Resolution of Respect Robert M. May (1936–2020)
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
Photo 1. Robert May in December 2000. Image credit: Royal Society/Laurence Bulaitis. After a brief return to Australia, May was hired at Princeton to be a colleague of MacArthur and others; but sadly, he became in effect MacArthur’s replacement after the latter’s untimely death. At Princeton, he rose swiftly to prominence as one of the world’s leading ecologists, winning the MacArthur Prize, and publishing his lecture in Ecology as “The Search for Patterns in the Balance of Nature: Advances and Retreats.” Bob stayed at Princeton until 1988; in that year, he left for Oxford to begin his third career, as a Royal Society Professor, and immediately assumed a role of prominence in the British ecological community, eventually becoming President of the British Ecological Society. In 1994, he gave the prestigious Josiah Willard Gibbs Lecture of the American Mathematical Society (the AMS’s most important lecture) and is the only person ever to give both the MacArthur Lecture and the Gibbs Lecture. Having made his mark in two academic fields, Bob’s interest in how science influences policy was given full expression, and his fourth career began, when he was offered the post of Chief Scientific Advisor (GCSA) to the UK Government in 1995. His appointment came at a critical time for the relationship between the science community and policymaking in the UK. The country had just emerged from the trauma of the bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) crisis, during which politicians had at times unwisely declared that the “science said” there was no risk to eating beef. The subsequent many deaths from variant Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease belied this assurance and raised questions of the complicity of science advice and policymakers, and a high-profile public enquiry exposed shortcomings in how the UK Government worked with its science advisors. Bob immediately grasped the importance of this issue and developed a series of guidelines that have since formed the rules of engagement between scientific advisors and policymakers. They stress the importance of advisors summarizing multiple viewpoints as well as being clear about uncertainty, and being open and transparent in what they tell policymakers. The May guidelines remain highly influential and are part of the discussion about how scientific advisors and policymakers work together to address the current COVID-19 pandemic. A second major theme of his time as GCSA was climate change, and his tenure coincided with key developments in this area and the agreements that led up to the Paris Climate Treaty. Bob had good relationships with both prime ministers he worked with, Tony Blair (from the left-of-center Labour Party) and John Major (from the right-of-center Conservative Party). Crucially, he was influential in avoiding the politicization of climate change in the UK that has hampered responses in a number of other countries. Bob, through his network and influence, also helped involve many other colleagues in government advisory roles. It is fair to conjecture that in no other country is sound ecological advice so effectively integrated into the workings of government, and that was to large extent through Bob’s efforts. Bob stepped down as GCSA and became President of the Royal Society, an office where he could again use his phenomenal ability to perceive and execute vital changes in management that led to increased efficacy. In particular, he put his considerable energy into ensuring that more women were elected as Fellows of the Society. Bob’s thinking was always ahead of the frontiers of the field, and his insights helped sculpt British science and its role in shaping society. He received many honors from the UK: a knighthood and life peerage and, a special honor, a member of the Order of Merit. In the time leading up to the financial crisis of 2008–2009, Bob began his fifth career, turning his attention to lessons learned from his system-oriented work in ecology to draw lessons for financial system stability. In 2008, about a half-year before the collapse of Lehman Brothers, Bob, with his former student George Sugihara and one of the authors of this note, wrote a Nature perspective, “Ecology for Bankers,” warning that the overconnectedness of the banking system and the emerging problems with subprime loans should cause regulators to fear for the robustness of the financial system. The full implications of this were worked out after the collapse of the system, when he turned much of his energies to designs for better regulatory systems, working closely with his postdoctoral fellow Nimalan Arinaminpathy and Andrew Haldane, the chief economist of the Bank of England. May viewed his intellectual development from childhood and through his several careers as having been guided by extraordinary mentors, whom he met by being “extraordinarily lucky,” most critically during his years at Sydney Boys High School (1948–1952) and as an undergraduate at Sydney University (1953–1956). Bob tells this story with passion in a 2011 interview with the science journalist Robyn Williams, which was recently rebroadcast on the ABC Science Show, and in a longer transcript of that interview on the website of the Australian Academy of Science (available online).1 In high school, the most influential of Bob’s “uniformly excellent” teachers was Lenny Basser, who taught chemistry “by not teaching us.” Instead, he told stories about past students and challenged his current students to find examination subjects that interested them and write essays on those subjects. Some students hated this approach, but Bob and many others loved it. Basser ended up producing eight future Fellows of the Royal Society, including a Nobel Prize winner and a President of the Royal Society (Bob). May also participated actively in the school’s outstanding debate team, which dominated its league during those years. Perhaps