Revealing the truth about ‘trapped rainbow’ storage of light in metamaterials

Sailing He, Yingran He, Yi JinScientific 2012 · DOI

Abstract

It was claimed that the incident light can be gradually slowed down and finally trapped in a tapered metamaterial waveguide. Here we show that the energy incident from the input port of the tapered metamaterial waveguide will be totally reflected (instead of being trapped) due to the strong intermodal coupling between the forward and backward modes. The underlying physical mechanism for this strong intermodal-coupling is given. The occurrence of energy reflection is unambiguously proved using several independent methods, (1) the semi-analytical mode matching technique, (2) the numerical finite element simulation, (3) the requirement of energy and momentum conservation, and (4) an experimental verification at microwave frequency. The dream of 'trapped rainbow' for storage of light might still be possible if this intermodal coupling could be blocked, and our study provides a useful guidance for such an endeavor.

Introduction

The concept of a "trapped rainbow"—using tapered metamaterials to bring light to a complete standstill—has long been a goal for optical storage and all-optical computing. If light could be slowed to zero velocity, it would enable ultra-compact optical buffers and memories. Previous theoretical work suggested that "negative refractive index" metamaterials could achieve this by tapering a waveguide so that different frequencies reach a "critical thickness" and stop. However, this study demonstrates that true trapping is physically impossible in these structures; instead, light undergoes total reflection due to intense coupling between forward and backward traveling waves at the critical point.

Methodology

The researchers employed a four-pronged approach to investigate the phenomenon:

  1. Semi-analytical Mode Matching: Modeling the tapered waveguide as discrete steps to calculate reflection and transmission by matching electromagnetic fields at interfaces.
  2. Numerical Finite Element Method (FEM): Using COMSOL Multiphysics to simulate field distributions and wave packet propagation in both frequency and time domains.
  3. Conservation Law Analysis: Deriving analytical equations based on energy and momentum conservation to check the mathematical consistency of a "stopped" state.
  4. Experimental Verification: Constructing a "spoof plasmon" waveguide with periodic copper grooves to observe the behavior at microwave frequencies (8-10 GHz).

The Physics of Intermodal Coupling

The core finding is the "Mode Degeneracy Trap." At the critical thickness ($d_c$) where group velocity should theoretically reach zero, the forward-traveling and backward-traveling modes become degenerate. They share the same wave vector and identical spatial profiles.

Dispersion curves showing the degeneracy of forward ($M_f$) and backward ($M_b$) modes at the critical thickness $d_c$.

As shown in the dispersion analysis, even an extremely smooth taper acts as a physical perturbation. Because the modes are nearly identical near $d_c$, this perturbation inevitably couples energy from the forward mode into the backward mode. Furthermore, analysis of momentum flow reveals that as light slows, the ratio of momentum flow to energy flow ($\eta$) diverges. To satisfy momentum conservation, the system must reflect the energy rather than trapping it.

Results and Evidence

The study provides several lines of evidence for total reflection:

  • Unity Reflection: For sufficiently smooth tapers, the reflection coefficient reaches 100%. The light turns around rather than stopping.
  • Time-Domain Dynamics: Simulations show a wave packet slowing and compressing as it approaches $d_c$, but eventually propagating backward toward the input.
  • Experimental Standing Waves: Microwave experiments revealed strong intensity modulation (standing waves) with a contrast exceeding 20 dB, a clear signature of interference between incident and reflected waves.
  • Finite Field Enhancement: If light were trapped, field intensity at $d_c$ would theoretically grow toward infinity. Instead, only a modest ~4x enhancement was observed, confirming energy escape via reflection.

Conclusion

This research effectively debunks the simplest implementation of "trapped rainbow" storage in tapered metamaterials. While it closes one door, it points toward a new direction: light storage might be achievable if intermodal coupling can be blocked. Future efforts should focus on engineering waveguides that support a forward mode without a corresponding backward mode at the same wave vector, perhaps by breaking reciprocity or utilizing topological insulators.

Summary updated

Abstract

It was claimed that the incident light can be gradually slowed down and finally trapped in a tapered metamaterial waveguide. Here we show that the energy incident from the input port of the tapered metamaterial waveguide will be totally reflected (instead of being trapped) due to the strong intermodal coupling between the forward and backward modes. The underlying physical mechanism for this strong intermodal-coupling is given. The occurrence of energy reflection is unambiguously proved using several independent methods, (1) the semi-analytical mode matching technique, (2) the numerical finite element simulation, (3) the requirement of energy and momentum conservation, and (4) an experimental verification at microwave frequency. The dream of 'trapped rainbow' for storage of light might still be possible if this intermodal coupling could be blocked, and our study provides a useful guidance for such an endeavor.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2012revealing,
  author = {Sailing He and Yingran He and Yi Jin},
  title = {{Revealing the truth about ‘trapped rainbow’ storage of light in metamaterials}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1038/srep00583},
}
Figure