Review of robotic systems for thoracoabdominal puncture interventional surgery

Cheng Wang, Li Guo, Jianjun Zhu, Lifeng Zhu, Chichi Li, Hai‐Dong Zhu, Aiguo Song, Ligong Lu, Gao‐Jun Teng, Nassir Navab, Zhongliang JiangAPL 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review paper surveys the landscape of robotic systems designed for thoracoabdominal puncture interventional surgery, highlighting their potential to overcome the limitations of manual procedures. It delves into the critical enabling technologies, from spatial registration and navigation to advanced feedback mechanisms and motion compensation, offering a comprehensive overview of the current state and future directions in this rapidly evolving field.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional manual puncture interventional surgery, while minimally invasive, is heavily reliant on surgeon experience, leading to challenges in precision, safety, and efficacy. This is particularly true for complex procedures in the thoracoabdominal region, where factors like respiratory motion and the soft, deformable nature of tissues make accurate needle placement difficult. These limitations contribute to longer procedure times, increased radiation exposure for patients and staff, and potential for suboptimal treatment outcomes. The paper addresses the need for robotic systems that can enhance precision, improve safety, and reduce the learning curve associated with these critical surgical interventions.

Methods

The paper provides a comprehensive review of existing PISR systems, categorizing them based on their level of automation in positioning and needle insertion. It then systematically discusses the key technological components that underpin these systems:

  • Spatial Registration and Positioning Navigation: This involves accurately mapping preoperative medical images (CT, MRI) to the patient's anatomy in real-time. Techniques discussed include rigid and non-rigid registration, with a focus on the challenges posed by soft tissue deformation and the need for robust methods like deep learning-based approaches. Positioning navigation relies on mechanical, electromagnetic, or optical methods, with optical systems generally offering higher precision.
  • Puncture Guidance Feedback Technology: This encompasses methods to provide real-time information to guide the robotic system and surgeon. Visual feedback (ultrasound, near-infrared) and force feedback are explored, along with emerging technologies like Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG) sensors for precise shape sensing of instruments.
  • Respiratory Motion Compensation Technology: Crucial for thoracoabdominal procedures, this area focuses on accounting for the involuntary movement of organs due to breathing. Strategies include developing respiratory motion models, real-time target tracking using imaging, and external respiratory signal tracking via markers.
  • Motion Control Technology: This covers the control of both the robotic manipulator and the puncture needle itself. It examines manipulator motion control, including teleoperation and autonomous control, and needle motion control, distinguishing between flexible and rigid needles and discussing teleoperation and autonomous approaches for needle advancement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review and does not present new experimental data or introduce new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Experience Gap" is a Major Hurdle: The paper strongly emphasizes that traditional manual puncture relies heavily on surgeon experience, creating a significant barrier to entry and consistency. Robotic systems aim to democratize precision.
  • Respiratory Motion is the Nemesis: For thoracoabdominal interventions, patient breathing is a primary challenge that significantly impacts needle accuracy. Addressing this is paramount for effective robotic surgery in this region.
  • Multimodal Feedback is the Future: Relying solely on visual feedback is insufficient. The paper highlights the growing importance of integrating force, tactile, and even FBG sensor data to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the surgical environment and instrument interaction.
  • Flexible Needles Offer New Possibilities: The development of flexible needles, both passive and active, opens doors for more intricate maneuvers and the ability to navigate around vital structures, a significant advantage over rigid needles.
  • Deep Learning is Revolutionizing Registration: The paper points to deep learning as a powerful tool for improving the accuracy and efficiency of medical image registration, a foundational step for robotic guidance.

Key Results

As this is a review paper, it does not present specific quantitative results from new experiments. Instead, it synthesizes the findings from numerous existing studies. The "results" are in the form of a comprehensive overview of the capabilities and limitations of current PISR systems and the technologies that enable them. The paper highlights that while PISR systems have demonstrated improvements in accuracy and stability compared to manual methods, significant challenges remain, particularly in achieving real-time, robust compensation for soft tissue deformation and respiratory motion.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Soft Tissue Deformation: Accurately modeling and compensating for the complex deformation of soft tissues remains a significant challenge.
  • Respiratory Motion Compensation: While progress has been made, achieving perfect real-time compensation for respiratory motion is still an open problem.
  • Needle Tip Tracking: Real-time, precise tracking of the needle tip within the body, especially in soft tissues, is difficult and often requires multiple imaging sessions.
  • Integration of Technologies: A key future direction is the enhanced integration of various sensing modalities (optical, force, ultrasound, FBG) and advanced AI techniques (like LLMs) to create more intelligent and perceptive PISR systems.
  • Hardware Innovation: There is a need for innovative robot hardware designs that can minimize patient trauma, especially for procedures requiring multiple punctures.
  • Enhanced Perception: Future PISR systems should aim for enhanced multi-dimensional perception, integrating a wider range of sensory inputs for a more holistic understanding of the surgical environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cancer, with high morbidity and high mortality, is one of the major burdens threatening human health globally. Intervention procedures via percutaneous puncture have been widely used by physicians due to its minimally invasive surgical approach. However, traditional manual puncture intervention depends on personal experience and faces challenges in terms of precisely puncture, learning-curve, safety and efficacy. The development of puncture interventional surgery robotic (PISR) systems could alleviate the aforementioned problems to a certain extent. This paper attempts to review the current status and prospective of PISR systems for thoracic and abdominal application. In this review, the key technologies related to the robotics, including spatial registration, positioning navigation, puncture guidance feedback, respiratory motion compensation, and motion control, are discussed in detail.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024review,
  author = {Cheng Wang and Li Guo and Jianjun Zhu and Lifeng Zhu and Chichi Li and Hai‐Dong Zhu and Aiguo Song and Ligong Lu and Gao‐Jun Teng and Nassir Navab and Zhongliang Jiang},
  title = {{Review of robotic systems for thoracoabdominal puncture interventional surgery}},
  booktitle = {APL},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1063/5.0180494},
}
Figure