Retrospective analysis of 217 fatal intoxication autopsy cases from 2009 to 2021: temporal trends in fatal intoxication at Tongji center for medicolegal expertise, Hubei, China

Lin Lihua, Yuning Wang, He Henghui, Xiang Liu, Min Jiang, Li Zehao, Li Lianjie, Qian LiuFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This retrospective analysis examines 217 fatal intoxication autopsies performed at the Tongji Center for Medicolegal Expertise in Hubei (TCMEH) between 2009 and 2021. By comparing these findings with a previous decade of data (1999–2008), the study identifies significant shifts in poisoning patterns. While deaths from traditional agents like carbon monoxide and rodenticides have declined due to regulation, fatalities from alcohol and synthetic drugs are increasing. The results highlight a stark gender divide in the manner of death and emphasize the need for updated forensic protocols and public safety policies.

Introduction

In China, rapid urbanization and evolving chemical regulations are fundamentally altering the landscape of fatal poisonings. Despite these changes, comprehensive national statistics based on autopsy-confirmed cases remain limited. Forensic pathologists and law enforcement require up-to-date data to recognize emerging toxicological threats and improve public health interventions. This study addresses this gap by analyzing over a decade of data from a major forensic center in Central China.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 4,753 autopsy records at TCMEH. From this pool, 217 cases were identified where intoxication was the primary cause of death between 2009 and 2021. Toxicological screening utilized advanced techniques, including Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS/MS) and Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). These results were statistically compared against a baseline dataset of 218 cases from 1999–2008 to identify temporal trends.

Comparison of age distribution in intoxication deaths between 1999–2008 and 2009–2021.

The analysis revealed that fatal intoxications are most prevalent among males and individuals aged 30–39.

Sex and age distribution of fatal intoxication cases from 1999 to 2021.
  • Gender Disparities: Men accounted for 60.8% of the cases and were significantly more likely to die from accidental exposures, often linked to alcohol consumption and social pressures. Conversely, women (39.2%) were more likely to die by suicide, frequently using pesticides.
  • Impact of Regulation: A sharp decline was observed in deaths from tetramine (a potent rodenticide) and carbon monoxide (CO). This shift is attributed to stricter government enforcement on rodenticides and the transition from coal to cleaner heating sources.
  • The Rise of Synthetic Drugs: Fatalities involving amphetamines emerged from zero in the previous decade to 4.6% in the current study, reflecting a growing trend in synthetic drug abuse.

Results: Toxic Agents and Manner of Death

Pesticides remain the leading cause of fatal intoxication, involved in 33.2% of deaths, with organophosphates being the most common subtype. Alcohol-related fatalities saw a significant increase, rising from 12.4% to 19.4% of total intoxication deaths.

The manner of death was predominantly accidental (60.4%), followed by suicide (26.3%) and homicide (6.5%). Notably, homicides often involved the use of succinylcholine or cyanide, sometimes delivered via illegal hunting tools. The study also highlighted the vulnerability of children to accidental phosphine gas inhalation from improperly stored household rodenticides.

Conclusion

The decrease in the proportion of autopsies attributed to intoxication (from 9.0% to 4.7%) indicates the success of public health regulations. However, the emergence of new psychoactive substances and the persistence of pesticide-related suicides call for continued vigilance. Recommendations include stricter storage for household chemicals and the constant updating of toxicological libraries to detect evolving chemical threats.

Summary updated

Abstract

This retrospective analysis of fatal intoxication case autopsies was performed at Tongji Center for Medicolegal Expertise in Hubei (TCMEH) from 2009 to 2021 to obtain up-to-date information on intoxication cases. The objective was to describe important data about evolving patterns in intoxication occurrences, enhance public safety policies, and assist forensic examiners and police in more efficient handling of such cases. Analyses based on sex, age, topical exposure routes, toxic agents, and mode of death were performed using 217 records of intoxication cases collected from TCMEH as a sample, and the results were compared with reports previously published (from 1999 to 2008) from this institution. Deaths from intoxications occurred at a higher rate in males than in females and were most common among individuals aged 30-39 years. The most frequent method of exposure was oral ingestion. The causative agents of deadly intoxications have changed when compared to the data from the previous 10 years. For instance, deaths from amphetamine overdoses are becoming more prevalent gradually, whereas deaths due to carbon monoxide and rodenticide intoxication have declined dramatically. In 72 cases, pesticides continued to be the most frequent intoxication cause. A total of 60.4% of the deaths were accidental exposure. Men died from accidents at a higher rate than women, although women were more likely to commit suicide. Particular focus is needed on the use of succinylcholine, cyanide, and paraquat in homicides.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lihua2023retrospective,
  author = {Lin Lihua and Yuning Wang and He Henghui and Xiang Liu and Min Jiang and Li Zehao and Li Lianjie and Qian Liu},
  title = {{Retrospective analysis of 217 fatal intoxication autopsy cases from 2009 to 2021: temporal trends in fatal intoxication at Tongji center for medicolegal expertise, Hubei, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1137649},
}
Figure