Revealing Semantic Structures of Texts: Multi-grained Framework for Automatic Mind-map Generation

Yang Wei, Honglei Guo, Jin-Mao Wei, Zhong SuIJCAI 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multi-grained framework for automatically generating mind maps from text. By employing a multi-perspective recurrence detector to understand inter-sentence relationships and a recursive algorithm for hierarchical structuring, the approach generates more semantically accurate and human-like mind maps than previous methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Creating mind maps manually is a time-consuming process that requires understanding the hierarchical relationships between ideas within a text. While existing automatic methods can parse sentences or identify basic similarities, they struggle to capture the deeper, cross-sentence semantic connections that form the backbone of a good mind map. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a system that can automatically detect these nuanced relationships and construct a coherent, hierarchical mind map.

Methods

The proposed framework consists of three main components:

  • Governing Relationship Detector (GRD): This is the core of the system, responsible for identifying directed semantic relationships between sentences. It uses a novel Multi-perspective Recurrence Detector (MRD).
  • Multi-hop Self-Attention: Used in the encoding layer to capture multiple latent semantic perspectives from the "governor" sentence.
  • Gated Recurrence Module: Employed in the interaction layer to encode the "governed" sentence's semantic association evidence by attending to the governor's perspectives. This allows for a deeper understanding of how sentences relate beyond simple word overlap.
  • Salient-Sentence-based Mind-map (SSM) Generator: This component takes the governing relationships detected by the GRD and recursively builds a hierarchical mind map. It identifies the most salient sentence as a root and then recursively clusters and identifies roots for sub-groups, ensuring a tree-like structure where each node has at most one governor.
  • Key-Snippet-based Mind-map (KSM) Generator: This final stage refines the SSM by extracting key phrases from the salient sentences to create a more concise, human-like mind map, focusing on the critical points.

Datasets

The authors built a custom training corpus from CNN news articles. This corpus consists of titles, highlights, and content. Highlights were treated as governors for sentences in their corresponding paragraphs, and the title as a governor for all highlights. They sampled 20 documents for human expert validation of this assumption. The final training corpus contains approximately 2.2 million governing pairs from 90,000 articles. For evaluation, they used a randomly selected test set of 100 CNN news articles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Intra-Sentence: The paper strongly emphasizes that true mind map generation requires understanding relationships between sentences, not just within them. This is a critical limitation of many prior approaches.
  • "Governing" Relationship: The concept of a "governing" relationship (where one sentence implies or supports another) is central. This directed relationship is more nuanced than simple similarity.
  • Multi-Perspective Encoding: Capturing multiple "perspectives" of a sentence is key to understanding its semantic role. The multi-hop self-attention mechanism is crucial for this.
  • Gated Recurrence for Interaction: The gated recurrence module's ability to selectively attend to relevant information from the governor sentence when processing the governed sentence is vital for detecting subtle associations.
  • Recursive Hierarchy Construction: A recursive algorithm is an effective way to build the hierarchical structure of a mind map, ensuring a clear parent-child relationship between ideas.
  • SSM vs. KSM: The distinction between a sentence-level mind map (SSM) and a key-phrase-level mind map (KSM) is valuable. SSMs offer more detail and are easier to read, while KSMs highlight core concepts, providing complementary views.

Key Results

The proposed MRDMF framework significantly outperforms existing methods, including parser-based approaches, similarity-based methods (LexRank), and other neural network models (DLMG, MAMG).

  • SSM Generator: Achieved 49.44% improvement over LexRank, 32.52% over DLMG, and 27.79% over MAMG.
  • KSM Generator: Also showed substantial improvements over baseline methods.
  • Threshold Tuning: The confidence threshold (T) for sentence salience was found to be critical, with a value around 0.4 yielding optimal performance. This threshold balances the complexity of the mind map with the inclusion of relevant governing relationships.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Argumentative Essays: The authors acknowledge that the current framework struggles with argumentative essays, where balancing opinions and evidence is challenging. They plan to improve the framework for such texts.
  • Confidence Threshold: While a threshold is necessary, its selection can impact the depth and complexity of the generated mind map. Further research into adaptive thresholding or more robust salience scoring could be beneficial.
  • Human-like Structure: While KSM aims for human-like output, further refinement in key phrase extraction and semantic representation could lead to even more natural mind maps.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2019revealing,
  author = {Yang Wei and Honglei Guo and Jin-Mao Wei and Zhong Su},
  title = {{Revealing Semantic Structures of Texts: Multi-grained Framework for Automatic Mind-map Generation}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2019/729},
}
Figure