because of his skill in public argumentation, he was urged by many advisors (but not by Basser) to pursue a law degree when he went to university. He ended up choosing chemical engineering instead, but then discovered that he enjoyed and excelled at math and physics, even winning a substantial prize by topping an examination in the honors physics course. This led to a more advanced second-year physics course, and soon, he came to the attention of Professor Harry Messel, who had recently assembled a small but world-class group of faculty in theoretical physics at Sydney (John Blatt, Stuart Butler, and Robbie Schafroth). Bob got to know this group through doing an honors year in physics. Seeing what fun they were having, he decided in the end to become a scientist rather than an engineer. For his Ph.D., supervised by Schafroth, he began working on a model that the Sydney group had devised to explain superconductivity and which turned out to be close but not identical to the correct explanation, which was soon published by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer. Bob finished his thesis on other aspects of the superconductivity problem, and then did a postdoc with Max Krook at Harvard, where he met his future wife Judith Feiner, “the luckiest of all the lucky things in my life.” Bob returned to a faculty position in physics at Sydney, and he and Judith married; and within a few years, he was promoted to a named professorship. He became concerned about environmental issues in the late 1960s, in part through the influence of a distinguished faculty colleague, the ecologist L.C. Birch. Both Birch, who won the ESA’s Eminent Ecologist Award in 1988, and the brilliant physicist Freeman Dyson, who was at the Princeton Institute for Advanced Study when May visited on a sabbatical in 1971, had suggested that Bob talk with MacArthur about whether he should change fields and become a theoretical ecologist. In the end, his second career went far beyond just changing fields. He played a leading role in the development of theory that now underpins modern ecology and provides humanity with indispensable tools to address 21st-century problems ranging from biodiversity loss to epidemic disease to climate change. May’s early work focused on understanding the relationship between the stability of ecosystems (collections of interacting species) and diversity of species. In a 1972 Nature paper, he argued that the stability of an ecosystem as measured by the maintenance of an equilibrium should decrease as species diversity and system complexity increased. This flew in the face of conventional ecological wisdom that large, species-diverse ecosystems would be stable in terms of species abundances and as Bob occasionally remarked, it made it challenging to understand why the world outside his window, or in the Institute Woods, continued to persist. The paper engendered many adherents and dissenters, and much debate, and continues to stimulate theoretical and applied work today. A few years later, in 1976, Bob published what remains his most cited paper, “Simple Mathematical Models with Very Complicated Dynamics,” in which the discipline of ecology was introduced to the possibility of chaotic dynamics in even the simplest of models, ones that were taught in virtually every introductory ecology course. This paper has had transformative influence both within and beyond the discipline. Understanding the relationships between the various perspectives set a major agenda for ecologists over the next 30 to 40 years. Bob put forth his unique perspectives in his path-breaking book Stability and Complexity in Model Ecosystems, an early volume of the series he co-edited for Princeton University Press. It is a book that can still be read productively today, full of insights, eloquence, and a guide for thinking about natural history from a quantitative dynamic perspective. Bob and the British scientist (later Sir) Roy Anderson then followed with a series of fundamental papers and a textbook that has become the bible for those working on the modeling of infectious diseases, extending his influence to another area and bringing it into the sphere of ecological research. Bob also was a regular contributor to Nature’s News and Views for many years, encompassing a broad range of topics in ecology, epidemiology, and conservation biology, and exhibiting biological depth and trenchant wit. May embraced life at Princeton with the zeal and gusto he brought to everything he did. He totally adopted ecology as his discipline, writing a series of keystone papers, and editing the textbook Theoretical Ecology that laid out the many environmental problems that would benefit from a quantitative approach; that book has seen multiple editions, most recently in collaboration with (Dame) Angela McLean. He also took over the co-editorship with the late Henry S. Horn of the influential Princeton University Press Monographs in Population Biology, working closely with Judith in her role as an Editor at the Press. May mentored everyone from undergrads, graduate students, and postdocs to colleagues and members of the administration. He reveled in teaching and co-taught introductory biology, balancing the traditional chemistry, developmental and physiologically based syllabus with evolutionary-ecological theory. He relished working with empiricists, infusing their studies with theory that often shed new light on old problems. At Princeton, he became chair of the University Research Board, where he was most proud of his successful argument to maintain a cap on the rate of overhead added to research grants. This ultimately saved Princeton many millions of research dollars when other less abstemious institutions fell afoul of new rules for research funding and had to repay a significant fraction of the excessive overhead they had accrued. He also took particular delight in the unique 0 parking permit conferred on him for this position, which allowed him to park directly outside his office and next to the tennis