TL;DR
This paper presents a novel, sustainable grouting material for metro tunnel construction that effectively reuses excavated shield muck. By incorporating slag and a novel additive, TMS-Na, the material significantly improves early strength, reduces setting time, and enhances mechanical properties and impermeability, while also drastically cutting costs and environmental impact.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Metro tunnel construction using shield tunneling generates massive amounts of excavated soil, known as shield muck. Currently, this muck is often disposed of through landfilling or stockpiling, leading to land occupation, pollution, and significant costs. Simultaneously, conventional grouting materials used to fill the annular tail void behind the shield are resource-intensive and can have limitations like low early strength and slow setting, hindering efficient tunneling. This research tackles the dual problem of shield muck disposal and the need for more sustainable, high-performance grouting materials by developing a novel formulation that utilizes shield muck as a primary component.
Methods
The study employed a systematic approach to develop and characterize the novel grouting material. Key methods included:
- Orthogonal Experimental Design: This statistical method was used to efficiently explore the influence of various factors (cement content, slag content, TMS-Na dosage, and water content) on the material's workability and mechanical properties.
- Microstructural Analysis: A suite of advanced techniques was utilized to understand how the new material forms and why it performs better:
- Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To visualize the microstructure and observe the formation of hydration products.
- X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To identify the mineral phases present and track changes during hydration.
- Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): To analyze chemical bonds and understand reaction mechanisms.
- Thermogravimetric (TG) Analysis: To quantify the amounts of hydration products (like C-S-H gel and Ca(OH)2) by analyzing thermal decomposition.
- Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP): To characterize the pore structure (size distribution, porosity, and average pore size), which is crucial for mechanical performance and durability.
- Performance Testing: Standard tests were conducted to evaluate:
- Workability: Fluidity and setting time.
- Mechanical Properties: 3-day and 28-day compressive strength.
- Durability: Impermeability grade.
- Field Application: A trial section in the Changsha Metro Line 7 project was used to validate the material's performance in real-world conditions, monitoring construction effects and ground settlement.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized shield muck collected from the Changsha Metro Line 7 project as the primary raw material.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Synergistic Activation: The combination of slag and TMS-Na acts as a powerful composite activator. Slag provides reactive silica and alumina, while TMS-Na, through hydrolysis, creates an alkaline environment that disrupts the slag's glassy structure and also acts as a pore refiner.
- Shield Muck Transformation: The inert shield muck aggregate is not just a filler; it's actively incorporated into the grout matrix. The alkaline environment and TMS-Na's action erode and disrupt the quartz structure of the muck, making it participate in the hydration reaction.
- Organic-Inorganic Hybridization: TMS-Na's hydrolysis product, trimethylsilanol, can form stable Si-O-Si or Si-O-Al covalent bonds with slag components. This creates an organic-inorganic hybrid network, leading to a denser and more robust microstructure.
- Accelerated Hydration and Densification: The novel material exhibits significantly more complete hydration, leading to a denser microstructure with reduced pore size and porosity compared to conventional grouts. This is evidenced by increased C-S-H gel, Ca(OH)2, and CaCO3 formation.
- Economic and Environmental Win-Win: The material not only offers substantial cost savings (71% reduction in material cost) but also drastically reduces the environmental burden associated with shield muck disposal.
Key Results
- Optimal Mix: The best performing formulation consists of 60.8% shield muck, 23% water, 8% cement, 8% slag, and 0.2% TMS-Na.
- Performance Enhancements: Compared to conventional grout, the novel material shows:
- Fluidity: Increased by 47 mm.
- Setting Time: Shortened from 11 hours to 3.5 hours.
- Compressive Strength: Approximately 97.4% higher at 3 days and 93.3% higher at 28 days.
- Impermeability: Grade P10 achieved (up from P8).
- Microstructural Refinement: Average pore size reduced by 58.12% (34.55 nm decrease), porosity lowered by 11.69%, and intermediate/micropores constituted 66.22% of the total volume.
- Shield Muck Utilization: Increased to 60.8%.
- Cost Savings: Approximately 71% reduction in material cost per cubic meter, with projected savings of ~150,000 RMB for the remaining rings of the Changsha Metro Line 7 project, plus ~467,000 RMB in avoided disposal costs.
- Field Validation: Successful application in a trial tunnel section demonstrated complete cavity filling, no leakage, and effective control of ground deformation, with lower grouting pressure required.
Limitations and Future Work
- Geological Heterogeneity: The paper acknowledges that variations in muck composition (clay content, particle gradation, moisture) along the tunnel can affect grout workability and mechanical properties. This necessitates stricter quality control and more robust muck characterization.
- Future Work Suggestions: The authors recommend developing real-time muck monitoring and adaptive mixture proportion adjustment systems to ensure intelligent production and consistent product quality. Further research could focus on optimizing these systems for intelligent production and ensuring consistent quality across varying geological conditions.
Summary updated