Restituer les bidonvilles de Nanterre : l’apport d’un outil de visualisation 3D à un projet de sciences sociales

Paul Lecat, Emile Blettery, Lætitia Delavoipière, Frédéric Saly-Giocanti, Sylvaine Conord, Valérie Gouet-Brunet, Alexandre Devaux, Mathieu Brédif, Frédéric MoretHumanités 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how a 3D visualization platform, iTowns, can be used to integrate and analyze diverse historical data for social science research. By combining historical aerial imagery with census data, the researchers were able to reconstruct and understand the formation of shantytowns in Nanterre, France, offering a novel approach to urban history and sociology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The study tackles the challenge of reconstructing and understanding the history of informal settlements, specifically the shantytowns (bidonvilles) of Nanterre, France, that emerged in the mid-1950s. Traditional historical and sociological research often struggles with the ephemeral nature of such settlements, which leave limited material traces and fragmented archival documentation. The authors aim to bridge this gap by leveraging a multidisciplinary approach that combines historical data with advanced visualization tools to create a more comprehensive understanding of their formation, spatial organization, and persistence in collective memory.

Methods

The core of the methodology revolves around the use of the iTowns platform, an open-source 3D visualization and spatialization tool. The researchers employed a semi-automatic georeferencing technique to integrate historical aerial photographs into a 3D model of the territory. This involved selecting corresponding points in both the 2D photograph and the 3D reference model to estimate the camera's pose. Additionally, they processed and spatialized census data from 1954, detailing social and housing characteristics at the "îlot" (city block) level. The iTowns platform then allowed for the covisualization of these heterogeneous datasets, enabling temporal navigation and comparative analysis between historical aerial views and current urban structures.

Datasets

  • 1954 Census Data: Statistical data from the general population census of May 1954, specifically focusing on the Seine department. This data was processed and organized by "îlot" (city block) and included information on population, active population, housing, and buildings.
  • IGN Aerial Photographs: A collection of historical aerial photographs from the IGN (Institut national de l'information géographique et forestière) and departmental archives (AD92). These included both vertical and oblique views, dating from the 1947-1960 period, with a focus on Nanterre and its shantytowns.
  • Urban Data: Contemporary 3D models of buildings and infrastructure were used as the reference for georeferencing historical images.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D Visualization as an Integrative Tool: The study highlights the power of 3D visualization platforms like iTowns to bring together disparate data sources (historical imagery, statistical data) into a cohesive and interactive spatial context.
  • Bridging Historical and Social Sciences: The research demonstrates how interdisciplinary collaboration between historians, sociologists, and computer scientists can unlock new insights into complex social phenomena by leveraging advanced digital tools.
  • Understanding the "Ephemeral": The methodology proved effective in documenting the formation and evolution of informal settlements, which are often difficult to study due to their transient nature.
  • Photo Elicitation in a Digital Context: The use of historical photographs within the iTowns platform facilitated a form of "photo elicitation," allowing former residents to engage with and narrate their experiences within the spatial context of their former homes.
  • Temporal Navigation is Crucial: The ability to navigate through time using a temporal slider was identified as a critical feature for understanding the dynamic evolution of urban spaces like shantytowns.

Key Results

The research successfully reconstructed the formation of the "La Folie" shantytown in Nanterre, tracing its development from scattered huts in 1954 to a more structured settlement by 1961. By overlaying census data with aerial imagery, the study identified specific "îlots" with a high concentration of Algerian residents and noted the correlation between these areas and the emergence of informal housing. The platform allowed for a visual comparison of the urban transformation, highlighting the stark contrast between the informal settlements and the concurrent large-scale urban development projects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Completeness and Accuracy: The authors acknowledge that the 1954 census data for Algerian residents might be underestimated due to the difficult living conditions and potential distrust of authorities. The georeferencing process, while semi-automatic, still required manual input and could be subject to inaccuracies, especially with older or less clear imagery.
  • Platform Updates: One interviewee noted that the iTowns platform's data might not always be up-to-date, with new constructions not immediately reflected.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the iTowns platform has vast potential for further research on urban history and social issues in the Paris region. They also mention that the IGN is continuing to integrate new photographic archives, which will further enrich the possibilities for cross-referencing and new research projects. The development of new functionalities for the platform, particularly for users less familiar with coding, is also an ongoing effort.

Summary updated

Abstract

Au milieu des années 1950 surgissent à Nanterre les premières cabanes de fortune abritant des travailleurs algériens. Bientôt, ces baraques informelles s’agrègent et finissent par former des ensembles urbains, présentés et administrés comme des bidonvilles, et la ville de Nanterre y est alors durablement associée. Cet article se propose de revenir sur une expérience de recherche interdisciplinaire autour de cet objet d’étude. Des chercheurs en histoire et en sociologie urbaine ont collaboré avec des informaticiens de l’IGN afin d’utiliser et d’enrichir une plateforme de spatialisation et de visualisation de données hétérogènes pour documenter l’histoire de ces bidonvilles et comprendre la formation et la permanence de ces lieux dans la mémoire collective actuelle.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lecat2021restituer,
  author = {Paul Lecat and Emile Blettery and Lætitia Delavoipière and Frédéric Saly-Giocanti and Sylvaine Conord and Valérie Gouet-Brunet and Alexandre Devaux and Mathieu Brédif and Frédéric Moret},
  title = {{Restituer les bidonvilles de Nanterre : l’apport d’un outil de visualisation 3D à un projet de sciences sociales}},
  booktitle = {Humanités},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.4000/revuehn.1946},
}
Figure