Resource Matching in the Supply Chain Based on Environmental Friendliness under a Smart Contract

Jinyu Wei, Zihan Liang, Yaoxi Liu, Xin YangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the environmental impact of manufacturing supply chains by integrating environmental friendliness into a two-sided matching problem for cloud platforms. By leveraging blockchain smart contracts for transparency and a modified Gale-Shapley algorithm incorporating learning theory and dynamic evaluations, they achieve more robust and environmentally conscious resource matching.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The manufacturing industry is a significant contributor to resource consumption and pollution. While efforts are underway to promote green development, a key challenge lies in optimizing supply chain resource allocation to be environmentally friendly. Traditional resource matching often overlooks environmental factors, leading to inefficiencies and potential pollution. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a system that explicitly incorporates environmental friendliness into the matching process, aiming to foster sustainable manufacturing practices.

Methods

The core of this research is a novel two-sided matching model. Key methodological components include:

  • Environmental Friendliness Integration: Environmental friendliness is introduced as a critical criterion in the preference calculation for both demand and supply sides.
  • Learning Theory and Dynamic Evaluation: To account for evolving capabilities and preferences, the authors incorporate learning theory and dynamic evaluation parameters. This allows the system to adapt to changes in service quality and partner evaluations over time.
  • Modified Gale-Shapley (GS) Algorithm: The standard GS algorithm is adapted to handle the dynamic preferences and to distinguish between "positive" and "negative" collaborators. This enhanced GS algorithm aims to improve matching accuracy and promote more constructive partnerships.
  • Blockchain and Smart Contracts: The entire matching process is deployed on a blockchain using smart contracts. This ensures transparency, openness, and security of transactions, automatically executing agreements once predefined conditions are met.

Datasets

The paper uses a simulated dataset for its calculation example. This dataset includes information on suppliers and demand parties, encompassing various attributes like product quality, reputation, environmental friendliness, and service levels. No pre-existing public datasets are mentioned as being used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental Friendliness as a First-Class Citizen: The research demonstrates that explicitly including environmental friendliness as a matching criterion, rather than an afterthought, can significantly influence partnership outcomes.
  • Dynamic Preferences Matter: Incorporating learning theory and dynamic evaluation is crucial for realistic supply chain matching. Preferences aren't static; they evolve with experience, and the model captures this.
  • Blockchain for Trust and Transparency: The use of blockchain and smart contracts is vital for building trust in the matching process, ensuring that agreements are executed as intended and that all parties have visibility into the transaction lifecycle.
  • Distinguishing Good from Bad Partners: The improved GS algorithm's ability to differentiate between positive and negative collaborators is a significant advancement, potentially preventing detrimental partnerships and fostering more productive ones.

Key Results

The study's example analysis highlights several key findings:

  • Successful Environmental Matching: Demand side 10, with high environmental friendliness requirements, was successfully matched with supplier 1 (92% environmental friendliness), even though another supplier might have had a higher overall preference but lower environmental credentials.
  • Reduced Resource Waste: The analysis of specific pairings (e.g., demand side 5 and supply side 7) showed minimal deviation, indicating high-quality pairings with efficient resource utilization.
  • Transparency and Openness: The blockchain implementation ensures that the supply chain production process is open and transparent.
  • Positive Collaboration Encouraged: The appendix's comparison test showed that the improved GS algorithm successfully matched positive demand sides with positive supply sides, enhancing partner enthusiasm and avoiding negative cooperation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The paper notes that the data presented in the study is available on request from the corresponding author but is not publicly available due to platform confidentiality principles. This limits external validation of the model.
  • Simulation-Based: The primary analysis relies on a simulated dataset and a Python implementation. While this demonstrates the model's feasibility, real-world deployment and testing on actual industry data would be beneficial.
  • Complexity of Smart Contracts: While the paper advocates for smart contracts, the practical implementation and maintenance of these contracts for all parties involved might present challenges, especially for less technically savvy participants.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into the upstream and downstream aspects of manufacturing supply chains, emphasizing the need for uniform processes and environmental standards. They also highlight the importance of completing digital supply chain transformation to enable real-time monitoring via blockchain.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to solve the problem of environmental pollution caused by industry through the upgrading and transformation of the supply chain, supply chain resource allocation, and related aspects. Specifically, environmental friendliness is added to the resource-matching problem of the cloud platform supply chain. Additionally, learning theory and dynamic evaluation systems are introduced when creating a preference sequence. The deferred-acceptance algorithm is used for matching. Finally, the automatic matching of blockchain smart contracts ensures the interests of both matching parties. Through the analysis of the example at the end of the study, we found that (1) the deviation table of demand side 5 and supply side 7 in the example shows that the deviation between demand side 5 as demand side and supply side 7 is only 11.55186, and the deviation between supply side 7 as demand side and demand side 5 is only 6.56778, and both sides form a high-quality pairing when matched with other partners. No excessive waste of its resources occurs. (2) Effectively ensure the openness and transparency of the supply chain production process; (3) The impact of environmental factors on enterprises is fully considered. In the analysis of the calculation cases, it can be found that demand side 10 has extremely high requirements for the environmental friendliness of its partners, and although supplier 2 has a very high preference for demand side 10, it is not successfully matched because the environmental friendliness of its own enterprise is not up to the standard, while supplier 1 has an environmental friendliness of up to 92 and is finally matched with Demand side 10; (4) Through the comparison test in the appendix, it can be found that the improved GS algorithm achieves the distinction between positive and negative partners. After multiple rounds of scoring, positive demand side 1, 3 was matched with positive supply side 2, 4, which can strengthen the enthusiasm of both partners and avoid negative cooperation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2023resource,
  author = {Jinyu Wei and Zihan Liang and Yaoxi Liu and Xin Yang},
  title = {{Resource Matching in the Supply Chain Based on Environmental Friendliness under a Smart Contract}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15021505},
}
Figure