Responses to heartbeats in ventromedial prefrontal cortex contribute to subjective preference-based decisions

Damiano Azzalini, Anne Buot, Stefano Palminteri, Catherine Tallon‐BaudrybioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that our internal bodily signals, specifically heartbeat-evoked responses (HERs) in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), play a crucial role in subjective decision-making. The interaction between these internal signals and the neural encoding of subjective value in the vmPFC predicts how consistently we make preference-based choices, suggesting that self-reflection, rooted in interoception, is key to stable preferences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We often make decisions based on subjective preferences, like choosing a movie we "like best." These decisions are deeply personal and involve self-reflection – considering how an item affects us. However, the neural mechanisms underlying this self-reflection and its contribution to subjective valuation have remained largely unspecified. While we understand how the brain encodes objective value (e.g., the number of characters in a word), the biological basis for subjective preference, which relies on internal states and self-awareness, is less clear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how the brain's monitoring of internal bodily signals, specifically heartbeats, interfaces with value encoding in the vmPFC to support subjective decision-making.

Methods

The researchers employed magnetoencephalography (MEG) and electrocardiography (ECG) to simultaneously record brain and cardiac activity from human participants. The core of their approach involved:

  • Heartbeat-Evoked Responses (HERs): They measured neural responses time-locked to heartbeats (specifically, T-waves on the ECG) during an "instruction period" before participants made a choice. This allowed them to assess how the brain responds to internal bodily signals when preparing for a decision.
  • Subjective vs. Objective Decisions: Participants performed two types of tasks:
  • Preference-based choice: Choosing between two movie titles based on their subjective liking.
  • Perceptual discrimination: Choosing between two movie titles based on an objective feature (visual contrast). This served as a control to isolate the effects related to subjective preference.
  • Value Encoding: Using time-resolved statistical modeling (Generalized Linear Models - GLMs), they analyzed the MEG data during the "choice period" to identify how subjective value (likability ratings) and objective evidence (contrast) were encoded in neural activity.
  • Interaction Analysis: Crucially, they investigated whether HERs measured before the choice interacted with the neural encoding of subjective value during the choice. This was done using statistical analyses, including cluster-based permutation tests and regression models, to determine if the strength of HERs predicted the precision of value encoding and, consequently, choice consistency.
  • Control Measures: They also analyzed cardiac parameters (heart rate, stroke volume) and arousal indices (pupil diameter, alpha power) to rule out these factors as explanations for their findings.

Datasets

The study used a dataset of 540 popular movie titles. Participants first rated the likability of these movies in a behavioral session. Then, in the MEG session, pairs of these movie titles were presented as stimuli for decision-making tasks. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing behavioral and neuroimaging data collection and analysis techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heartbeats as a "Self-Signal": The study strongly suggests that our brain's response to heartbeats (HERs) isn't just a passive physiological event but an active signal that influences subjective decision-making.
  • vmPFC as the Integration Hub: The ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) appears to be a critical area where these internal bodily signals (HERs) are integrated with the brain's representation of subjective value.
  • Preparation Matters: The timing of HERs is important. HERs measured before the decision (during preparation) seem to prime the brain for subjective valuation, leading to stronger value encoding later.
  • Subjectivity is Key: The interaction between HERs and value encoding was specific to subjective preference decisions, not objective perceptual tasks. This highlights the unique role of self-related processes in subjective choices.
  • Predicting Consistency: The strength of the interaction between HERs and value encoding not only influenced how precisely a choice was made on a given trial but also predicted how consistently an individual made their preferences over time.

Key Results

  • Larger HERs for Subjective Decisions: Participants showed larger HERs in the vmPFC when preparing for subjective preference-based decisions compared to objective perceptual discrimination tasks. This effect was localized in the anterior vmPFC.
  • HERs Modulate Value Encoding: Larger HERs before option presentation were followed by stronger encoding of subjective value in the vmPFC during the choice. This interaction was significant and specific to the right posterior vmPFC.
  • Choice Consistency: The magnitude of the interaction between HER amplitude and subjective value encoding explained 22% of the inter-individual differences in choice consistency. In simpler terms, individuals with a stronger interaction between their heartbeat signals and value representation were more consistent in their preferences.
  • Trial-by-Trial Precision: On a trial-by-trial basis, a larger interaction between HERs and value encoding led to increased choice precision, meaning participants made more accurate subjective choices.
  • Specificity: The observed effects were specific to HERs and subjective value encoding. HERs did not interact with the encoding of perceptual evidence in the objective task, and other physiological measures like heart rate, pupil diameter, or alpha power did not explain the findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanistic Detail: While the study shows that HERs influence value encoding and choice consistency, the precise neural mechanisms of how this influence occurs, especially the temporal dynamics between task preparation and choice, require further investigation.
  • Computational Models: The authors suggest that their findings pave the way for quantifying self-related processes in decision-making, an aspect often missing from current computational models. Future work could integrate these findings into more comprehensive models of decision-making.
  • Maladaptive Decisions: The study hints at a connection between impaired interoception and maladaptive decisions. Future research could explore this link more deeply, potentially informing interventions for psychiatric disorders characterized by decision-making deficits.
  • Raw Data Availability: While code is available, raw MEG and physiological data are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request, which is a standard practice but limits immediate independent verification by the broader community.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Forrest Gump or Matrix? Preference-based decisions are subjective and entail self-reflection. However, these self-related features are unaccounted for by known neural mechanisms of valuation and choice. Self-related processes have been linked to a basic interoceptive biological mechanism, the neural monitoring of heartbeats, in particular in ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), a region also involved in value encoding. We thus hypothesized a functional coupling between the neural monitoring of heartbeats and the precision of value encoding in vmPFC. Human participants were presented with pairs of movie titles. They indicated either which movie they preferred, or performed a control objective visual discrimination that did not require self-reflection. Using magnetoencephalography, we measured heartbeat-evoked responses (HERs) before option presentation, and confirmed that HERs in vmPFC were larger when preparing to the subjective, self-related task. We retrieved the expected cortical value network during choice with time-resolved statistical modeling. Crucially, we show that larger HERs before option presentation are followed by stronger value encoding during choice in vmPFC. This effect is independent of the overall vmPFC baseline activity. The neural interaction between HERs and value encoding predicted preference-based choice consistency over time, accounting for both inter-individual differences and trial-to-trial fluctuations within individuals. Neither cardiac activity nor arousal fluctuations could account for any of the effects. HERs did not interact with the encoding of perceptual evidence in the discrimination task. Our results show that the self-reflection underlying preference-based decisions involves the integration of HERs to subjective value encoding in vmPFC, and that this integration contributes to preference stability. Significance statement Deciding whether you prefer Forrest Gump or Matrix is based on subjective values, which only you, the decision-maker, can estimate and compare, by asking yourself. Yet, how self-reflection is biologically implemented and its contribution to subjective valuation are not known. We show that in ventromedial prefrontal cortex, the neural response to heartbeats, an interoceptive self-related process, influences the cortical representation of subjective value. The neural interaction between the cortical monitoring of heartbeats and value encoding predicts choice consistency, i.e. whether you consistently prefer Forrest Gump over Matrix over time. Our results pave the way for the quantification of self-related process in decision making and may shed new light on the relationship between maladaptive decisions and impaired interoception.
BibTeX
@misc{azzalini2019responses,
  author = {Damiano Azzalini and Anne Buot and Stefano Palminteri and Catherine Tallon‐Baudry},
  title = {{Responses to heartbeats in ventromedial prefrontal cortex contribute to subjective preference-based decisions}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/776047},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure