TL;DR
Researchers have found that optimizing the dimerization properties of fluorescent proteins (FPs) is crucial for maximizing the dynamic range of FRET-based biological indicators. Specifically, FPs with a weak dimerization tendency, rather than strong dimerization or monomeric forms, lead to indicators that can detect subtle biological changes with greater sensitivity and precision.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Genetically encoded Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based indicators are powerful tools for visualizing dynamic biological processes in living cells, such as the activity of second messengers or signaling pathways. These indicators work by linking a "sensor" domain between two fluorescent proteins (a donor and an acceptor). When the sensor domain undergoes a conformational change (e.g., due to binding a specific molecule like Ca²⁺ or ATP), it alters the distance and/or orientation between the FPs, leading to a measurable change in FRET efficiency.
However, a significant challenge in developing these indicators is achieving a large "dynamic range" – the difference between the signal in the "off" and "on" states. Many existing indicators show only small changes in FRET efficiency, making it difficult to detect subtle biological events. Current strategies to improve this dynamic range involve optimizing linker lengths between the FPs and the sensor domain, and carefully controlling the relative orientation of the FP chromophores. This paper investigates a less explored but critical factor: the inherent tendency of the FPs themselves to dimerize.
Methods
The researchers systematically investigated the impact of FP dimerization on FRET-based indicator performance. They utilized several well-established FRET-based indicators:
- Cameleon (YC3.60): A Ca²⁺ indicator.
- TN-XL: Another Ca²⁺ indicator.
- ATeam: An ATP indicator.
They created variants of these indicators by introducing specific mutations into the fluorescent proteins. These mutations were designed to alter the FP dimerization properties:
- Monomer-associated mutations (e.g., A206K): These mutations aim to disrupt FP dimerization, making the FPs more monomeric.
- Dimer-enhancing mutations (e.g., S208F/V224L): These mutations are known to promote FP dimerization.
- Native FP variants: Used as controls, representing the natural dimerization behavior.
The researchers then performed:
- In vitro spectroscopic analyses: Measuring fluorescence spectra and FRET efficiency changes in purified protein samples under varying conditions (e.g., presence or absence of Ca²⁺ or ATP).
- Ca²⁺ titration assays: Quantifying the binding affinity (K<0xE1><0xB5><0x80>) of Ca²⁺ indicators to Ca²⁺.
- Live-cell imaging: Transfecting cells with the indicator variants and observing their responses to stimuli (e.g., histamine for Ca²⁺, or ATP depletion for ATP indicators) to assess dynamic range in a physiological context.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on the creation and characterization of engineered protein variants rather than pre-existing datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dimerization is a double-edged sword: While some level of FP interaction is necessary for FRET, excessive dimerization can hinder the sensor domain's conformational flexibility, thereby limiting the dynamic range of reversible indicators.
- Weak dimerization is optimal for reversible indicators: The study strongly suggests that FPs with a moderate or weak tendency to dimerize strike the right balance. They allow for sufficient interaction for FRET but also permit the conformational changes required for a large signal swing.
- Monomeric FPs can reduce FRET efficiency: Introducing mutations that strongly promote monomerization (like A206K) can lead to a significant decrease in FRET efficiency and dynamic range, likely by preventing the necessary close proximity or optimal orientation.
- Dimer-enhancing FPs can increase basal FRET: Mutations that enhance dimerization can lead to a higher baseline FRET signal, which paradoxically reduces the change in signal upon stimulus, thus lowering the dynamic range.
- Mechanism matters: The optimal dimerization strategy differs between reversible indicators (like Ca²⁺ or ATP sensors) and irreversible indicators (like protease sensors). For irreversible cleavage events, strong dimerization before cleavage can be beneficial.
Key Results
- YC3.60 (Ca²⁺ indicator): Variants with monomer-associated mutations (A206K) showed reduced dynamic range compared to the native YC3.60. The YC3.60-mD/mA mutant (both donor and acceptor mutated) exhibited the lowest dynamic range (159%). Conversely, the dimer-enhancing mutant (YC3.60-dD/dA) also showed a reduced dynamic range (100%), likely due to a high basal FRET signal.
- TN-XL (Ca²⁺ indicator): Similar trends were observed, with monomer-associated mutations reducing the dynamic range and dimer-enhancing mutations also negatively impacting performance.
- ATeam (ATP indicator): By reverting the ATeam-mD/mA (which has the A206K mutation) to a form with native FPs (ATeam-nD/nA), the researchers achieved a 40% gain in dynamic range. Live-cell imaging confirmed this improved dynamic range.
- Ca²⁺ Affinity: Monomer-associated mutations in YC3.60 slightly lowered its affinity for Ca²⁺, suggesting that FP interactions can indirectly influence sensor domain function.
Limitations and Future Work
- Empirical screening is key: The authors emphasize that predicting the optimal FP interface is challenging. Therefore, empirical screening of various FP interface mutations is essential for designing high-performance FRET-based indicators.
- FP orientation: While the study provides evidence, further investigation is needed to fully clarify the role of FP orientation (especially antiparallel configuration enabled by circular permutation) in achieving high FRET efficiency.
- Non-Aequorea FPs: The authors suggest that interface engineering could be applied to non-Aequorea FPs with longer excitation/emission wavelengths, potentially expanding the applicability of FRET techniques.
- Combinatorial approaches: Future work could explore combinations of mutations at the FP interface to identify even better-performing variants.
Summary updated