courts for his early-morning tennis games with fellow faculty Sam Treiman, Si Kochen, and others naïve enough to underestimate Bob’s competitive nature. Parking his red BMW as close as possible to where he needed to be allowed Bob maximum time for the multiple tasks he undertook every day, from solving problems with an elegant fountain pen on yellow sheets of legal paper, through his continual dictation of a voluminous correspondence. Once he moved to Oxford, his racket indulgence expanded obsessively to include the archaic sport of “real tennis.” In 1974, Bob was invited to visit Silwood Park in England by (later Sir) Richard Southwood, then chair of Imperial College’s Zoology & Applied Entomology Department. Silwood Park is Imperial’s country campus 30 miles outside London, not far from Windsor. Southwood had recruited a series of young ecologists who, with colleagues in other UK universities (York and Oxford in particular), were taking a much more quantitative approach to population ecology. Bob found the intellectual atmosphere at Silwood greatly to his liking, and he and Judith bought a house nearby where he based himself each summer from the mid-70s until his permanent move to the UK. His mastery of the issues in ecology allowed him to engage with people working on very different topics, while his insightfulness and background in physics allowed him to make significant advances in each of these areas that transformed the quantitative study of ecology. For example, he and (later CBE) Michael Hassell developed new models for insect exploiter-victim systems, and he and (later Sir) Gordon Conway developed more rigorous approaches to integrated pest management. There were other collaborations hosted at Silwood, for example with the York University scientists (later Sir) John Lawton, who went on to become the first Director of the famous NERC Centre for Population Biology at Silwood, and later head of NERC (the Natural Environment Research Council), and (later Sir) John Beddington, who became UK Government Chief Scientific Advisor in 2013–2018. Bob also developed a very close friendship at Oxford with (later Lord) John Krebs, who also became Director of NERC as well as the First Chairman of the British Food Standards Agency. Bob’s influence again was apparent in the expanding role for ecologists in advising science policy. It was during these visits that Bob met Roy Anderson, and they discussed examining parasites as a special case of exploiter–victim relationships. The collaboration quickly developed, and within a couple of years, they had developed the core of a major body of theory that is central to our understanding of the dynamics of infectious diseases and their control. The culmination of this was the massive volume on Infectious Diseases of Humans (1991) written in a month at the Rockefeller Center in Bellagio, Italy. The work was written at a time when HIV was emerging as the etiological agent of AIDS, and they spent a considerable amount of time developing models that provided key understanding for how HIV spread and might be controlled. The productivity of Bob and his collaborators during his summer visits to Silwood Park was in part due to its unique esprit at the time. Bouts of intense intellectual activity with Imperial faculty and the many students and visitors also present were punctuated by highly competitive sport, from real tennis to croquet and table tennis, with Bob always at the fore. Taking Bob on intellectually or physically was not for the faint-hearted! Bob also initiated an annual four-day hiking trip that began in North Wales and the English Lake District, but then expanded to other British mountains, and then from the mid-90s to the Alps and other European mountain ranges. The participants varied from year to year, but for four decades Bob led a diverse group of ecologists and friends up vertiginous mountain tracks, often in driving rain, talking simultaneously of science, science politics, and anything else. No one ever died, but as the years went by Bob curated an increasing number of anecdotes about near-misses and disasters avoided, only made more perilous in lore by the passage of time. Bob was, as already mentioned, President of the British Ecological Society and was also the recipient of the Balzan Prize, Blue Planet Prize, and the Swedish Academy’s Crafoord Prize. He chose to share his good fortune, endowing a fellowship at Princeton to help support a rising theoretically oriented graduate student in evolutionary ecology. The British Ecological Society each year also bestows the Methods in Ecology and Evolution (MEE) Robert May Early Career Researcher Award upon a young researcher. Bob was also awarded the Royal Society’s Copley Medal, one of its oldest and most prestigious awards, given annually for outstanding achievements in research in any branch of science, and was an International Member of a number of national academies including the U.S. National Academy of Sciences. Bob continued to retain a Visiting Professorship at Princeton, where he would visit Princeton colleagues and friends and lecture on almost an annual basis until his declining health made that impossible; he received an honorary degree along with President Bill Clinton at Princeton’s 250th anniversary in 1996. Until the end, he treasured his old and new colleagues alike and was steadfastly loyal in supporting them. He is survived by his wife, Judith, and their daughter, Nome. This article is an expansion of an article by some of the same authors that originally appeared on the Princeton University website. Google Scholar Page: https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=ScXat-4AAAAJ&hl=en
BibTeX
@article{dobson2020resolution,
author = {Andrew Dobson and H. C. J. Godfray and Simon A. Levin and Stephen W. Pacala and Daniel I. Rubenstein and Jon Seger},
title = {{Resolution of Respect Robert M. May (1936–2020)}},
journal = {Bulletin},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1002/bes2.1769},
}Loading related content...