TL;DR
This study assesses the environmental risk posed by 70 industrial enterprises to the Lanzhou section of the Yellow River using a combined AHP-EW methodology. While most enterprises pose a low risk, Xigu District emerges as a high-risk area due to its concentration of petrochemical industries, highlighting the need for improved supervision and emergency preparedness.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Yellow River, a vital water source for China, faces significant environmental pressure from industrial activities, particularly in urbanized sections like Lanzhou. While pollution control has historically focused on treatment, there's a growing need for proactive risk assessment and management. Previous studies have not comprehensively evaluated the specific risks posed by industries along the Lanzhou section of the Yellow River, especially considering the unique geographical constraints and the concentration of heavy industries like petrochemicals in this region. This paper aims to fill this gap by precisely assessing environmental risks from these enterprises and identifying key contributing factors and vulnerable areas.
Methods
The researchers employed a novel combined approach of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the Entropy-Weight (EW) method to assess environmental risks.
- AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process): A structured technique for organizing and analyzing complex decisions based on mathematics and psychology. It involves breaking down a decision into a hierarchy of criteria, sub-criteria, and alternatives, then using pairwise comparisons to determine the relative importance of each element. This method incorporates expert judgment.
- EW (Entropy-Weight) Method: An objective weighting method that determines the weight of indicators based on their variability. Higher variability (entropy) indicates more information and thus a higher weight.
- Combined AHP-EW: The paper utilizes a linear combination of AHP and EW weights. This hybrid approach aims to balance the subjectivity of expert-based AHP with the objectivity of EW, leading to a more robust risk assessment. They also explored nonlinear weighting to emphasize sensitive factors.
- Environmental Risk Index (ERI): A calculated index to quantify the environmental risk, where a higher ERI indicates a greater probability of pollution.
- Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to analyze the relationships between different risk factors and identify the most influential ones.
Datasets
The study utilized data from 70 representative industrial enterprises in Lanzhou. These enterprises were selected based on their annual main business income (over CNY 20 million) and their involvement in water-related activities (quantitative wastewater treatment or discharge). The data sources included:
- Reports from the second national census of pollution sources.
- Environmental protection, water conservancy, and urban construction data.
- Expert evaluation and consultation.
The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather analyzes existing enterprises within the Lanzhou region.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Hybrid Approach is Key: Combining subjective expert judgment (AHP) with objective data-driven analysis (EW) provides a more balanced and accurate assessment of environmental risks than either method alone.
- Petrochemicals are High-Risk: Petrochemical industries are identified as the biggest potential risk contributors due to the nature and quantity of hazardous substances they handle.
- Geography Matters: The narrowness of the Yellow River basin in Lanzhou forces industries to be located close to the river, increasing their direct impact and vulnerability.
- Supervision Gaps Exist: Weak outfall supervision and a shortage of emergency supplies are critical issues that require immediate attention across many enterprises.
- No "High Risk" Enterprises, but Medium Risks are Present: While no enterprise was classified as "high risk," a significant portion (27%) were identified as "medium risk," indicating areas for improvement.
Key Results
- Risk Distribution: 73% of enterprises were classified as low-risk, and 27% as medium-risk. No high-risk enterprises were identified.
- District-Level Risk: Xigu District showed the highest total environmental risk value (40.51), followed by Honggu District (22.87) and Anning District (14.17). This is attributed to the concentration of industries in these areas.
- Major Risk Contributors: The type of enterprise (especially petrochemical), the species of risk substance, shortest distance to the Yellow River, river level, and population density were identified as the main contributors to environmental risks.
- Hazardous Chemicals: Aromatic aliphatic hydrocarbons and explosive chemicals constitute over 90% of the hazardous chemical storage in Lanzhou, with Xigu District being the primary storage area.
- Supervision Weakness: Nearly all enterprises showed pressure regarding sewage outlet monitoring (C7), indicating a universal lack of robust oversight.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study focused on 70 representative enterprises, which is a subset of all industries in Lanzhou.
- While the combined AHP-EW method is robust, the specific weighting (μ=0.8 for linear weighting) was chosen to reduce risk from underestimation, which might still overlook some risks.
- The study acknowledges that venture enterprises in tributaries of the Yellow River may require separate consideration.
- Future Work:
- Strengthen the accountability for outlet monitoring.
- Enhance supervision of high-risk and medium-risk enterprises, focusing on developing active prevention and control mechanisms, including environmental liability insurance and emergency response plans.
- Control venture enterprise industry away from water sources and densely populated areas in tributaries.
- Further investigate the specific risks associated with venture enterprises in less industrialized areas.
Summary updated