those consumed by pigs and poultry using FAOSTAT data and a feed model. They also estimated grass and other feed consumption based on ruminant energy requirements.
  • Methane Emission Estimation: They revised yearly enteric CH₄ emissions (FCH₄-ruminant) using an IPCC Tier 2 approach, which incorporates country-specific data on gross energy intake and methane conversion factors, allowing for more detailed parameterization of rumen fermentation.
  • Isotopic Signature Estimation: A key innovation was establishing a relationship between the δ¹³C of ruminant diet (δ¹³Cdiet) and the δ¹³C of enteric methane emissions (δ¹³CCH₄-ruminant). This relationship was derived from published observations and then used to estimate national and time-dependent isotopic signatures from 1961 to 2012. They also accounted for the influence of decreasing atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C on plant isotopic signatures.
  • Model Simulations: A time-dependent one-box model of the CH₄ budget was used to assess the impact of their revised estimates on atmospheric CH₄ concentration and its isotopic signature. They ran simulations to isolate the effects of revised emissions and revised isotopic signatures.

Datasets

The study utilized several key datasets:

  • FAOSTAT: This provided annual national statistics on live animal stocks, slaughter numbers, milk and meat yields, and concentrate feed commodities for the period 1961-2012.
  • Published Literature: Observations of δ¹³CCH₄-ruminant and associated δ¹³Cdiet or diet composition data from various studies were compiled to establish the empirical relationship between diet and methane isotopic signatures.
  • Scripps CO₂ Program: Data on atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C was used to adjust the isotopic signature of plant biomass over time.
  • CRU-NCEP: Gridded precipitation and temperature data were used to derive C3-C4 grass distributions.
  • MsTMIP: Gridded C3-C4 grass distribution data was utilized.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced, but the study synthesized and integrated existing data to create novel time-series and spatially resolved estimates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diet is Key to Isotopic Signature: The ¹³C signature of ruminant methane is strongly influenced by the C3 vs. C4 plant composition of their diet. This highlights the importance of understanding agricultural practices and plant distribution in determining methane's isotopic fingerprint.
  • Temporal and Regional Shifts Matter: The study emphasizes that both the amount of methane emitted and its isotopic signature have changed over time and vary significantly by region. This dynamic nature is crucial for accurate global accounting.
  • Ruminant Impact on Atmospheric Trends: The revised estimates suggest that ruminant methane emissions play a larger role in the recent increase in atmospheric methane and the observed decrease in its ¹³C signature than previously understood. This implies that changes in livestock production are a significant factor in atmospheric methane dynamics.
  • CO₂ Fertilization's Complex Isotopic Effect: While rising atmospheric CO₂ can influence plant water-use efficiency and thus their isotopic signature, the net effect on ruminant diet δ¹³C is complex and not always a simple decrease, requiring careful consideration.

Key Results

  • Increased Methane Emissions: Global enteric methane emissions from ruminants doubled from 48.5 ± 5.6 Tg CH₄ yr⁻¹ in 1961 to 99.0 ± 11.7 Tg CH₄ yr⁻¹ in 2012.
  • Revised Isotopic Signature: The global mean δ¹³CCH₄-ruminant slightly decreased from -64.49‰ in 1961 to -64.93‰ in 2012. While seemingly small, this trend, combined with regional variations, has significant implications.
  • Larger Contribution to Recent Methane Increase: The revised estimates suggest a larger contribution of ruminant enteric emissions to the increasing trend in global methane emissions between 2000 and 2012.
  • Influence on Atmospheric δ¹³C: The study indicates a larger contribution of ruminant emissions to the observed decrease in the δ¹³C of atmospheric methane, particularly in recent decades. Model simulations showed that revised emissions and isotopic signatures could explain a significant portion of the observed decrease in atmospheric δ¹³C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Feed Model Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge uncertainties in their simple feed model, particularly regarding the allocation of concentrate feeds to pigs and poultry, and the assumptions made about feed digestibility.
  • Spatial and Temporal Variability of Plant Isotopes: While they accounted for the global trend of decreasing atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C, the potential effects of latitudinal gradients and seasonality of CO₂ on plant isotopic signatures were not fully addressed.
  • Model Simplifications: The one-box model used for simulations is a simplification of the complex atmospheric system.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future isotopic mass balance studies should incorporate their revised source estimates and isotopic signatures. Further research is needed to refine feed models, better understand the spatial and temporal variability of plant isotopic signatures, and potentially incorporate more complex atmospheric models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate knowledge of <sup>13</sup>C isotopic signature (δ<sup>13</sup>C) of methane from each source is crucial for separating biogenic, fossil fuel and pyrogenic emissions in bottom-up and top-down methane budget. Livestock production is the largest anthropogenic source in the global methane budget, mostly from enteric fermentation of domestic ruminants. However, the global average, geographical distribution and temporal variations of the δ<sup>13</sup>C of enteric emissions are not well understood yet. Here, we provide a new estimation of C3-C4 diet composition of domestic ruminants (cattle, buffaloes, goats and sheep), a revised estimation of yearly enteric CH<sub>4</sub> emissions, and a new estimation for the evolution of its δ<sup>13</sup>C during the period 1961-2012. Compared to previous estimates, our results suggest a larger contribution of ruminants' enteric emissions to the increasing trend in global methane emissions between 2000 and 2012, and also a larger contribution to the observed decrease in the δ<sup>13</sup>C of atmospheric methane.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chang2019revisiting,
  author = {Jinfeng Chang and Shushi Peng and Philippe Ciais and Marielle Saunois and Shree R. S. Dangal and Mario Herrero and Peter Havlík and Hanqin Tian and Philippe Bousquet},
  title = {{Revisiting enteric methane emissions from domestic ruminants and their δ13CCH4 source signature}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-11066-3},
}
Figure