Retention of deposited ammonium and nitrate and its impact on the global forest carbon sink

Geshere Abdisa Gurmesa, Ang Wang, Shanlong Li, Shushi Peng, W. de Vries, Per Gundersen, Philippe Ciais, Oliver L. Phillips, Erik A. Hobbie, Weixing Zhu, Knute J. Nadelhoffer, Yi Xi, Edith Bai, Tao Sun, Dexiang Chen, Wenjun Zhou, Yiping Zhang, Yingrong Guo, Jiaojun Zhu, Lei Duan, Dejun Li, Keisuke Koba, Enzai Du, Guoyi Zhou, Xingguo Han, Shijie Han, Yunting FangNature Communications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Human activities are significantly increasing nitrogen deposition globally, impacting forest carbon sinks. This study reveals that while forests retain similar amounts of deposited ammonium and nitrate, nitrate is preferentially taken up by plants, and ammonium by soils. This differential fate leads to a larger estimated N-deposition-induced carbon sink in forests than previously thought.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing deposition of nitrogen (N) into ecosystems due to human activities is a major environmental concern. This N can influence the global carbon (C) cycle, particularly by enhancing forest carbon sinks. However, the impact of N deposition depends crucially on its form: reduced (ammonium, NH₄⁺) or oxidized (nitrate, NO₃⁻). While it's generally understood that plants might prefer ammonium and soils might retain it better, the precise fates of these two forms of N and their distinct contributions to forest C sinks remain unclear. This lack of clarity hinders accurate estimations of the global forest C sink and its response to future changes in N deposition. This paper aims to resolve this by quantifying and comparing the retention and fate of deposited ammonium and nitrate across diverse forest ecosystems.

Methods

The core of this research relies on paired ¹⁵N-tracer experiments conducted across 13 forest sites spanning tropical, subtropical, and temperate climate zones. At each site, researchers simultaneously applied isotopically labeled ammonium (¹⁵NH₄⁺) and nitrate (¹⁵NO₃⁻) to the forest floor. Over approximately one year, they meticulously tracked the recovery of the ¹⁵N label in various ecosystem compartments: plants (including trees and understory vegetation), soil organic layer, and mineral soil. This allowed them to quantify the retention fractions of each N form in different pools and estimate losses from the ecosystem.

To scale these findings globally, the researchers developed stoichiometric upscaling models. They established relationships between ¹⁵N recovery in different pools and ecosystem characteristics like soil C/N ratio, soil organic layer mass, annual net primary production (NPP), and wood biomass. These relationships, derived from the experimental data, were then applied to global gridded datasets of these characteristics and N deposition to estimate N retention and its impact on the C sink across all global forests.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • 13 ecosystem-scale paired ¹⁵N-tracer experiments: These experiments were conducted across China, Europe, and the USA, providing the primary empirical data for N retention.
  • Global gridded datasets: These included:
  • Global maps of total N deposition (NH₄⁺ and NO₃⁻) for forests, derived from four different models.
  • Global forest cover data.
  • Global maps of Net Primary Production (NPP).
  • Global soil datasets for C/N ratios, soil organic layer mass, and wood biomass.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing global datasets were leveraged for the upscaling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differential but balanced retention: While plants preferentially take up nitrate and soils preferentially retain ammonium, the total ecosystem retention of both forms of N is remarkably similar over the first year. This challenges the assumption that one form is inherently much better retained than the other at the ecosystem level.
  • Nitrate's plant preference is key: The higher uptake of nitrate by plants, despite the common belief that plants favor ammonium, is a crucial finding. This suggests that nitrate, even if less abundant in some soils, is readily available and efficiently assimilated by plants, contributing significantly to plant biomass.
  • Soil organic matter as a major sink: Both ammonium and nitrate are substantially retained in soil pools, particularly the soil organic layer in temperate forests. This highlights the critical role of soil processes in buffering N inputs and influencing long-term N availability.
  • Climate and soil attributes matter: The partitioning of N between plants and soils, and overall retention, varies significantly with biome-specific factors like climate (temperature, precipitation) and soil properties (organic matter content, C/N ratio). Temperate forests, for instance, show higher retention in organic soil compared to tropical forests.
  • Nitrate drives a larger C sink: Because nitrate is more effectively taken up by plants and incorporated into biomass, it drives a larger N-deposition-induced C sink per unit of N deposited compared to ammonium.

Key Results

  • Total ecosystem N retention: Similar for ammonium (67%) and nitrate (69%) one year after labeling.
  • Plant uptake: Plants took up significantly more labeled nitrate (20% of applied) than ammonium (12%).
  • Soil retention: Soils retained more ammonium (57%) than nitrate (46%).
  • N-deposition-induced C sink: Estimated at 0.72–0.96 Pg C yr⁻¹ in the 2010s, which is higher than previous estimates.
  • Nitrate's C gain: Deposited nitrate contributes to a greater C gain per unit of N deposited (35 ± 145 kg C kg⁻¹ N) compared to ammonium (24 ± 33 kg C kg⁻¹ N).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Uneven distribution of experimental sites: The lack of sites in African and South American forests reduces confidence in estimates for these regions. The study sites were also primarily in areas with moderate to high ambient N deposition.
  • Seasonal bias: ¹⁵N labeling was mostly conducted during the growing season, assuming year-round retention efficiency, which might overestimate plant uptake and the C sink.
  • Short-term focus: The C sink estimates are based on the first year of deposited N fate. Longer-term turnover and loss of N could alter the impact on the C sink.

Future work should aim to:

  • Expand ¹⁵N-tracer experiments to underrepresented regions (e.g., Africa, South America) and areas with low N deposition.
  • Investigate the long-term fate of deposited N and its implications for C sequestration beyond the first year.
  • Further refine the understanding of how land use, technology, and policy changes might alter future NH₄⁺ and NO₃⁻ input ratios and, consequently, forest C sinks.

Summary updated

Abstract

The impacts of enhanced nitrogen (N) deposition on the global forest carbon (C) sink and other ecosystem services may depend on whether N is deposited in reduced (mainly as ammonium) or oxidized forms (mainly as nitrate) and the subsequent fate of each. However, the fates of the two key reactive N forms and their contributions to forest C sinks are unclear. Here, we analyze results from 13 ecosystem-scale paired <sup>15</sup>N-labelling experiments in temperate, subtropical, and tropical forests. Results show that total ecosystem N retention is similar for ammonium and nitrate, but plants take up more labelled nitrate ([Formula: see text]%) ([Formula: see text]) than ammonium ([Formula: see text]%) while soils retain more ammonium ([Formula: see text]%) than nitrate ([Formula: see text]%). We estimate that the N deposition-induced C sink in forests in the 2010s is [Formula: see text] Pg C yr<sup>-1</sup>, higher than previous estimates because of a larger role for oxidized N and greater rates of global N deposition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gurmesa2022retention,
  author = {Geshere Abdisa Gurmesa and Ang Wang and Shanlong Li and Shushi Peng and W. de Vries and Per Gundersen and Philippe Ciais and Oliver L. Phillips and Erik A. Hobbie and Weixing Zhu and Knute J. Nadelhoffer and Yi Xi and Edith Bai and Tao Sun and Dexiang Chen and Wenjun Zhou and Yiping Zhang and Yingrong Guo and Jiaojun Zhu and Lei Duan and Dejun Li and Keisuke Koba and Enzai Du and Guoyi Zhou and Xingguo Han and Shijie Han and Yunting Fang},
  title = {{Retention of deposited ammonium and nitrate and its impact on the global forest carbon sink}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-28345-1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure