Reviews and Responses for Evaluating Potential Fuel-Savings of External Alternative Ground Propulsion Systems

Manuel Waltert, Benoit Figuet, Michael Felux, Xavier Olivé, Martin Strohmeier, Tatiana PolishchukJournal of Open Aviation Science 2025 · DOI

This document represents an editorial "Reviews and Responses" piece for a study published in the Journal of Open Aviation Science. It details the peer-review process for a paper evaluating the fuel-saving potential of Alternative Ground Propulsion Systems (AGPS)—such as electric tugs—at Zurich Airport.

TL;DR

By leveraging high-fidelity ADS-B trajectory data from the OpenSky Network, this research moves beyond simplistic taxi models to accurately quantify fuel savings from external aircraft towing. The study demonstrates that targeting specific high-impact runways and long-haul flights can yield massive emissions reductions even with a limited fleet of propulsion units.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aircraft taxiing is a significant source of ground-level emissions and fuel waste. While Alternative Ground Propulsion Systems (AGPS)—like the "Taxibot" or "WheelTug"—promise to reduce this by moving aircraft without using their main engines, calculating the actual Return on Investment (ROI) is difficult.

Most existing models rely on simplistic "average taxi times" that fail to account for real-world airport congestion, specific runway configurations, or pilot behavior. This paper addresses the need for a data-driven, high-resolution assessment of AGPS potential using actual observed flight trajectories rather than theoretical estimates.

Methods

The authors developed a framework to process and analyze surface movement data:

  • Trajectory Analysis: Using the traffic Python library, the authors created custom functions to identify specific phases of ground movement, such as pushback and takeoff rolls.
  • Pattern Recognition: They implemented an "alternative classification method" to detect complex pushback patterns (S-shape, U-shape, and L-shape) which are often missed by standard algorithms.
  • Fuel Flow Modeling: By connecting ICAO Emission Databank values with observed taxi durations, the authors estimated fuel burn under the assumption that engines remain in "idle" during traditional taxiing.
  • Optimization via Bin-Packing: To simulate a realistic scenario with a limited number of AGPS units, the authors used a bin-packing algorithm to determine how many flights could be serviced by a finite fleet of tugs.

Datasets

  • OpenSky Network (OSN): Five months of ADS-B based surface trajectory data from Zurich Airport (LSZH).
  • FZAG (Zurich Airport Ltd.) Statistics: Official airport reports (59,222 departures) used to validate the completeness of the ADS-B dataset.
  • ICAO Aircraft Emission Databank: Used for fuel flow and consumption coefficients for various turbojet aircraft types.
  • Traffic Library: An open-source library used for air traffic data processing, to which the authors contributed their new track_based takeoff detection method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Runway 16" Strategy: The authors found that focusing AGPS exclusively on Runway 16—primarily used by heavy, long-haul aircraft—is highly efficient. These aircraft have higher fuel burn rates and longer taxi distances, making them the "low-hanging fruit" for emissions reduction.
  • Data Reliability Hurdles: A significant insight is the "transponder gap." Pilots often don't activate transponders until midway through a taxi, leading to incomplete data. The authors implemented stringent filters (e.g., filtering groundspeed jumps >200 knots) to ensure noisy data didn't skew the results.
  • Diminishing Returns in Fleet Size: The results suggest that a "significant part" of the total fuel-saving potential can be realized with a relatively small number of AGPS units. This is crucial for airports looking for cost-effective ways to start their decarbonization journey.
  • Validation of "Idle" Assumptions: While the model assumes engines are in idle, the authors acknowledge that real-world factors like aircraft mass and acceleration are often ignored in literature, representing a standard but notable limitation in current aviation research.

Key Results

  • Total Potential: If all departing turbojet aircraft at Zurich Airport were towed to their respective runways over the 5-month study period, an estimated 5,178.6 tons of fuel could have been saved.
  • Targeted Impact: Limiting AGPS usage to just Runway 16 departures still results in a saving of 1,574.0 tons of fuel.
  • Per-Movement Metrics: The study estimates an average taxi fuel consumption of 190.69 kg per movement across all types, and 152.42 kg specifically for the ubiquitous Airbus A320 family.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Physics: The current model does not account for aircraft mass, ground acceleration, or varying meteorological conditions, which can all impact fuel flow.
  • Scheduling Logistics: The authors used bin-packing for simplicity but admit it may not yield the optimal real-world schedule. They plan to address constrained resource allocation in future work (specifically for the ATRS 2025 conference).
  • Economic Analysis: While the fuel savings are clear, a full cost-benefit analysis—including the purchase, maintenance, and operational costs of the AGPS units themselves—remains a task for future research.
  • Data Gaps: The study excluded turboprops and business jets due to a lack of open-access fuel consumption data for those specific categories.

Summary updated

Abstract

See detailed reviews and responses in the PDF file. DOI for the original paper: https://doi.org/10.59490/joas.2024.7888
BibTeX
@article{waltert2025reviews,
  author = {Manuel Waltert and Benoit Figuet and Michael Felux and Xavier Olivé and Martin Strohmeier and Tatiana Polishchuk},
  title = {{Reviews and Responses for Evaluating Potential Fuel-Savings of External Alternative Ground Propulsion Systems}},
  journal = {Journal of Open Aviation Science},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.59490/joas.2024.8170},
}
Figure