Review on Application of Hybrid Energy Storage Based on Ultracapacitor

Xiao-bin Yang, Heming Li, Zhe Jiang, He Wang, Zhongdong YinProceedings of the 2nd International Conference On Systems Engineering and Modeling 2013 · DOI

Abstract

This paper introduces the characteristics and classic equivalent models of ultracapacitors. Due to their superior power performance, ultracapacitors are increasingly integrated into hybrid energy storage systems (HESS) alongside lead-acid batteries. This review elaborates on the performance benefits and potential industrial applications of HESS, contributing to the broader promotion of advanced energy storage technologies.

1. Introduction

Traditional energy storage systems rely heavily on lead-acid batteries. While these batteries offer high energy density, they suffer from significant limitations, including poor handling of deep discharges, slow response to sudden power spikes, and a relatively short cycle life. Conversely, standard capacitors offer fast response but negligible energy storage capacity.

As the global transition toward renewable energy and electric vehicles accelerates, there is a growing need for systems capable of managing "bursty" power demands—such as motor start-up inrushes or regenerative braking surges. Hybrid Energy Storage Systems (HESS) bridge this gap by combining high-capacity batteries with high-power ultracapacitors.

2. Modeling and Methodology

To analyze and predict system behavior, the authors utilize the "Classic Equivalent Model" for ultracapacitors. This model simplifies complex electrochemical dynamics into a manageable circuit.

Classic equivalent circuit model for an ultracapacitor.

As shown in Figure 1, the model consists of a serial resistor ($R_s$), a shunt resistor ($R_p$), and an ideal capacitance ($C_c$). This framework allows engineers to calculate energy losses and system efficiency with high reliability. The HESS architecture typically employs a parallel configuration where the ultracapacitor acts as a high-frequency filter, absorbing the "shocks" of fluctuating load currents.

3. The Buffer Effect and System Efficiency

The primary advantage of the HESS is the "buffer effect." By bearing the brunt of rapid load fluctuations, the ultracapacitor protects the battery from the thermal stress associated with internal resistance—the leading cause of battery degradation.

Current waveforms showing the buffering effect of the ultracapacitor.

Figure 3 illustrates this synergy: while the load current exhibits sharp pulses, the ultracapacitor current ($I_c$) reacts instantaneously to meet these peaks. Consequently, the battery current ($I_b$) remains smoothed and low-intensity. This management not only extends battery life but also improves overall energy efficiency by reducing heat waste during peak loads.

4. Performance Analysis and Industrial Impact

The performance metrics of ultracapacitors are starkly superior to batteries in specific areas. Ultracapacitors offer a specific power of 1000–2000 W/kg and a service life exceeding 10,000 cycles, whereas lead-acid batteries typically provide only 50–200 W/kg and 500–2000 cycles.

In industrial settings, such as motor start-up applications, HESS can replace multiple expensive frequency converters with a single bi-directional inverter and an ultracapacitor bank. This reduces initial investment costs while ensuring smoother operation and the ability to capture regenerative braking energy that would otherwise be lost as heat.

5. Conclusion and Future Directions

While the simplified classic model is effective for general analysis, high-precision engineering may require more complex Debye or transmission line models. Furthermore, the high initial cost of ultracapacitors remains a barrier to universal adoption. Future research should focus on optimizing manufacturing processes and further integrating HESS into smart grids and electric vehicle infrastructure to leverage their full potential in the modern energy landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Characteristics of ultracapacitor and classic model have been introduced in this paper. Due to its superior performance, ultracapacitor is used for hybrid energy storage system with lead-acid battery. The performance and potential application of hybrid energy storage system have been elaborated, which make some contribution to the promotion and application of energy storage technology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2013review,
  author = {Xiao-bin Yang and Heming Li and Zhe Jiang and He Wang and Zhongdong Yin},
  title = {{Review on Application of Hybrid Energy Storage Based on Ultracapacitor}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference On Systems Engineering and Modeling},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.2991/icsem.2013.60},
}
Figure