Reuse, remanufacturing and recycling in the steel sector

Claire Davis, Rosie Hall, Sumit Hazra, Kurt Debattista, Shengyao Zhuang, Jiaqi Duan, Ziwei Li, J. Shenton, D. Panni, Andrew HalfpennyPhilosophical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

The global steel industry is transitioning towards a circular economy to reduce its significant CO2 emissions. This paper examines the UK's path to near net-zero steel production by analyzing strategies like increased reuse, remanufacturing, and recycling, alongside technological shifts like electric arc furnaces. It highlights challenges and opportunities, including the need for better material tracking and understanding the impact of recycled scrap on steel quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The steel sector is a major contributor to global CO2 emissions, accounting for approximately 8% of the total. To achieve net-zero targets, the industry must move away from traditional, carbon-intensive production methods. This paper addresses the multifaceted challenge of decarbonizing the steel sector by exploring a combination of approaches: shifting to lower-emission production technologies (like Electric Arc Furnaces - EAFs), increasing the use of recycled steel scrap, and promoting material efficiency through reuse and remanufacturing of steel-intensive products. The paper specifically focuses on the UK context, analyzing current industry practices, future plans, and identifying key enablers and barriers to this transition.

Methods

The paper employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Scenario Modeling: It uses modeling to project the potential impact of different decarbonization strategies on UK steel production emissions up to 2050. This includes scenarios with varying levels of EAF adoption and increased reuse/remanufacturing.
  • Literature Review and Analysis: The authors synthesize existing knowledge on steelmaking technologies, circular economy principles, and the challenges associated with scrap recycling and material efficiency.
  • Case Studies: The paper presents case studies to illustrate specific technical challenges and potential solutions. These include:
  • In-service monitoring for material passports: Investigating the use of sensors on heavy-duty vehicles to assess component condition and inform decisions about reuse or remanufacturing.
  • Impact of residual elements from scrap: Analyzing how increased recycling of scrap steel affects steel composition and its subsequent impact on microstructure development and processing.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on existing data from industry reports, government publications, and academic literature for its analysis and modeling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • EAF Transition is Key: The shift from traditional Blast Furnace-Basic Oxygen Furnace (BF-BOF) to Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) steelmaking, powered by renewable energy, offers the most significant potential for CO2 emission reductions in the UK steel sector.
  • Reuse/Remanufacturing as a Complement: While crucial for a circular economy, reuse and remanufacturing currently have a smaller impact on overall CO2 emissions compared to the technological shift in primary steel production. However, their long-term importance for achieving near net-zero is acknowledged.
  • Scrap Quality is a Growing Concern: As EAF production increases, the reliance on scrap steel will grow. This raises concerns about the accumulation of residual elements (like copper and tin) from recycled materials, which can affect steel processing, microstructure, and properties.
  • Material Passports are Essential: To facilitate reuse and remanufacturing, robust systems for tracking material condition and history at the end-of-life are needed. In-service monitoring and data analytics are identified as crucial for developing these "material passports."
  • Residual Elements: A Double-Edged Sword: While residual elements can pose challenges (e.g., hot shortness), they can also offer benefits, such as contributing to precipitate strengthening, potentially reducing the need for intentional alloying additions.

Key Results

  • Emission Reduction Potential: Modeling suggests that a full transition to EAF production in the UK by 2050 could reduce CO2e emissions from steel production to approximately 2.70 Mtpa, a significant decrease from the projected 12.03 Mtpa without such changes.
  • Reuse/Remanufacturing Impact: With 25% reuse and remanufacturing by 2050, alongside full EAF production, CO2e emissions could be further reduced to around 2.08 Mtpa.
  • In-service Monitoring Success: A case study on heavy-duty vehicles demonstrated that relatively few sensors (accelerometers, roll sensors, displacement sensors) can provide sufficient data to estimate in-service usage and inform fatigue life assessment.
  • Residual Element Effects: The paper details how residual elements like copper can affect steel hardenability, influence microstructure development (e.g., by promoting precipitates at grain boundaries), and potentially lead to processing issues like hot shortness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scrap Availability and Geography: The global supply of scrap steel is limited and geographically concentrated, posing a challenge for widespread adoption of scrap-intensive steelmaking.
  • Renewable Energy Assumption: The emission reduction models assume a fully renewable energy supply for EAF steelmaking, which is not currently the case and may not be fully realized by 2050.
  • DRI Development: While hydrogen-based direct reduced iron (H-DRI) is a promising low-emission technology, its widespread use in the UK steel industry is not yet planned, and its embodied emissions are not fully accounted for in current models.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into:
  • Developing improved scrap sorting and quality control technologies.
  • Redesigning products for easier disassembly, reuse, remanufacture, and recycling.
  • Exploring collaborations between steel producers and customers to optimize material use and alloy selection.
  • Further development of low CO2 emission technologies for primary steel manufacture.
  • Investigating the potential to exploit residual elements for enhanced steel properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The global steel sector is undergoing a transition from being a major CO<sub>2</sub> emitter to a more sustainable circular material service provider, moving towards (near) net zero CO<sub>2</sub> through combined strategies of reuse, remanufacturing, recycling and changes to primary steelmaking. This paper considers the transition using the UK as an example, based on the current sector state and future plans/opportunities. Some key enablers/barriers have been identified, and case studies are presented on the current state of knowledge and technology developments. For example, increasing reuse/remanufacturing requires data on the component's remaining life at the end-of-product life; in this work use of in-service monitoring for steel-intensive applications in the transport sector is discussed identifying sensor types/locations for fatigue loading assessment for different use conditions to feed into material/product passports for reuse/remanufacturing decisions. Increased recycling of obsolete scrap has implications for composition control with increases in residual elements, such as Cu, Sn, Cr and Ni inevitable. Current and future approaches to recycling and scrap sorting are discussed along with case studies for how residual elements affect microstructural development during steel processing, including effects on recrystallization, phase transformation and fine-scale precipitation, which potentially could be exploited to give increases in product strength. This article is part of the discussion meeting issue 'Sustainable metals: science and systems'.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{davis2024reuse,
  author = {Claire Davis and Rosie Hall and Sumit Hazra and Kurt Debattista and Shengyao Zhuang and Jiaqi Duan and Ziwei Li and J. Shenton and D. Panni and Andrew Halfpenny},
  title = {{Reuse, remanufacturing and recycling in the steel sector}},
  booktitle = {Philosophical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1098/rsta.2023.0244},
}
Figure