Retrospective analysis of breast lumps in a given population: an institutional study

Deepak Choudhary, Sandeep Goyal, Sandeep Beniwal, Pawan Kapoor, Pawan GoyalInternational Surgery Journal 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Background: A lump in the breast is a common complaint in surgical outpatient departments, often accompanied by significant anxiety regarding potential malignancy. Early presentation and prompt diagnosis are essential to manage non-neoplastic conditions and improve outcomes for carcinoma. This retrospective study audits the clinicopathologic features of patients with breast lumps at a teaching hospital in Northern India.

Methods: A total of 138 patients presenting with breast lumps between 2013 and 2015 were retrospectively analyzed. Data on demographics, symptom duration, clinical findings, and histopathological diagnoses were extracted and analyzed using SPSS software.

Results: The study included 131 females and 7 males. The mean age was 36.8 years. Painless lumps were reported by 54.3% of patients. Notably, 40.6% of patients delayed seeking medical advice for over 12 months. Fibroadenoma was the most common benign lesion (46.2%), while ductal carcinoma was the primary malignancy (35.1%).

Conclusions: Breast lumps are a frequent presentation, but significant delays in seeking care persist, particularly for painless masses. Improved public health awareness is critical for early diagnosis and treatment.

Introduction

Breast cancer is the leading malignancy globally, accounting for over 15% of all cancer cases. In clinical practice, a breast lump is the most common reason patients visit a surgical outpatient department. While the presence of a lump causes significant anxiety, many patients—particularly in developing regions—delay seeking help.

The authors address the need for localized clinicopathologic data to understand the patterns of breast disease in their specific demographic. By auditing these features, the study aims to identify patterns in presentation and the accuracy of clinical versus histological (tissue-based) diagnoses.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective audit of 138 patients at the Maharaja Agrasen Medical College in Haryana, India. Key methodological steps included:

  • Data Extraction: Information was pulled from case files regarding age, parity, symptom duration, lump location, and size.
  • Diagnostic Correlation: The study compared initial clinical diagnoses with final histopathological diagnoses obtained via biopsy (excision, incision, core-cut, or FNAC).
  • Statistical Analysis: Data were processed using SPSS software, employing Chi-square tests to determine the significance of the findings.

Results and Clinical Insights

Demographics and Presentation

The study population consisted of 131 females and 7 males, with ages ranging from 15 to 70 years. The age distribution highlights that a significant portion of the patients were under 40 years old, with the highest frequency in the <20 age group.

Age distribution of patients presenting with breast lumps.

A major insight is the significant delay in seeking care. Only 17.4% of patients sought medical advice within the first month of discovering a lump, while over 40% waited longer than a year. This delay is often linked to the fact that 54.3% of lumps were painless, leading to a false sense of security among patients.

Anatomical and Pathological Findings

The upper outer quadrant was the most common site for lumps (34.9%), and the left breast was slightly more frequently affected (47.1%) than the right. Histopathological confirmation remains the gold standard for diagnosis, revealing a mix of benign and malignant conditions.

Final histopathological diagnosis of breast lumps.

Fibroadenomas were the most common benign diagnosis (46.2%), typically appearing in younger patients. Conversely, breast cancer (primarily ductal carcinoma) accounted for nearly 36% of cases, generally affecting an older cohort. The clinical diagnosis of breast carcinoma was found to be relatively accurate when compared to histological results, suggesting that clinical examination remains a robust diagnostic tool in experienced hands.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Breast lumps are the primary presenting complaint for both benign and malignant diseases. The findings underscore a critical public health challenge: the significant delay in presentation for painless masses.

Future public health initiatives must focus on encouraging patients to report any lump immediately, regardless of whether it is painful. While this study provides valuable institutional data, larger multi-center prospective studies are needed to further refine these demographic patterns and track long-term patient outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background:A lump in the breast is a common complaint presenting in the surgical outpatient department of all major hospitals, with anxiety regarding a possible malignancy being extremely common. Early presentation and prompt diagnosis is essential to relieve anxiety of non-neoplastic conditions, and in case of carcinoma, it can save the patient from metastases. This retrospective study aims to audit the clinic pathologic features of patients with breast lump at teaching hospital in northern India.Methods: A total of 138 patients were included for the present study. The data on all patients who presented with history of breast lump to the surgical outpatient department at a teaching hospital, Maharaja Agrasen Medical College, Agroha from 1st January 2013 to 31st December 2015 were retrospectively analyzed. Information on age at presentation, parity, duration of symptom before presentation, previous breast disease, side and quadrant of breast affected, maximum diameter of breast lump, clinical diagnosis made by the senior registrar or unit consultant, type of biopsy done and histology diagnosis for patients who returned with histology report were extracted from the case files. All the results were analyzed by Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) software. Chi-square test was used to measure the level of significance.Results:in our present study, out of all the patients, 7 were males and rests were females. Out of 131 females, 3 (2.1%) were premenstrual and 35 (25.4%) were postmenopausal. 39 (28.3%) female patients were nulliparous. Lump was painless in 75 (54.3%) patients. Duration from discovery of lump to presentation was &lt; 1 months in 24 (17.4%), 1-3 months 10 (7.2%), 3-6 months 18 (13.0%), 6-12 months 20 (14.5%), &gt; 12 months in 56 (40.6%) and ranges from 2 days to 19 years. The duration was not documented in 10 (7.2%) patients. Left breast was more affected i.e. 65 (47.1%) cases than right sided. Bilateral involvement in around 12 cases (8.7%). Breast lump was presenting complaint in 138 patients in 3 years. The mean age of patients presenting with breast lump was 36.8 years (Range 15-70 years).Conclusions:Breast lump was the most common presenting complaint with most patients not presenting within one month.
BibTeX
@article{choudhary2016retrospective,
  author = {Deepak Choudhary and Sandeep Goyal and Sandeep Beniwal and Pawan Kapoor and Pawan Goyal},
  title = {{Retrospective analysis of breast lumps in a given population: an institutional study}},
  journal = {International Surgery Journal},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.18203/2349-2902.isj20162745},
}
Figure