Response to comments on “Ensuring safety of implanted devices under MRI using reversed RF polarization”
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
We are pleased at the interest being generated by our work on reversed radiofrequency (RF) polarization for patient safety in the presence of long-wire metallic implants. The work by Eryaman et al. in response to our article demonstrates an important test case that helps delineate the validity and use of reverse polarized transmission and reception for detecting RF coupling to wire implants. In their response, they experimentally show that a spiral wire under reversed-polarization transmission produces tip heating that underestimates wire coupling by as much as 8.8× in certain spatial locations. These results closely agree with their simulations and demonstrate that wire structures of certain geometry could react unequally when exposed to ideal forward or reverse polarization. Our article broadly analyzed the conditions where a reversed transmitter polarization could expose the wire to a reversed electric field, which is not necessarily equivalent to the forward field for asymmetric loads and instrumentation limits. To avoid this potential source of inaccuracy, we proposed as one option the use of reversed polarization for only the RF receiver, while leaving the transmitter in its normal, forward-polarized configuration. This has the benefit of exposing the sample to the identically phased, forward field at all times, thereby eliminating this source of error. It would be informative to see the results of Eryaman's experiment under these imaging conditions. Theory suggests that the resulting signal should provide an excellent measure of wire coupling, even in the pathologic case of a spiral wire shape. The simplified concept and underlying theory behind reverse polarized transmission and reception assumes straight wirelike structures that generate predominantly linearly polarized fields if RF current is induced on these elements. In this case, the scattering field will contain both circularly polarized components, one of which can excite spins during transmission, while the other can create receive sensitivity even if the source field lacked these components. A device that generates linearly polarized fields will react equally to ideal left- or right-hand circular polarization, and thus the reversal of polarization should have no effect on the signal generated by this straight wire. The theory becomes more complex when the wire shape is not straight, but a key concept of our work is that a quadrature MRI receiver, when reverse-polarized, has sensitivity to the exact left-hand circularly polarized field that is present during forward transmission. This reversed receive field is not sensitive to the bulk spins excited by the birdcage itself, but is sensitive in the vicinity of a coupled wire, and that sensitivity is exactly proportional to the degree of dangerous transmitter coupling. This relationship is shown in Eqs. 4–7 of our article. The spiral wire test is equivalent to a helical antenna (1-3) (invented in 1946 by J. Kraus) and strongly violates the linearly polarized assumption. Helical antennas can radiate axial mode or normal mode circularly polarized fields. When the helical antenna (and similar spiral structures) transmits a circularly polarized field, by reciprocity, maximum current will be induced when a field of opposite rotation is incident. As Eryaman stated, such a helical shape is unlikely to occur in implants; however, it does demonstrate a limiting case. More generally, it raises the interesting question of the degree to which deep brain stimulator or pacemaker leads can create significant elliptically polarized scattering fields. Typical layouts, which are limited to more planar surgical pockets, lack the volumetric extent of the spiral, which is key to its asymmetric reaction. Our view is that the reverse-polarization technique, when combined with a very low-power MR prescan sequence, can provide a first-pass projection image to detect the possibility of unsafe current-flow conditions. It answers the question of whether an interaction exists, but is not necessarily a quantitative measure of current flow. Similar prescans are feasible with low-power conventional imaging and gradient-spoiled projections. In neither case should power levels be used in a prescan sequence that would create the reported tip heating. The next level for prescan safety would involve quantification of RF current, as demonstrated by Venook et al. (4). Ultimately, we assert that physical measurement of potentially dangerous coupling conditions is needed on a case-by-case basis to assure safety.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{overall2011response,
author = {William R. Overall and John M. Pauly and Pascal Stang and Greig Scott},
title = {{Response to comments on “Ensuring safety of implanted devices under MRI using reversed RF polarization”}},
booktitle = {Magnetic},
year = {2011},
doi = {10.1002/mrm.23183},
}Loading related content...