Return to Sport Tests' Prognostic Value after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis

X Wang, Peng Yuan, Shiqi Yu, Yilin Xu, Lei Yang2023 · DOI

This document is a formal protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. It outlines the methodology for a forthcoming study rather than presenting final experimental results.

TL;DR

This protocol outlines a systematic review designed to determine if passing "Return to Sport" (RTS) tests actually predicts a successful comeback and lower re-injury risk after ACL reconstruction. By comparing outcomes between athletes who pass versus those who fail these clinical hurdles, the researchers aim to validate—or challenge—the prognostic value of current orthopedic standards.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injuries are a major setback for athletes. While reconstruction surgery (ACLR) is the standard treatment, the "finish line" of recovery is notoriously blurry. Statistics show that fewer than two-thirds of patients return to their pre-injury level of play, and re-injury rates can soar as high as 37.5%.

To manage this risk, clinicians use a battery of "Return to Sport" (RTS) tests—ranging from physical strength and "hop tests" to psychological readiness surveys—to decide when an athlete is cleared for action. However, the actual prognostic value of these tests is controversial. There is no global consensus on which tests truly predict a safe return versus which are merely clinical formalities. This paper proposes a rigorous meta-analysis to see if these tests actually do what they claim: identify who is ready and who is at risk.

Methods

As this is a protocol for a systematic review, the "methods" describe the roadmap for data synthesis rather than a laboratory experiment:

  • Search Strategy: The authors will perform a comprehensive search of both English (PubMed, Web of Science, EBSCO) and Chinese (CNKI, Wanfang) databases for studies published between 2000 and 2022.
  • Inclusion Criteria: The review focuses on observational studies (cohort and case-control) involving athletes who underwent primary ACLR and were subjected to a specific RTS test protocol.
  • Comparison Groups: The core of the analysis involves splitting subjects into two cohorts: the "Test Passed" group and the "Test Failed" group.
  • Statistical Approach: The team will use Review Manager 5.3 to calculate Risk Ratios (RR). An RR of less than 1 for the "passed" group would indicate a statistically significant reduction in re-injury risk. They will also employ a random-effects model to account for the inevitable heterogeneity (differences) between various clinical studies.
  • Quality Assessment: The MINORS (Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies) scale will be used to grade the quality of the evidence and mitigate bias.

Datasets

The "datasets" in this context are the collective results of previously published clinical literature. The researchers are targeting:

  • Primary Sources: Peer-reviewed observational studies.
  • Databases: EBSCO (CINAHL, MEDLINE, SPORTDiscus), Web of Science, PubMed, CNKI, and Wanfang.
  • Exclusions: They are specifically excluding "grey literature" like books, comments, and letters, as well as studies involving conservative (non-surgical) treatment or ACL revisions.

Key Insights and Ideas

While the final data is pending, the protocol highlights several critical "aha" moments regarding the current state of sports medicine:

  • The Prognostic Gap: The authors acknowledge that while RTS testing is common, its application is "not uniform." This suggests that the medical community may be relying on metrics that haven't been fully validated against long-term outcomes.
  • Bilingual Scope: By including major Chinese databases, the study aims to capture a more diverse global data pool than reviews that only look at English-language journals.
  • The "Pass" Definition: A key idea here is the "all-or-nothing" approach to passing. The study defines the "Test Passed" group as only those who successfully pass each individual test in a battery, which may reveal whether partial success is a hidden risk factor.

Key Results

Not discussed in the paper. As a protocol, this document does not contain results. The objective is to eventually report the Risk Ratio (RR) for two primary outcomes:

  1. The rate of successful return to pre-injury sport levels.
  2. The rate of ACL re-injury (on either the surgical or the healthy leg).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several constraints:

  • Language Restriction: The study is limited to English and Chinese literature, potentially missing data from other regions.
  • Study Design: By relying on observational studies rather than randomized controlled trials (which are difficult to perform in this context), the results will be subject to the inherent biases of those original studies.
  • Future Direction: If the meta-analysis finds that current tests have low prognostic value, it will signal a need for the sports medicine community to develop entirely new, more predictive biological or biomechanical markers for recovery.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2023return,
  author = {X Wang and Peng Yuan and Shiqi Yu and Yilin Xu and Lei Yang},
  title = {{Return to Sport Tests' Prognostic Value after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.37766/inplasy2023.6.0096},
}
Figure