Revealing the structures of megadalton-scale DNA complexes with nucleotide resolution

Massimo Kube, Fabian Köhler, Elija Feigl, B. Nagel-Yuksel, Elena M. Willner, Jonas J. Funke, Thomas Gerling, Pierre Stömmer, Maximilian N. Honemann, Thomas G. Martin, Sjors H. W. Scheres, Hendrik DietzNature Communications 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a significant advancement in visualizing and validating complex DNA nanostructures. By combining high-resolution cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) with molecular dynamics simulations, the researchers can now resolve DNA origami structures at nucleotide resolution, enabling precise design refinement and opening doors for more sophisticated DNA-based molecular machines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA nanotechnology, particularly DNA origami, allows for the rational design and self-assembly of intricate 3D nanoscale objects. These objects, composed of thousands of base pairs and hundreds of DNA strands, hold immense promise for applications ranging from drug delivery to nanoscale robotics. However, a major bottleneck has been the accurate experimental validation of these designs in solution. Existing structural data for DNA nanostructures has been relatively low-resolution compared to fields like protein crystallography, hindering the ability to precisely inspect and refine designs at the base-pair level. This paper tackles this challenge by developing and applying advanced cryo-EM and computational methods to achieve unprecedented structural detail for large DNA origami assemblies.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a multi-pronged approach:

  • High-Resolution Cryo-EM: The researchers employed cryo-EM to image a library of diverse DNA origami objects in their native solution state. Crucially, they accounted for structural fluctuations and employed advanced 3D classification and refinement techniques.
  • Multibody Refinement: To overcome limitations of treating the entire object as a rigid body, they developed a "multibody refinement" strategy. This involves dividing the complex structure into smaller, independently refined "domains" or sub-bodies, allowing for more accurate reconstruction of each part.
  • Focal Scanning Refinement: Further enhancing resolution, they introduced a "focal scanning refinement" approach. This method iteratively reconstructs specific, small regions of interest within the structure to very high resolution, effectively zooming in on critical areas.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) for Pseudo-Atomic Model Building: Interpreting the high-resolution cryo-EM maps is challenging. The paper presents a semi-automated method using MD simulations to build "pseudo-atomic" models. This involves fitting atomic models into the electron density maps, guided by MD force fields and a "cascaded relaxation" protocol that progressively refines the fit.
  • Context-Based Zoning and Cropping Tool: A custom viewer tool was developed to link the experimental cryo-EM maps, the fitted atomic models, and the original DNA origami design diagrams. This facilitates detailed inspection and comparison between design and experimental reality.

Datasets

The paper utilizes a library of twenty different DNA origami objects, including:

  • Multilayer DNA origami in honeycomb and square-lattice packing.
  • Specific examples include "Brick" DNA origami, a "barrel-like 126-helix bundle," "Twisttower" variants, a "Pointer" variant, a "16-helix bundle," "hinged-beam-like" objects, and "dumbbell-like" objects.
  • The study also includes variants of these objects designed to test specific hypotheses, such as those with varying internal floppiness or modifications at crossover sites.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the paper focuses on applying and advancing methodologies to existing types of DNA origami structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DNA Origami are Not Rigid: A fundamental insight is that DNA origami structures, even large ones, are not static. They exhibit significant structural heterogeneity, including domain motions and lattice breathing, which must be accounted for to achieve high-resolution structural data.
  • Global Twist is Prevalent and Design-Dependent: The study systematically reveals prevalent global twist deformations in many DNA origami designs, particularly in honeycomb lattices. This twist is influenced by design context (lattice type, cross-sectional area) and can be mitigated through specific design modifications.
  • Crossovers are Crucial for Torque Transmission: The research demonstrates that while crossovers are necessary for transmitting torques that counteract twist, simply adding unpaired bases at crossovers (to make them "floppier") does not necessarily reduce global twist.
  • Nicks Have Limited Impact on Global Twist: The distribution of single-strand nicks, which were previously thought to influence twist, was found to have little impact on the global twist deformation in the tested configurations.
  • High-Resolution Details are Now Accessible: The developed methods allow for the visualization of fine details like helical grooves, single-strand vs. double-strand crossovers, backbone phosphate positions, and even single-strand breaks. This level of detail was previously unattainable.

Key Results

  • Nucleotide-Resolution Structures: The paper successfully determined cryo-EM structures with resolutions allowing for the discernment of nucleotide-level features. For example, focal scanning refinement achieved local resolutions below 4 Å for parts of the Twisttower.
  • Pseudo-Atomic Models Built Semi-Automatically: The MD-driven fitting procedure allows for the construction of pseudo-atomic models in approximately 12 hours on a standard desktop, a significant speedup compared to manual methods.
  • Validation of Design Principles: The study validates and refines existing design principles for DNA origami, particularly concerning how to mitigate unwanted twist deformations.
  • Identification of Structural Heterogeneity: The work clearly demonstrates and quantifies the dynamic nature of DNA origami, revealing domain motions and lattice breathing that were previously only inferred.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While the pseudo-atomic model construction is semi-automated, the overall process involving cryo-EM data acquisition, processing, and MD fitting is still computationally intensive.
  • Generalizability of MD Fitting: The MD-based fitting is powerful, but its accuracy and efficiency might depend on the specific DNA origami structure and the quality of the cryo-EM map.
  • Future Work: The authors envision that this higher level of structural detail will enable designers to perform base-pair level interventions for more precise refinement of their designs. This capability is expected to drive the development of more advanced DNA-based functionalities, such as precise positioning of functional groups for molecular recognition, templated synthesis, and photonic applications. The improved structural data will also be invaluable for parameterizing computational prediction methods for DNA nanostructures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The methods of DNA nanotechnology enable the rational design of custom shapes that self-assemble in solution from sets of DNA molecules. DNA origami, in which a long template DNA single strand is folded by many short DNA oligonucleotides, can be employed to make objects comprising hundreds of unique DNA strands and thousands of base pairs, thus in principle providing many degrees of freedom for modelling complex objects of defined 3D shapes and sizes. Here, we address the problem of accurate structural validation of DNA objects in solution with cryo-EM based methodologies. By taking into account structural fluctuations, we can determine structures with improved detail compared to previous work. To interpret the experimental cryo-EM maps, we present molecular-dynamics-based methods for building pseudo-atomic models in a semi-automated fashion. Among other features, our data allows discerning details such as helical grooves, single-strand versus double-strand crossovers, backbone phosphate positions, and single-strand breaks. Obtaining this higher level of detail is a step forward that now allows designers to inspect and refine their designs with base-pair level interventions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kube2020revealing,
  author = {Massimo Kube and Fabian Köhler and Elija Feigl and B. Nagel-Yuksel and Elena M. Willner and Jonas J. Funke and Thomas Gerling and Pierre Stömmer and Maximilian N. Honemann and Thomas G. Martin and Sjors H. W. Scheres and Hendrik Dietz},
  title = {{Revealing the structures of megadalton-scale DNA complexes with nucleotide resolution}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-20020-7},
}
Figure