Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery versus Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Lower Calyceal Stones of ≤ 2 cm

Rajiv Ratn Shah, Tika Devi Kandel, Deepak AdhikariJournal of College of Medical Sciences-Nepal 2023 · DOI

This research paper, published in the Journal of College of Medical Sciences-Nepal, compares two minimally invasive surgical techniques for treating medium-sized kidney stones located in the lower part of the kidney.

TL;DR

For kidney stones between 1–2 cm in the lower calyx, surgeons face a trade-off: mini-PCNL offers a higher stone-free rate but carries a greater risk of bleeding, while RIRS is less invasive with shorter hospital stays but is slightly less effective and more likely to cause post-operative fever.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Kidney stones in the "lower pole" (the bottom section of the kidney) are notoriously difficult to treat. Because of gravity, fragments don't wash out easily after being broken up. While Shockwave Lithotripsy (SWL) is non-invasive, its success rate for lower pole stones is often disappointing (37%–68%).

Urologists generally choose between two surgical "routes":

  1. Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS): Going "up the natural plumbing" through the urethra and ureter using a flexible scope and lasers.
  2. Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (mini-PCNL): Creating a small "tunnel" through the skin of the back directly into the kidney.

The "optimal" choice for stones in the 1–2 cm range is still a matter of intense debate in the urological community. This study aims to provide comparative data on which method is safer and more effective.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective comparative study at Chitwan Medical College, Nepal, involving 60 adult patients with solitary lower calyceal stones (1–2 cm). Patients were divided into two groups of 30 via a simple lottery method:

  • Group A (RIRS): Performed in the lithotomy position. Surgeons used a flexible fiberoptic ureteroscope and a 100-Watt Holmium:YAG laser to "dust" the stones. All patients received a temporary double J (DJ) stent.
  • Group B (mini-PCNL): Performed in the prone position (face down). Surgeons created a small tract (up to 20 Fr) and used a pneumatic lithotripter to pulverize the stones. This was a "tubeless" procedure (no nephrostomy tube), though a DJ stent was used.

The study measured stone-free rates (defined as fragments $\le$ 4mm at 12 weeks), operative time, hospital stay duration, and complications.

Datasets

The "dataset" consists of clinical data from 60 patients treated between October 2022 and March 2023.

  • Inclusion: Adults with solitary 1–2 cm lower calyceal stones.
  • Exclusion: Patients under 18, those with multiple stones, stones > 2 cm, renal failure, or active infections.
  • Statistical Tools: Data was analyzed using SPSS 20, employing Student’s t-tests for continuous variables and chi-squared tests for categorical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Efficacy vs. Invasiveness Trade-off: The study reinforces the idea that there is no "free lunch" in surgery. The more invasive route (mini-PCNL) is better at clearing stones, but the less invasive route (RIRS) gets patients home faster.
  • Complication Profiles: The types of complications were distinct. Mini-PCNL patients suffered significantly more from hematuria (blood in urine, 70% of cases) because the kidney tissue is punctured. RIRS patients suffered more from pyrexia (fever), likely due to the high-pressure fluid irrigation required to see through the flexible scope.
  • Technological Barriers: The authors note that while RIRS is attractive, the high cost of flexible scopes and lasers remains a major deterrent in developing countries.

Key Results

  • Stone-Free Rate (SFR): Mini-PCNL was superior, achieving a 90% success rate compared to 83.33% for RIRS ($p < 0.001$).
  • Hospital Stay: RIRS allowed for faster discharge, with an average stay of 3.47 days versus 4.50 days for mini-PCNL.
  • Operative Time: Mini-PCNL was generally faster (~62.5 minutes) than RIRS (~79.4 minutes), though this didn't quite reach the standard threshold for statistical significance ($p = 0.091$).
  • Hemoglobin Drop: There was a significantly larger drop in hemoglobin (indicating blood loss) in the mini-PCNL group, though no patients required a blood transfusion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: With only 30 patients per group, the study is relatively small. Larger, multi-center trials would provide more robust data.
  • Stone Stratification: The study grouped all stones between 1–2 cm together. Results might differ significantly for a 1.1 cm stone versus a 1.9 cm stone.
  • Follow-up: The study focused on short-term outcomes (up to 12 weeks). Long-term data on stone recurrence or late complications (like ureteric strictures from RIRS) would be valuable.
  • Cost Analysis: A formal cost-benefit analysis comparing the expensive equipment of RIRS vs. the longer hospital stays of mini-PCNL was not performed.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction: Renal stones are one of the common urological problems. The optimal management of lower calyceal renal calculi of 1-2 cm is still debatable. The objective of this research is to assess the safety, efficacy, and stone-free rate of retrograde intrarenal surgery and mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy for the management of lower calyceal stones of 1-2 cm. Methods: A prospective comparative study was conducted among 30 patients which were divided in two group (A and B) prospectively with lower calyceal stones of 1-2 cm. Group A were treated with retrograde intra renal surgery while Group B were treated with mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Results: The mean age of patient in Group-A was 44.27±17.10 year and in Group-B was 45.27±16.11 year. The hospital stay in Group-A was 3.47±0.62 and in Group-B was 4.50±0.73 days. The stone size in Group-A was 13.30±2.21 mm and in Group-B was 15.60±2.55 with p-value of 0.381. The duration of operation time in Group-A was79.37±13.96 minutes and in Group-B was 62.53±7.41 minutes with p value of 0.091. Conclusions: Both retrograde intrarenal surgery and mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy procedure are comparable. Mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy has a better stone free rate and haematuria is more common but retrograde intrarenal surgery has less hospital stay and post operative pyrexia is more common.
BibTeX
@article{shah2023retrograde,
  author = {Rajiv Ratn Shah and Tika Devi Kandel and Deepak Adhikari},
  title = {{Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery versus Mini-Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Lower Calyceal Stones of ≤ 2 cm}},
  journal = {Journal of College of Medical Sciences-Nepal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3126/jcmsn.v19i4.56590},
}
Figure