Retinotopic and topographic analyses with gaze restriction for steady-state visual evoked potentials

Nannan Zhang, Yadong Liu, Erwei Yin, Baosong Deng, Lu Cao, Jun Jiang, Zongtan Zhou, Dewen HuScientific 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Although the mechanisms of steady-state visual evoked potentials (SSVEPs) have been well studied, none of them have been implemented with strictly experimental conditions. Our objective was to create an ideal observer condition to exploit the features of SSVEPs. We present here an electroencephalographic (EEG) eye tracking experimental paradigm that provides biofeedback for gaze restriction during the visual stimulation. Specifically, we designed an EEG eye tracking synchronous data recording system for successful trial selection. Forty-six periodic flickers within a visual field of 11.5° were successively presented to evoke SSVEP responses, and online biofeedback based on an eye tracker was provided for gaze restriction. For eight participants, SSVEP responses in the visual field and topographic maps from full-brain EEG were plotted and analyzed. The experimental results indicated that the optimal visual flicking arrangement to boost SSVEPs should include the features of circular stimuli within a 4–6° spatial distance and increased stimulus area below the fixation point. These findings provide a basis for determining stimulus parameters for neural engineering studies, e.g. SSVEP-based brain-computer interface (BCI) designs.

Introduction

Steady-State Visual Evoked Potentials (SSVEPs) are periodic brain responses elicited by flickering visual stimuli. Due to their high signal-to-noise ratio and minimal training requirements, they are widely used in non-invasive Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs). However, standard BCI paradigms often allow overt attention (direct gaze), which obscures the underlying retinotopic mapping—how specific regions of the visual field contribute to the overall signal.

To optimize BCI performance, it is critical to understand the "ideal observer" conditions. This study addresses the lack of strictly controlled experimental data by implementing a gaze-restricted paradigm to map the cortical response across the visual field, providing a blueprint for stimulus size, shape, and spatial arrangement.

Methods

The researchers developed a synchronized system combining 31-channel high-density EEG with an infrared eye tracker to ensure data integrity.

Experimental Paradigm

Eight healthy participants (ages 23–30) were tasked with maintaining fixation on a central cross. To enforce gaze restriction, real-time biofeedback was provided; trials where the gaze drifted more than 1.5° from the center were automatically discarded. The stimulus set consisted of 46 circular flickers (15 Hz) arranged in six concentric layers across an 11.5° visual field.

Data Analysis

Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) was employed to quantify the relationship between the EEG signals and the stimulus frequency. The team also analyzed the "single-channel contribution" to determine the topographic distribution of the response across the scalp, focusing on the occipital and parietal regions.

Results

The study revealed several critical spatial characteristics of the SSVEP response that can significantly impact BCI design.

The Retinotopic Map

The strongest SSVEP responses were not uniformly distributed across the visual field. A significant "below the midline" advantage was observed, where stimuli in the lower visual field evoked more robust signals than those in the upper field. This suggests that the human visual system is more sensitive to periodic changes occurring below the point of fixation.

Retinotopic mapping of SSVEP responses across the visual field. (a) Individual 3D surface plots of CCA scores for eight subjects. (b) 2D contour map showing stimulus positions and signal intensity. (c) Statistical decay of CCA scores as a function of stimulus eccentricity.

Optimal Spacing and Interference

The researchers quantified the "error rate"—the likelihood of a peripheral flicker producing a stronger signal than the target. This rate was 11.55% at a 2° separation but dropped to 2.08% at 6°. This suggests a "Goldilocks zone" for stimulus spacing between 4° and 6°, where competitive inhibition between stimuli is minimized without sacrificing interface density.

Topographic Distribution

While the primary response was concentrated in the occipital region (electrodes O1, Oz, O2), a clear contralateral effect was observed in the parietal-occipital pairs (PO3–PO4). Stimuli in the right visual field triggered stronger responses in the left hemisphere, and vice versa. Quantifying this effect helps in selecting which EEG channels to prioritize based on button placement.

Discussion

These findings have direct implications for BCI engineering. The authors recommend a layout where the target character (e.g., a letter) is positioned slightly above the center of the flickering area. This ensures that when a user looks at the character, the bulk of the flickering stimulus falls into the high-sensitivity zone below their fixation point. Furthermore, circular stimuli were found to be more effective than square ones, likely due to the circular nature of receptive fields in the primary visual cortex.

While limited by a small sample size and a single test frequency (15 Hz), this study provides a precise framework for future neural engineering. Future work will investigate frequency-dependent variations and the potential for personalized BCI layouts based on individual topographic maps.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Although the mechanisms of steady-state visual evoked potentials (SSVEPs) have been well studied, none of them have been implemented with strictly experimental conditions. Our objective was to create an ideal observer condition to exploit the features of SSVEPs. We present here an electroencephalographic (EEG) eye tracking experimental paradigm that provides biofeedback for gaze restriction during the visual stimulation. Specifically, we designed an EEG eye tracking synchronous data recording system for successful trial selection. Forty-six periodic flickers within a visual field of 11.5° were successively presented to evoke SSVEP responses, and online biofeedback based on an eye tracker was provided for gaze restriction. For eight participants, SSVEP responses in the visual field and topographic maps from full-brain EEG were plotted and analyzed. The experimental results indicated that the optimal visual flicking arrangement to boost SSVEPs should include the features of circular stimuli within a 4–6° spatial distance and increased stimulus area below the fixation point. These findings provide a basis for determining stimulus parameters for neural engineering studies, e.g. SSVEP-based brain-computer interface (BCI) designs. The proposed experimental paradigm could also provide a precise framework for future SSVEP-related studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019retinotopic,
  author = {Nannan Zhang and Yadong Liu and Erwei Yin and Baosong Deng and Lu Cao and Jun Jiang and Zongtan Zhou and Dewen Hu},
  title = {{Retinotopic and topographic analyses with gaze restriction for steady-state visual evoked potentials}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-41158-5},
}

Loading related content...

Figure