Resilient Containment Control of Heterogeneous Multiagent Systems Against Unbounded Attacks on Sensors and Actuators

Shan Zuo, Yichao Wang, Mohamadamin Rajabinezhad, Yi ZhangIEEE Trans. Control. Netw. Syst 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of maintaining control and coordination in multi-agent systems (MAS) when faced with sophisticated, unbounded, and correlated attacks on both sensors and actuators. The authors propose a novel distributed control framework that guarantees system stability and ensures agents remain within a defined boundary around the leaders' states, even under these severe adversarial conditions. This work is crucial for the security and reliability of MAS in real-world applications like power grids and autonomous systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern multi-agent systems (MAS) rely heavily on distributed control, where agents share information over communication networks to achieve collective goals. However, these networks are vulnerable to malicious attacks. Existing fault-tolerant control strategies often assume that sensor faults are bounded and uncorrelated, which is unrealistic in the face of intelligent attackers. These attackers can launch coordinated, unbounded attacks that can bypass conventional detection methods, destabilize the system, and compromise its performance. Furthermore, attackers might gain access to actuators, manipulating control inputs. This paper addresses the gap in existing research by developing a control strategy that is resilient to simultaneously unbounded and correlated sensor attacks and unbounded actuator attacks in heterogeneous MAS. This is a more practical and challenging scenario than previously studied.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution is a novel distributed attack-resilient control framework. This framework incorporates:

  • Dynamic Compensators (Observers): These are used to estimate the states of the leaders, providing a reference for the followers.
  • Local Control Protocols: These are designed to compute the control inputs for each follower. A key aspect is the use of a measurable error term ($v_i(t)$) which incorporates the estimated sensor attack, rather than relying solely on direct state measurements. This is a departure from traditional methods that assume intact sensor data.
  • State Observers: These estimate the true states of the followers, compensating for the effects of attacks.
  • Sensor Attack Observers: These specifically estimate the injected sensor attack signals.
  • Actuator Attack Estimator: A novel adaptive tuning law is used to estimate the unbounded actuator attack signals.

The framework is designed to be distributed, meaning each agent only needs local information and information from its neighbors. The stability and containment performance are rigorously proven using Lyapunov-based techniques, analyzing the closed-loop system dynamics under these complex attack scenarios.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a simulated numerical example for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unbounded and Correlated Attacks are a Serious Threat: The paper highlights that assuming bounded or uncorrelated faults is insufficient for real-world security. Intelligent attackers can exploit system configurations to launch coordinated attacks that are difficult to detect.
  • Rethinking Sensor Measurement Use: Instead of relying on direct, potentially compromised sensor measurements, the proposed framework uses a measurable error term that accounts for estimated sensor attacks. This is a crucial step in achieving resilience.
  • Unified Approach for Sensor and Actuator Attacks: The paper uniquely addresses both sensor and actuator attacks simultaneously, which is a significant step towards practical security solutions for MAS.
  • Distributed Resilience is Achievable: The proposed framework demonstrates that even with complex, unbounded attacks, a distributed control architecture can maintain system stability and achieve the desired containment objective.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates through theoretical proofs and a numerical example that the proposed distributed attack-resilient control framework guarantees:

  • System Stability: The closed-loop dynamical system remains stable.
  • Uniformly Ultimately Bounded (UUB) Containment Performance: The trajectories of the follower agents converge to a small neighborhood around the dynamic convex hull spanned by the leader agents. This means the followers stay within a controlled region defined by the leaders.

The numerical simulation shows that while conventional control methods fail and lead to diverging follower trajectories under unbounded sensor and actuator attacks, the proposed resilient method successfully keeps the followers within the desired containment region.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption 5 (Bounded Derivatives): The current framework assumes that the derivatives of the attack signals are bounded. The authors suggest that relaxing this assumption to handle generally unknown and unbounded sensor and actuator attacks would be a valuable direction for future research.
  • Graph Topology Information: While the paper notes that the coupling gain $c$ can be chosen sufficiently large without detailed graph information (as long as Assumption 1 holds), it also mentions alternative methods for adaptively designing $c$ in a fully distributed manner, implying that explicit graph topology information might be a limitation in some scenarios.
  • Practical Implementation: While the framework is distributed, real-world implementation would involve challenges related to communication delays, sensor noise, and computational limitations, which are not explicitly addressed.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zuo2024resilient,
  author = {Shan Zuo and Yichao Wang and Mohamadamin Rajabinezhad and Yi Zhang},
  title = {{Resilient Containment Control of Heterogeneous Multiagent Systems Against Unbounded Attacks on Sensors and Actuators}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Control. Netw. Syst},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tcns.2023.3338772},
}
Figure