Revealing the Relationship Between Macrostructures and Inclusions Across the Thickness Direction of Q235B Slabs

Bo Wang, Jinwen Jin, Chao Gu, Ze Wei, Ziyu Lyu, Lidong Xing, Yan-ping BaoCrystals 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the crucial link between the internal structure (macrostructure) and tiny impurities (inclusions) within Q235B steel slabs. By combining laboratory experiments and theoretical modeling, the researchers reveal how different solidification zones influence the type, size, and distribution of manganese sulfide (MnS) inclusions, offering insights for improving steel quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quality of steel slabs, fundamental building blocks for many industries, is significantly impacted by their internal characteristics: the macrostructure (the large-scale arrangement of crystals) and inclusions (undesirable foreign particles). While both are known to affect mechanical properties, the precise relationship between the macrostructure and the formation and distribution of inclusions, particularly across the thickness of a slab, remains unclear. This lack of understanding hinders efforts to optimize steel production processes for better quality. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically exploring how the macrostructure, which varies from the outer edge to the center of the slab, influences the characteristics of MnS inclusions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Laboratory Experiments:
    • Material Preparation: Samples of Q235B steel were taken from a continuous casting machine.
  • Macrostructure Analysis: Samples were etched to reveal the different solidification zones: columnar crystal (CZ), columnar-to-equiaxed transition (CET), and equiaxed crystal (EZ).
  • Chemical Analysis: Carbon and sulfur content was measured using a carbon and sulfur analyzer. Manganese content was determined by direct reading spectroscopy.
  • Inclusion Characterization: * Automatic Inclusion Scanning (ASPEX): Used to quantify the number, area fraction, and size distribution of MnS inclusions across the slab thickness.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) with Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS): Employed for detailed analysis of inclusion morphology and elemental composition.
  • Theoretical Calculations:
    • Thermodynamic Modeling (Thermo-Calc): Used to predict the precipitation behavior of MnS inclusions as a function of temperature and macrostructure. This included calculating the maximum precipitation amount and initial precipitation temperature.
  • Kinetic Modeling: Equations were used to calculate the liquidus and solidus temperatures and then to model the theoretical precipitation radius of MnS inclusions based on solidification fraction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized experimental samples from a steel plant and theoretical calculations based on established thermodynamic databases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry in Macrostructure: The paper confirms a symmetrical distribution of macrostructures across the slab thickness, transitioning from columnar crystals at the edges to equiaxed crystals in the center, with a transition zone in between. This symmetry is attributed to variations in cooling rates.
  • MnS Inclusions Follow Macrostructure: A key finding is that the characteristics of MnS inclusions (area fraction, number density, size, and morphology) are directly influenced by the macrostructure they are embedded within.
  • CZ Zone is "Dirtier": The columnar crystal (CZ) zone, found at the edges, exhibits a higher area fraction and number density of MnS inclusions compared to the CET and EZ zones. This suggests that the solidification conditions in the CZ zone are more conducive to MnS formation.
  • Morphology Matters: The shape of MnS inclusions varies significantly with macrostructure: elliptical/rod-like in CZ, irregular dendrites in CET, and quadrilateral/pentagonal in EZ. This morphological difference likely stems from varying formation temperatures and segregation patterns.
  • Thermodynamics and Kinetics Align: Both theoretical calculations and experimental results show a consistent trend: MnS inclusions precipitate more readily and grow larger in the CZ zone compared to CET and EZ.

Key Results

  • Macrostructure Distribution: Columnar crystal zone (CZ) → columnar-to-equiaxed transition (CET) → equiaxed crystal zone (EZ) from the edge to the center.
  • MnS Area Fraction: CZ (6.198) > CET (3.52) > EZ (3.43).
  • Average MnS Size: CZ (1.924 µm) > EZ (1.7 µm) > CET (1.495 µm).
  • Maximum Precipitation of MnS: CZ > EZ > CET.
  • Initial Precipitation Temperature of MnS: CZ (1450 °C) > CET (1445 °C) > EZ (1430 °C).
  • Theoretical Precipitation Radius of MnS: CZ > CET > EZ.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their theoretical calculations align well with experimental results, some differences exist. These discrepancies are attributed to factors like variations in cooling rates, uneven chemical component distribution, different solidification paths, dendrite growth, and potential experimental instrument errors.

For future work, the researchers propose focusing on more accurate thermodynamic and kinetic models to better predict the distribution of inclusions in Q235B steel slabs. This would involve a deeper dive into the nuances of solidification processes and their impact on inclusion formation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Macrostructures and inclusions are both vital for slabs because the quality of slabs is largely affected by them. However, the relationship between macrostructures and inclusions in the thickness direction of the slab is still unclear. Hence, in this paper, the relationship between macrostructures and inclusions was revealed by laboratory experiments and theoretical calculations. The laboratory experiments included carbon and sulfur content testing, direct reading spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and automatic inclusion scanning. The experimental results showed that the distribution of macrostructures was symmetrical from the inner and outer arc to the center. From the edge to the center of the slab, the variation in macrostructures was columnar crystal zone (CZ)→columnar-to-equiaxed transition (CET)→equiaxed crystal zone (EZ). Furthermore, the content of sulfur and manganese first decreased and then increased from the inner arc to the outer arc. The number density and area fraction of MnS inclusions in different macrostructures were CZ > CET > EZ. The average size of MnS in different macrostructures was CZ > EZ > CET. Moreover, the morphology of MnS inclusions was ellipse and rod in CZ, irregular dendrite in CET, and multilateral in EZ. Additionally, theoretical calculation results showed the maximum precipitation and initial precipitation temperature of MnS inclusions in different macrostructures were CZ > EZ > CET. Meanwhile, the theoretical precipitation radius of MnS inclusions in different macrostructures was CZ > EZ > CET.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024revealing,
  author = {Bo Wang and Jinwen Jin and Chao Gu and Ze Wei and Ziyu Lyu and Lidong Xing and Yan-ping Bao},
  title = {{Revealing the Relationship Between Macrostructures and Inclusions Across the Thickness Direction of Q235B Slabs}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst14121010},
}
Figure