Return Migration of Foreign Students

Govert E. Bijwaard, Qi WangEuropean 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the factors influencing the return migration of foreign students from the Netherlands, finding that unemployment significantly increases the likelihood of departure, while finding a job has a more nuanced effect depending on the student's country of origin. Marriage in the Netherlands also appears to increase the propensity to stay.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

International student mobility is on the rise, yet the decisions of these students to return to their home countries or stay abroad after graduation remain under-researched. Existing literature often treats student migration as a subset of skilled migration or family migration, overlooking the unique dynamics of this group. This paper aims to fill this gap by comprehensively analyzing the return migration of foreign students, specifically examining how their experiences in the labor market and their family formation decisions in the host country influence their decision to leave. Understanding these factors is crucial for both immigration policy and for retaining skilled individuals.

Methods

The study employs a sophisticated econometric approach using a "timing-of-events model" (Abbring and Berg, 2003). This model is designed to handle multiple, potentially interdependent events occurring over time, such as studying, employment, unemployment, marriage, and migration. A key methodological contribution is the explicit modeling of correlated unobserved heterogeneity across these processes. This means the model accounts for the possibility that unobserved individual characteristics (like risk aversion or motivation) might simultaneously influence a student's labor market outcomes, marriage decisions, and their likelihood of returning home. This is crucial for avoiding biased estimates that could arise from simply observing correlations between these events. The researchers use mixed proportional hazard (MPH) models to estimate the likelihood of each event occurring at any given time.

Datasets

The study utilizes a unique administrative panel dataset from Statistics Netherlands, covering the period 1999-2007. This dataset includes information on over 42,730 foreign students who entered the Netherlands. Crucially, it provides detailed, event-specific timing data for migration moves (entry and exit), labor market changes (study, employment, unemployment), and marriage formation. This rich, longitudinal data allows for a granular analysis of individual life course trajectories.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unemployment is a strong push factor: Regardless of origin, becoming unemployed significantly increases the probability of a foreign student leaving the Netherlands.
  • The "job effect" is complex: Finding a job doesn't uniformly lead to staying. For students from developed countries, it has little impact on their return decision. However, for students from less developed countries and Antilles/Surinam, finding a job actually increases their likelihood of leaving. This suggests these students may be using their time in the Netherlands to gain human capital and savings for better opportunities back home or elsewhere.
  • Marriage anchors students: Getting married in the Netherlands makes students more likely to stay, suggesting increased attachment to the host country.
  • Unobserved heterogeneity matters: Ignoring the correlations between unobserved factors influencing labor market, marriage, and migration decisions can lead to misleading conclusions. The study highlights how accounting for these correlations refines our understanding of the impact of employment and marriage.
  • Origin matters: Significant differences exist in return migration patterns based on students' countries of origin, necessitating a stratified analysis.

Key Results

  • Unemployment: For all student groups, unemployment significantly increases the hazard of return migration.
  • Employment: The effect of finding a job is mixed. For EU15 and DC students, it has a non-significant or even slightly negative impact on return. Conversely, for LDC and Antilles/Surinam students, employment significantly increases the return hazard.
  • Marriage: Marriage generally reduces the return hazard, making students more prone to stay. This effect is particularly strong for LDC students. However, for new EU and DC students, the marriage effect becomes insignificant when accounting for correlated unobserved heterogeneity.
  • Country of Origin Differences: Students from new EU countries have the highest probability of returning, while those from Antilles/Surinam are the most likely to stay.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations. They do not observe cohabitation, only official marriages, which may lead to an underrepresentation of union formation, especially for students from EU countries. They also lack detailed spousal information, such as whether the partner is a native or foreigner, and their labor market status, which could further explain marriage-related migration decisions. Future research could explore these aspects. The authors also note that while their "timing-of-events" model corrects for potential endogeneity, they are cautious about interpreting the effects as strictly causal due to the untestable "no-anticipation" assumption. They suggest that policies facilitating longer stays for foreign students, improving access to affordable housing, and easing labor market access for in-demand sectors could help retain skilled migrants.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using administrative panel data, this paper presents a comprehensive empirical analysis of the return of recent foreign students in the Netherlands. We focus on how individual labour market changes and marriage formation influence their decision to leave. Our model allows for correlated unobserved heterogeneity across the migration, the labour market and the marriage formation processes. The large size of the data permits us to stratify the analysis by five groups based on the country of birth. The empirical analyses reveal that when students become unemployed they leave faster. The effect of finding a job on return is more ambiguous. For students from developed (including EU) countries it hardly affects their return, while students from less developed countries and Antilles/Surinam are more prone to leave after finding a job. Marriage in the Netherlands makes the students more prone to stay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bijwaard2016return,
  author = {Govert E. Bijwaard and Qi Wang},
  title = {{Return Migration of Foreign Students}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/s10680-015-9360-2},
}
Figure