Resources or Capital?—The Quality Improvement Mechanism of Precision Poverty Alleviation by Land Elements

Dongsheng Zhang, Ming–Hsuan Yang, Ziyou WangLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how land, viewed as both a natural resource and a form of capital, impacts poverty alleviation in China. Using a panel vector autoregressive model, it reveals that improving land resources offers short-term poverty reduction, while developing land as capital provides longer-term, sustainable benefits through a positive feedback loop with rural poverty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has made significant strides in poverty reduction, but challenges like poverty's multidimensionality and relative nature persist. Land is a crucial element in rural livelihoods and economic activity, making its role in poverty alleviation a key area of focus. However, existing research often treats land as a monolithic entity, failing to differentiate between its "resource" and "capital" aspects and their distinct mechanisms for poverty reduction. This paper aims to clarify these distinct roles and their dynamic interactions to inform more effective and precise poverty alleviation strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a Panel Vector Autoregressive (PVAR) model to analyze the dynamic relationships between rural poverty, land resource endowment, and land capital endowment. This econometric approach is suitable for short-term panel data and controls for unobservable individual heterogeneity and time effects. They also utilized Granger causality tests to establish directional relationships and impulse response functions and variance decomposition analysis to understand the dynamic interactions and the relative importance of each factor in explaining poverty reduction. Data was standardized using the minimax method and weighted with an entropy method to handle different scales and ensure objectivity.

Datasets

The study utilized provincial panel data from 29 provinces in China spanning from 2010 to 2016. Data sources included various statistical yearbooks and reports from national and regional statistical bureaus, covering agricultural, economic, and land resource information.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Land is not monolithic: The distinction between land as a "resource" (natural attributes) and "capital" (value-generating asset) is crucial for understanding its impact on poverty.
  • Short-term vs. Long-term: Improving land resource endowment offers immediate poverty reduction, while developing land capital has a more sustained, long-term effect.
  • Positive Feedback Loop: Land capital endowment and rural poverty can create a virtuous cycle, where improvements in one reinforce the other, leading to sustainable poverty reduction.
  • The Double-Edged Sword of Capitalization: While land capitalization is beneficial, excessive capitalization can negatively impact land resource endowment, potentially degrading land quality and reducing its productive capacity.
  • Campaign-Style Governance: The rapid poverty reduction effects observed, especially from land resource improvements, might be linked to China's "campaign-style" governance approach, prioritizing quick, visible results.

Key Results

  • Land Resource Endowment: Showed a significant positive effect on short-term poverty reduction.
  • Land Capital Endowment: Demonstrated a more persistent, longer-term poverty reduction effect, amplified by a positive circular relationship with rural poverty.
  • Interaction: Land resource endowment positively influences land capital endowment. However, excessive increases in land capital endowment were found to negatively affect land resource endowment.
  • Granger Causality: Land resource endowment was found to be a Granger-determined reason for rural poverty. Bidirectional causality was observed between rural poverty and land capital endowment, and between land resource endowment and land capital endowment.
  • Impulse Response: Land capital endowment showed a positive response to land resource endowment, but land capitalization also had a negative impact on land resource endowment. Rural poverty responded negatively to both land resource and capital endowment improvements, with the effect of resource endowment being stronger initially.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: The study used macro-level provincial data (2010-2016). The authors acknowledge that provincial data is subject to various factors, and more micro-level data from questionnaires and surveys would be beneficial to improve the scientific validity and characterization of rural poverty.
  • External Interference: The study noted that the negative impact of rural poverty on land capital endowment might be masked by government intervention in poverty alleviation, especially in deeply impoverished regions where the focus is on survival rather than development.
  • Overcapitalization Risk: The potential for excessive land capitalization to harm land resource endowment needs careful policy management.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest collecting more micro data to refine findings and improve the scientific validity of their conclusions.

Summary updated

Abstract

With China facing the challenges of fragmentation, multidimensionality, and the dynamics of relative poverty under the present situation, more attention is being paid to the role of land in poverty alleviation. In order to improve the quality of precision in poverty alleviation, it is urgent to clarify the micromechanisms of precision poverty alleviation methods that utilize land elements. On the basis of panel data from 29 provinces from 2010 to 2016, this research uses a panel vector autoregressive model to empirically analyze the mechanisms of interaction among land resource endowment, land capital endowment, and rural poverty. The research results show that the improvement of land resource endowment has had a relatively prominent effect on short-term poverty reduction, while the improvement of land capital endowment has had a relatively longer-term effect on the improvement of rural poverty. Land capital endowment and rural poverty can constitute a positive, cumulative circular effect, which can play a sustainable role in improving poverty. The increase in land resource endowment has a positive effect on land capital endowment, but excessive increases in land capital endowment were found to have a negative effect on land resource endowment. Therefore, the implementation of land element resource-based and capital-based poverty alleviation policies can distinguish between shorter-term and relatively longer-term goals, enabling a more accurate improvement of the quality of poverty alleviation. At the same time, this approach is more sustainable, since it makes full use of the circular effect constituted by land capital endowment and rural poverty. However, attention should be paid to preventing damages to land resource endowment, which can be caused by the excessive capitalization of land.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022resources,
  author = {Dongsheng Zhang and Ming–Hsuan Yang and Ziyou Wang},
  title = {{Resources or Capital?—The Quality Improvement Mechanism of Precision Poverty Alleviation by Land Elements}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11101874},
}
Figure